Papa Johns Pizza

5205 Bobby Hicks Hwy, Gray
(423) 477-0990

Recent Reviews

Jeremy Bowman

Found a purple hair in my pizza. Employees are always hateful as hell and takes forever.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Spencer Robinson

My wife placed order on line and was given a time of 20 min. When she arrived she was told 20 more min. After 30 min. It hadn't been put in oven, I hope to see her soon??

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Casey Bacon

The staff has always been friendly to me at this location but the service for estimating pick up/delivery time is awful. It doesn’t matter if I call in my pick up order or do it on the app. I get a 10 min window…usually 20-30 min after ordering to pick up my order. Tonight I was told 22-33 minutes. I arrived 40 minutes after placing the order to give them a buffer and attempt to avoid the inconvenience but my pizza still hadn’t been put in the oven. It took 55 min for my order to be ready. A week ago same issue and I had to cancel it. Take A.I. out of it and let the stores go back to doing it themselves!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Jesse Koch

My pregnant wife has done 7 “Happy Dances” around the kitchen! Spot on Papa John’s way to go. Killer food and service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Cornett

Rude, understaffed and 1 hour and a half late

Jesús Ramírez

Same thing everyone else is saying… this is the only Papa John’s location that has an extremely long wait time. The other locations are not like that, if it were up to me I would be firing a lot of people in this location.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

David Cousin

Very good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

VisionedTrash91

absolutely ridiculous… ordered online at 8… it’s now 11:02 and still no pizza. I should’ve just cancelled the order, but I didn’t want to. I usually always choose papa johns over any pizza, but this is ridiculous. Making your customers wait this long, then not having the right amount of staff for the demand of the area is awful. someone needs to fix this because clearly this is an ongoing issue.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dominick Clark

I ordered a pizza and was told it would take 20 min max … went to pick it up and they said they needed another 30 min … when I cancelled they were extremely rude to me about doing so … they lost a customer … I’ll get Little Caesars or Pizza Hut

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Norton

Tried to order a pizza and they said it would be a hour and a half or longer on a Tuesday at 6:30 pm. I'll never go there again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

David Thompson

Pizza was hot. Check out fast and convenient.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Papadia with Philly Steak and Pepperoni

Ron P.

The pizza has improved since management changed at this location. The pizza seem to have a fresher taste and better quality than a few years ago. The ambiance and atmosphere of the store seems to be better working as a team seems to be better. The cleanliness of the store has improved keep up the improvement and more stars will come.

Selena

my husband placed an online order around 5:30 for us to pick up at 6:45, i arrived at 6:30 and it was SLAMMED i’m talking not one parking place left, people lined up on the inside, and drivers coming in and out. so i knew not to try to get my order early and just waited the 15 minutes. i walk in the store at 6:46 and let them know i was there to pickup an online order and had the order by 6:48 and was walking out the door, the pizza had just came out of the oven and was probably one of the best pizzas i’ve had from papa john’s. i just wanted to sing these employees praises as i don’t think that gets done very often. like i said they were absolutely slammed and i still got great service! i was greeted when i walked in and even though the poor drivers were working themselves to death when i left they still held the door open for me. 10/10 best experience i’ve had. great job!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gaga Traywick

Carry out is awesome, super fresh each time.

Larry Bernethy

Ordered online. Downtown show when delivery til after I paid. $22.00 for a thin crust pepperoni pizza. Ordered at 5:20. Got it at 8:45. Plus the pizza was not good. I was worried they wouldn’t refund my money if I had called to cancel. I could have gone to any other pizza store in the area and had a pizza within 30 minutes. Won’t do it with Papa John’s in Gray TN again. Bad Bad Bad.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More