WOW! Holy Pizza! We were in town with some family this past week and went to hyena Pizza and had the best experience! When you can't decide, hot chick, and Smoak ring pizzas were really, really good! All the pizzas are 10 inch and cooked to perfection, coming out of a woodfired oven gives them such great flavor! I would highly recommend strawberry salad, Bavarian pretzel steaks with a beer cheese! They have a great selection of beer and wine and this one stop pizza joint absolutely knock it out of the park! 💥💥💥💥💥💯
Kelly Johnson
Love this restaurant!! The food is incredible!!! Cute place to eat at. Great location!
Gregory Martinez
Best chicken wings in town
Sarah M.
I enjoyed the pizza and live entertainment! They have an indoor seating and two nice outdoor areas. Really liked the BBQ chicken pizza! They're also an inclusive employer...so you know the owner is a decent person.
Zachary Ruth
This is some pretty good pizza, it’s a little personal pizza which is a little pricey but tastes quite well, would definitely eat here again.
Daniel Ruth
This place was great, went here with my family and the service is great it’s fast and the menu names are funny, if you’re near come here it’s definitely worth a stop by.
janon jones
What an absolute gem! From the moment we walked into Pizza Hyena, we were greeted with warmth and smiles from every staff member — from the host to the manager to our amazing server. The vibe here is fun, welcoming, and full of personality.
The wings were bursting with flavor — perfectly crispy outside, juicy inside, and seasoned just right. But the real standout? The cheesy breadsticks. These weren’t your average breadsticks — they were exceptionally artisan, soft with the perfect cheese pull, and clearly made with care.
What truly made our visit unforgettable was how the server danced with my daughter, making her day (and mine)! That kind of energy and joy is rare and deeply appreciated.
We didn’t just have a meal — we had a deliciously good time. Can’t wait to come back!
Summer Cochran
We stopped here whilst honey mooning in Myrtle (specifically surfside beach). We loved it here we came a couple times. The BEST pizza and atmosphere. We still talk about it to family and friends. I still use my Pizza Hyena koozie! Can't wait until we get to go back, this will be our first stop.
Doug Deeds
We've avoided PH in the past because of the live music being too loud for conversation, even outside the restaurant. But we finally tried it since no one was playing.
My wife had the Prosciutto Your Eye Out and I had the When You Can't Decide (in photo). Both were good, but not much flavour. Given the high rating online I was expecting more
gerald Robinson
Very nice little place, right by the pier. Can recommend the Delicious pretzel and cheese appetizer and great pizzas!
Apps and pizza were great. Good local beer selection.
Kari Alvaro
We just ate here for the first time, it was AMAZING! Super awesome & friendly staff, food was fast, fresh and delicious! we will be back for sure!
Meghan Mace Spencer
First time at Pizza Hyena in Garden City and it was AMAZING! 10/10!
Everything we tried was so good — hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The service was awesome too — super quick and everyone was so nice. We’ll definitely be back!
Allison Coore
First time, last time.
Attempted to eat here yesterday (2PM Saturday). We were sat at an outside table quicker than told. GREAT! Waited 20+ minutes with no acknowledgement or eye contact from the server working the tables around ours. Assumed surely he can’t possibly be our server. Finally spoke with the hostess to let her know we were still waiting for someone to take our drink orders. Meanwhile the server continues to be in and out working the tables arounds us still not taking any acknowledgment of us or eye contact. We kept thinking after he closes their check he’ll be by. 10 minutes later or so as hostess was outside sitting another table, she asked if we were still waiting. We gave about another 5 minutes for her to get someone else to us before we left.
Christina
The absolute best wood fire pizza! Think and so tasty. Wait staff were so polite and nice although they were super busy! 2nd time there and is a must when we visit!
WOW! Holy Pizza! We were in town with some family this past week and went to hyena Pizza and had the best experience! When you can't decide, hot chick, and Smoak ring pizzas were really, really good! All the pizzas are 10 inch and cooked to perfection, coming out of a woodfired oven gives them such great flavor! I would highly recommend strawberry salad, Bavarian pretzel steaks with a beer cheese! They have a great selection of beer and wine and this one stop pizza joint absolutely knock it out of the park! 💥💥💥💥💥💯
Love this restaurant!! The food is incredible!!! Cute place to eat at. Great location!
Best chicken wings in town
I enjoyed the pizza and live entertainment! They have an indoor seating and two nice outdoor areas. Really liked the BBQ chicken pizza! They're also an inclusive employer...so you know the owner is a decent person.
This is some pretty good pizza, it’s a little personal pizza which is a little pricey but tastes quite well, would definitely eat here again.
This place was great, went here with my family and the service is great it’s fast and the menu names are funny, if you’re near come here it’s definitely worth a stop by.
What an absolute gem! From the moment we walked into Pizza Hyena, we were greeted with warmth and smiles from every staff member — from the host to the manager to our amazing server. The vibe here is fun, welcoming, and full of personality.
The wings were bursting with flavor — perfectly crispy outside, juicy inside, and seasoned just right. But the real standout? The cheesy breadsticks. These weren’t your average breadsticks — they were exceptionally artisan, soft with the perfect cheese pull, and clearly made with care.
What truly made our visit unforgettable was how the server danced with my daughter, making her day (and mine)! That kind of energy and joy is rare and deeply appreciated.
We didn’t just have a meal — we had a deliciously good time. Can’t wait to come back!
We stopped here whilst honey mooning in Myrtle (specifically surfside beach). We loved it here we came a couple times. The BEST pizza and atmosphere. We still talk about it to family and friends. I still use my Pizza Hyena koozie! Can't wait until we get to go back, this will be our first stop.
We've avoided PH in the past because of the live music being too loud for conversation, even outside the restaurant. But we finally tried it since no one was playing.
My wife had the Prosciutto Your Eye Out and I had the When You Can't Decide (in photo). Both were good, but not much flavour. Given the high rating online I was expecting more
Very nice little place, right by the pier. Can recommend the Delicious pretzel and cheese appetizer and great pizzas!
Restaurantji Recommends
Apps and pizza were great. Good local beer selection.
We just ate here for the first time, it was AMAZING! Super awesome & friendly staff, food was fast, fresh and delicious! we will be back for sure!
First time at Pizza Hyena in Garden City and it was AMAZING! 10/10! Everything we tried was so good — hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. The service was awesome too — super quick and everyone was so nice. We’ll definitely be back!
First time, last time. Attempted to eat here yesterday (2PM Saturday). We were sat at an outside table quicker than told. GREAT! Waited 20+ minutes with no acknowledgement or eye contact from the server working the tables around ours. Assumed surely he can’t possibly be our server. Finally spoke with the hostess to let her know we were still waiting for someone to take our drink orders. Meanwhile the server continues to be in and out working the tables arounds us still not taking any acknowledgment of us or eye contact. We kept thinking after he closes their check he’ll be by. 10 minutes later or so as hostess was outside sitting another table, she asked if we were still waiting. We gave about another 5 minutes for her to get someone else to us before we left.
The absolute best wood fire pizza! Think and so tasty. Wait staff were so polite and nice although they were super busy! 2nd time there and is a must when we visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...