Benky’s Cream & Sugar
111 Winter St, Keystone
(605) 666-4131
Customers' Favorites
Ice Cream 1 Scoop
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We are always looking for great ice cream shops on our vacations and this one did not disappoint! There were 18 flavors of hard ice cream plus other ice cream treats on the menu. I was excited to see bubblegum ice cream as this is rare to find! Delicious overall and the prices were not too expensive.
The ice cream is good-- not fancy but definitely better than I've come to expect in the tourist zone. Sundaes are huge and really sweet. They're attractively made and are plenty to share. Cute atmosphere with some candy for sale, also. Felt a bit classier and more polished than most of the other shops nearby.
Nice variety of ice cream and salt water taffies. The ice cream sandwiches looked really good. Had the Gold Rush sundae. It was sugary and delicious, can’t go wrong with those ingredients. However all the Butterfinger bits were at the bottom and the spoons aren’t particularly strong so scraping it and trying to stir it in was a little difficult. Could have been mixed a tad better. Also might consider using some lids on the sundaes as the toppings make it very full and ours...
You May Also Like
Red Garter Saloon - 124 Winter St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Cocktail Bar, Music Venues, Venues & Event Spaces, Bar
Jane's Boardwalk Pizza - 160 Winter St
![]()
Pizza, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Gluten-Free
The Front Porch Restaurant and Bar - 115 Swanzey St
![]()
American, Vegetarian