Gary’s donuts are delicious, made from scratch and are quite the delight. Current price is $2.36/donut regardless of type. The reason for less than 5 stars is we were grossly overcharged for our purchase. Not sure if it was because we were unfamiliar faces or purely an accidental. We purchased 6 donuts and were charged $27.40. The woman who rang us up was the same who grabbed the donuts and had clearly been working there a while as when a new customer came in she knew their order by face so can only conjecture it was an intentional overcharge charge. We unfortunately declined a receipt but the more I thought about it the more $4+ per donut just felt way too expensive for a small donut shop. The reason for 4 stars instead of less for the gross over charge is we returned to the shop and were refunded the overcharge without issue but it should not have happened. Even a new employee should have thought that $27 for 6 donuts didn’t sound right. Summary: great tasting donuts but get/check your receipt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Brad Wilkins
Good old fashioned rolls made fresh daily.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut
Amanda Klawonn
Doughnuts are always great! Service depends on who is working and how their day has gone.
Jim Cornell
Stop and bought a couple of pastries
Cassandra Benson
They were some of the freshest tastiest dounuts I have had in a while. Great small town bakery feel! Wonderful, had to try them after hearing so many good reviews from the locals.
Bakery style dinner rolls were great, but unfortunately not a fan of the donuts or muffins.
Deb West
Very friendly and helpful service. Good food
Nevaeh Rain
I was worried some of it was going to be too sugary, but I was astounded at how good it was! And not too pricey either! I'm definitely going to have to start getting up earlier ?
Gary’s donuts are delicious, made from scratch and are quite the delight. Current price is $2.36/donut regardless of type. The reason for less than 5 stars is we were grossly overcharged for our purchase. Not sure if it was because we were unfamiliar faces or purely an accidental. We purchased 6 donuts and were charged $27.40. The woman who rang us up was the same who grabbed the donuts and had clearly been working there a while as when a new customer came in she knew their order by face so can only conjecture it was an intentional overcharge charge. We unfortunately declined a receipt but the more I thought about it the more $4+ per donut just felt way too expensive for a small donut shop. The reason for 4 stars instead of less for the gross over charge is we returned to the shop and were refunded the overcharge without issue but it should not have happened. Even a new employee should have thought that $27 for 6 donuts didn’t sound right. Summary: great tasting donuts but get/check your receipt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Good old fashioned rolls made fresh daily.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut
Doughnuts are always great! Service depends on who is working and how their day has gone.
Stop and bought a couple of pastries
They were some of the freshest tastiest dounuts I have had in a while. Great small town bakery feel! Wonderful, had to try them after hearing so many good reviews from the locals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut
Best long johns in the state.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best donuts around !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best donuts around
Great donuts. Great service. Great people.
Warm friendly. consistently !!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Best fresh pastries in Madison.
Very good Donuts. Worrh the trip.
Bakery style dinner rolls were great, but unfortunately not a fan of the donuts or muffins.
Very friendly and helpful service. Good food
I was worried some of it was going to be too sugary, but I was astounded at how good it was! And not too pricey either! I'm definitely going to have to start getting up earlier ?
Loading...