Whitlock Bay Supper Club
HC 3 Box 76A, Gettysburg
(605) 765-9196
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We are originally from the Midwest and grew up eating walleye. We were traveling through Gettysburg and thought we would give the Whitlock Bay Supper Club a try. The panko crusted walleye was the best walleye meal we have ever had! It was seasoned and sauteed to perfection! The salad bar and bread with the salad bar was wonderful. The owner / chef and staff were great.
Ate there twice. 1st night food and drinks were good. 2nd night food was just ok. Had asked for medium raw burger and it wasn't. It was done done. Also had put rubin balls on the seafood platter instead of scallops.
You wouldn’t expect to find a restaurant out in the middle of nowhere like this one. It’s a cute little place and all of the servers are friendly. We were camping next door and walked over. The regular clientele was very friendly too. The prices were good for a nice meal.
