A mostly empty pizza shop on a Friday night should have been my first clue. The pizza was mediocre to put it charitably. Plus it was undercooked.
The staff were mildly surly and seemed to wish they were anywhere else.
The interior and atmosphere is charmingly dated and dingy, which would make this a cool throwback pizza joint if the food was any good. My hunch is this place is barely staying afloat, probably only from the alcohol sales margins.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
April Grant
First and last time trying here. All our pizzas were undercooked, floppy, and tasted off. Only 1 Price per item and 1 size listed on menu turns out to be for smalls. Ranch had zero flavor. Questions about menu were met with rude attitude. Strange and not pleasant experience. Mystery green seasoning on each pizza not spread out and didn’t taste good as well. Even the kids didn’t finish even 1 slice saying it tasted bad. That was a first.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jonathan Munoz
Ordered online. Server there had an attitude like I was wrong for ordering food. Pizza was ok at best. Deserts were frozen and the tiramisu frozen was chalky. Not a place I will be revisiting.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Samantha
Love. Bella’s is always amazing and delicious. Our go-to and they are so nice 😊
Gabe Abernathy
Meat lovers was point!
Phillip Bryce Clark
Our go-to spot for $1 wing night every Tuesday! The wings are always on point, but the real star is their pizza—the dough is hands down the best in town. Great local atmosphere, friendly staff, and a perfect place to support a hometown favorite. If you haven’t been yet, you’re missing out!
william miller
Take out and dine in....both wonderful experiences! Food and staff are over the top. Eat there 3-4 times a month.
M McGee
My favorite pizza in Collierville/ Memphis -area.
Capt Kirk
Not much to look at, but the pizza was amazing! Tried the Bella Special, which has no red sauce, but came with a good quality cheese, spinach, tomatoes, and a few dollops of Ricotta cheese and a delicious thin crust. Would definitely try again when in Collierville.
Pizza was burnt but pretty good. The dingey, old interior was as much of a turn off as the waitress' attitude. And don't even think about a refill.
Eva Hutton
Very tasty pizza and an awesome Caesar salad. They also allow call ahead seating so you can sit down and start eating right away. Service was great- such a friendly group!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua L. Gann
Dropped in due to some reviews. One read “ I’m from NY and this is the real deal”
No pies on display but I said why not?? I had 2 slices of cheese. Far from NY pizza, but still decent. Slices were made fresh. Just didn’t have the crisp on the undercarriage. Reminded me of a Tostino’s.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ja Waring
Amazing place. Definitely the best pizza in collierville, and one of the best pizzas in Memphis if not the best. Their pasta is also top notch. The staff is super friendly and will make you feel like family in no time. If you have taste buds then you will become a regular and the staff will remember you and invite you in every time. Don't be put off by the four parking spaces out front, there's also parking in the back as well as a patio and a rear entrance.
Wonderful staff, great food and great pasta!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A mostly empty pizza shop on a Friday night should have been my first clue. The pizza was mediocre to put it charitably. Plus it was undercooked.
The staff were mildly surly and seemed to wish they were anywhere else.
The interior and atmosphere is charmingly dated and dingy, which would make this a cool throwback pizza joint if the food was any good. My hunch is this place is barely staying afloat, probably only from the alcohol sales margins.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
First and last time trying here. All our pizzas were undercooked, floppy, and tasted off. Only 1 Price per item and 1 size listed on menu turns out to be for smalls. Ranch had zero flavor. Questions about menu were met with rude attitude. Strange and not pleasant experience. Mystery green seasoning on each pizza not spread out and didn’t taste good as well. Even the kids didn’t finish even 1 slice saying it tasted bad. That was a first.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered online. Server there had an attitude like I was wrong for ordering food. Pizza was ok at best. Deserts were frozen and the tiramisu frozen was chalky. Not a place I will be revisiting.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Love. Bella’s is always amazing and delicious. Our go-to and they are so nice 😊
Meat lovers was point!
Our go-to spot for $1 wing night every Tuesday! The wings are always on point, but the real star is their pizza—the dough is hands down the best in town. Great local atmosphere, friendly staff, and a perfect place to support a hometown favorite. If you haven’t been yet, you’re missing out!
Take out and dine in....both wonderful experiences! Food and staff are over the top. Eat there 3-4 times a month.
My favorite pizza in Collierville/ Memphis -area.
Not much to look at, but the pizza was amazing! Tried the Bella Special, which has no red sauce, but came with a good quality cheese, spinach, tomatoes, and a few dollops of Ricotta cheese and a delicious thin crust. Would definitely try again when in Collierville.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was burnt but pretty good. The dingey, old interior was as much of a turn off as the waitress' attitude. And don't even think about a refill.
Very tasty pizza and an awesome Caesar salad. They also allow call ahead seating so you can sit down and start eating right away. Service was great- such a friendly group!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dropped in due to some reviews. One read “ I’m from NY and this is the real deal”
No pies on display but I said why not?? I had 2 slices of cheese. Far from NY pizza, but still decent. Slices were made fresh. Just didn’t have the crisp on the undercarriage. Reminded me of a Tostino’s.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Amazing place. Definitely the best pizza in collierville, and one of the best pizzas in Memphis if not the best. Their pasta is also top notch. The staff is super friendly and will make you feel like family in no time. If you have taste buds then you will become a regular and the staff will remember you and invite you in every time. Don't be put off by the four parking spaces out front, there's also parking in the back as well as a patio and a rear entrance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Supreme Calzone, Lasagna, Garlic Knots, Tiramisu, Lasagne Bolognese, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pesto Pizza
Our server there was totally awesome... she worked hard to give us great service...13 ppl close to closing time...food was out quickly and tasted gret
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bella's White Pizza, Wings
Loading...