Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Beautiful place love the staff

It’s sad I would write this review as I used to love this place. I have been coming here over 10 years. Place has gone downhill. Our start with the front desk greeters, zero urgency . There was hardly anyone there and plenty of open tables. The waiter came to get our drink order 20 minutes after our arrival. Our beer was cold and probably the better part of our visit. We ordered a couple of appetizers were good. The problem came with the food . The boneless wings I ordered had probably been under a heatlamp so long the sauce dried on them and tasted dry and overcooked . The pizza I ordered was undercooked that the cheese on top had not even melted . The waiter was nice but lacked any urgency to get your order. Disappointed in this place as I remember doing many get togethers with friends and family here. The restroom also needs attention , the smell of urine leaks out of it when the door opens . I hope restaurant leadership sees this and remedies these shortcomings and makes the OC the great place it was .

Used to be one of the better spots in the area. Now it seems management is so bad, employees seem like they don't want to be there. Parking lot mostly empty, barely half the tables full, 8 servers on the floor and telling people 30 min wait. Just go somewhere else until this place gets it together.

The chicken strips way too salty. The pizza personal
Pan was ok. The waiter was great

We ordered the Thai Pie, which is our favorite, but the first one was overcooked. It was so dry. I spoke with manager Libby, she was very apologetic & prepared a fresh pizza & it was so good!!! Great service & food!!

Food was top-notch! Server was amazing 👏 huge shout out to her for doing such a fantastic job on her second day on the job!!

Great place friendly service.

Food was good and the staff was fun. The family went here after a funeral. The waiter Tommy went above and beyond. No matter what was happening he rolled with it when he came to the table.

We got sat immediately which was nice. However, we only sat at our booth for 1 minute due to a terrible sewer smell. It literally smelled like we were sitting on the floor of a bathroom. Gross!

We've eaten at this location several times and have had no problems. I love the food, but their sweet tea is exceptionally awesome! Italian nachos are what is in the picture. They're pretty awesome! We ordered individual pizzas but decided to take them to go. My wife always orders their cauliflower crust.

Yo idk why made my calzone tonight but it was 🔥🔥🔥🔥👍👍

Great upfront staff
Burnt pizza, just dough
Pasta was water bowl

Everything went great until the rain came by

Came in on 4/26/25, very poor service from start to finish. Had to beg for silverware, napkins, and refills. Wings were tough, out of spaghetti pie(which is what we drove from KY for). Then had to wait for over 15 minutes for server to check us out. Disappointing!

Our party of 4 waited 5 mins to be recognized and seated. Once seated, it was 30 minutes before we got our drinks and 15 mins later we got our food. Food was decent, place was clean but the cost doesn't match the product.