Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine

By far the best pizza in town. The Big John ( new Yorker) is big enough to feed my family of five. John the owner is very kind and always makes you feel appreciated and important ❤️. By far my favorite restaurant. Thank you 🙏🏽😊 for being awesome and caring. It's rare, the cannolis are to die for. It's a must try if you ask me. So if you are looking for quality service and great authentic Italian cuisine plain Jane's is the place to go.

The first spinach calzone we got was excellent, full of spinach and cheese. We couldn't wait to get another one. The one we just got last night was more like a cheese calzone that they accidentally got some spinach on. The crust wasn't nearly as flavorful. By the time I got home I didn't feel like going back. Probably not going to try again.

We gave them a second chance. We had been getting chicken bacon ranch pizzas half with no onion. and they were phenomenal. Ordered the same tonight. Then, we got handed an onion pizza light onion on half and it was terrible. I didn’t want heavy onion. I wrote on the order “one half with no onion please”…. The food is not consistent at all. We’re done.

The establishment was clean, service was good. Calzone and desrts were great. The Philly cheese sub was terrible, DRY and no sauce whatsoever (nor any mention that it's a sauce less sub) only a few (literally) pieces of thin slice onion and bell pepper. Although the bread of the sub was good.

Our order was on time and very good.They never disappoint.

Always good

Good food

The service is TERRIBLE!!!! We payed $45 for two people to eat supper. Waited 45 minutes on our food which was disgusting and something I could have made at home. The staff was rude and I stood at the window trying to get salad dressing for 10 minutes before deciding just to go home. We were there for a hour and a half for nasty food. I never leave reviews, but I would highly recommend not wasting your time or money.

First time trying Plain Jane's Italian Cuisine! Very nice people and really great food!

Delicious pizza!!!! Must try!!

Walked in, waited 8 minutes with no one else in line just to be talked to like a dog. Was handed a receipt with a 25% tip recommended for nothing. Paid a cashier and had to serve myself. Still haven't figured out what the tip was for. Food is a frozen entrée that was heated in a microwave or at least that's how it looked and tasted. Won't be back.

We ordered pizza here for the first time. I have to be honest, when I went to pick up my order, I was a little concerned to see that teenagers seemed to be running the place. However, they were very friendly and our pizzas were really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Parking isn't the best, but everything else is amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jane's Stromboli, 10 Cheese Bread Sticks, Garlic Bread, Baked Spaghetti or Baked Ziti in Marinara Sauce

I got spaghetti, a calzone, and tiramisu. The food was excellent and the staff are SUPER nice. If I could I would give them 10 stars but they limit it to 5 :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baked Spaghetti or Baked Ziti in Marinara Sauce

I’ve ate here quite a few times, everytime ordering something different and I absolutely love everything I’ve tried so far. Wings will be next and it will be the true test for me as I’m so picky with my wings! Love this place so far!