Prairie Pizza

404 5th St, Murdo
(605) 669-7492

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Holly T

Answered the phone promptly, was able to order over the phone. They told me when it would be ready, and it was ready when they said it would be. I got the cheese pizza 16 inch and was pleasantly surprised it had cinnamon in the crust, which went nicely with the icing. Thanks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Iwona Hennig

It was the worst experience. The customer service was horrible, the lady who served us was aweful. She treated us without respect. We felt very unwelcome. When we told her our feedback she started laughing and kept asking us where we were from. It was very racist of her. We came with our four kids and they felt very uncomfortable to be there. We have been in many other restaurants but have never felt treated so poorly. We ordered peperonni cheese pizzas but the the pizzas were with cinnamon but nobody mentioned anything about it. We do not mind cinnamon but we wanted to be informed about it because one of my kids is allergic to cinnamon. If you decide to go please be aware of it. The wait time was 45 minutes to be served but nobody was there.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rusty Hardy

Nice looking place rude people 1.5 hours before they close decided to only allow take outs and no sitting in the building

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

James Norvell

was coming in from Minnesota stopped by the pizza is delicious. The service is great. We called ahead grabbed the order since we’re on the road. Pizza was hot

Katie Walsh-Kallstrom

Picked up to go pizza (ranch hand I think it was called?), had no clue about the cinnamon crust and it was such a fun surprise!! Excellent pizza, will be our new stop when traveling through that direction!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shane Gochenour

Fantastic pizza i really enjoyed the cinnamon crust very unique i will definitely stop in again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane Gaudio

Wow, the pizza was great. The crust was a delicious surprise.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hunter

Great pizza and garlic bread. Loved the unique spin on cinnamon crust with icing. Our crust could have used a bit more cinnamon but was still good. Service was a bit questionable as the lady was a bit snappy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Heather

I was on the road - noticed there are very few places to get some food. Appreciate the friendly staff and the Parmesan bread was beyond delicious. Highly recommend.

Amanda Antognini

Very kind staff, very interesting surroundings with nice taxidermy animals! The food is very good but the pizza is VERYYY greasy. I recommend coming here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Rachel Winchel

We were there about 4 years ago driving thru to Yellowstone and we stopped and got the cinnamon roll pizza crust. Sitting here 4 years later still talking about that PIZZA and planning our next trip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie Wood

We came in about an hour after they opened on a Sunday. They are the only option in town other than Subway on a Sunday. There were 4 tables with families happily eating their meals inside. When we ordered, the young woman taking our order was very nice. As one of the tables dining in left, my family went to sit at the table. The older woman mumbled something about take out that I didn’t quite hear. As I looked at other tables dining in I figured she must have just asked if my family was taking out. Then I heard her tell the next three customers that they were carry out only because they were too busy. So we were forced to go outside to eat in 20 MPH winds. Strangely there were 0 cars in the lot when we left. The pizza was tasty but strange with the cinnamon crust. My advice? If you really want pizza expect to get it to go. Advice for the establishment? Maybe try understanding you are in a service industry and you will have busy times but that does not require to close the four little tables you have indoors. Nothing says I don’t want customers like telling them they aren’t welcome.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Claire Wood

The lady, who I believe is the owner, was very unwelcoming and rude. We walked in an hour after opening and there were three families sitting down and eating in the four table restaurant. We and a family behind us were immediately told it was takeout only in a very rude voice with absolutely no explanation. If there was no one sitting in there, totally understandable, but it didn’t make sense. Later on when asked again the same lady (again with no nicety used) declared that they were too busy. Lets be clear, the parking lot was empty, a family behind us was the last family to order as we sat outside in 40 mph winds to eat food that was just fine. I believe that was their “rush” time, but if you can’t handle an hour rush during dinner time you may not be in the right business. And you should still treat your customers with kindness, which was not happening here. The pizza was good, just.. maybe not the cinnamon on the pizza. It’s a great concept, it being in the crust, but you could taste the cinnamon in the pizza, not great. When you are one of the two places in this area open for dinner, maybe you shouldn’t be rude to all the customers that come in? I wouldn’t recommend, just get subway instead, at least there you could eat inside.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Kayla Swearingen

The place was quick and efficient. The pizza was incredible. The cinnamon sugar crust was so unique and unlike anything I've ever had. So glad we got to try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Casey Pesch

5 year old said “it’s the best pizza in the world” so that’s what we’re going with.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...