Godfather's Pizza

1300 9th Ave SE, Watertown
(605) 753-1411

Recent Reviews

Paul Schell

Bad selection of pizza. Pickle. Pineapple. Wont eat here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Scott Peters

Every time I'm in town visiting my dad got to get some Godfather's

Matt Nygaard

The pizza was dry and had very little flavor. The chicken was extremely dry. I could not eat the chicken at all. The salad bar was ok, so that is about all I could eat.The service was good. The kids behind the counter were doing the best they could and were promptly taking dirty plates from our table. This was the only part of my experience that kept me from only giving this 1 star.I will not be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Janelle Hein

I really like Godfathers pizza. Great place to get awesome food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Hall

Very nice place to eat with friends and family

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Large, Pepperoni Sausage and Green Olive Pizza, Super Combo Pizza, Soda, Garlic Bread, Taco Pizza, Potato Salad

LadyMarian52

They offer a buffet with a variety of pizza, but there's SO much tomato sauce on the pizza's your just not quite sure what you are ating.

Samuel Baggett

Before today, I had never ordered a full pizza from a buffet to take home with me after eating. But this was also my first time eating at Godfather's Pizza. The pizza here was by far the best buffet pizza I've ever had.The staff was friendly, helpful, and efficient, and I had a full assortment of hot pizza options with each return trip to the buffet counter. I'll certainly be bringing back friends and family to this joint.Parking: Large parking lotWheelchair accessibility: There didn't seem to be any obstacles for wheelchair accessibility, from the accessible tables, low buffet counters, and drink fountains.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Large, All

Dan Merchant

Best fried chicken ever!!!

Alex O.

Tyler Urban is a grimey piece of s**** and his holier than thou attitude is very laughable.

Lindsey

The taco pizza was very good! Very generous with the toppings. Shredded Cheese was melted on it, fresh lettuce, lots of extra taco sauce (packets).

B MArt

The Taco Pizza is a must try; the Chicken is Hot & Juicy, and they offer a good buffet, including Salad Bar, cleanliness was adequate & the Tables seem to be wiped down frequently. External entrance lets you go right in if you don't want to go into the Walk Mall.

Cory Zietz

I was very happy with the service and the food.we ordered a pepperoni pizza and wings and potato wedges. The potato wedges were awesome. The other stuff was good. I was a little disappointed cause I was expecting a buffet. The 2 people working did a very good job thanks.

Amy Culbertson

This is one of the best places to eat. The service is excellent to the point of they will make sure all your special requests are honored, and they don't make you feel like you are an inconvenience. The food was perfect and I truly appreciate it! There is no Godfathers near us and when we are craving Godfathers, we have no problem driving the 40 miles to go get it from here because it is so worth it. Thank you staff for doing such a wonderful job!

Kristy Hayes

Very friendly staff, food was done fast and was delicious.

David Fromke

Great staff and the Buffet is worth the money it was delicious

Load More