Best pizza we have had anywhere! So delicious. Yummy! Great food and service. Nice covered area to eat outside too with picnic tables. .
Lane Stevenson
Feels a bit pricey but the pepperoni slices were good - pretty thin with a nice ratio of ingredients. The large pepperoni are nice - as far as my pizza eating has led me, Pinky Ring and Five Points are the best in/around Nashville. The two aren't comparable at all, totally different styles of pizza. You could eat both back to back and be happy without feeling like you've had too much pizza.
Aaron N
Tried the pizza, and honestly, it's pretty average. The restaurant is cute and the service was good but there are better places for pizza. The reason I ranked it a three stars though, was because when buying a whole pizza, they still charge you the the by the slice rate. I've never seen a pizza shop do this. What this means is that if you get a whole pizza there, it's going to be expensive. Bottom line, I think the place is fine to grab a slice to hang out, but I wouldn't get a pizza to go.
Jocelyn Phillips
Delicious pizza. It’s a bit pricey but I’m so happy Madison has this delicious addition. Can’t wait to try the pickle pizza next!
Matt Adams
So lucky to have the best pizza in Nashville in Madison. Long live Pinky Ring!
Ian Sprague Haines
I got a half cheese half mushroom. The pizza was cooked very well but needed extra sauce, and cheese.
Scott Takac
This is authentic New York City pizza, right down to the price. It cost me $38 with gratuity for a large, one-topping pizza, the same amount an identical pizza would have cost in the Big Apple. There was a slight problem: I was in Madison, TN. I really wanted to love this place but cannot. Light on cheese, light on toppings, through the roof on price. I will not be back. The value isn’t there.
Chase L
Best pizza I’ve had in town yet. Super friendly staff, too! Will be back soon.
Phillip Alford
This establishment claims to be a NY-style pizza place. However, they do not consistently sell slices. I entered the restaurant and saw a small section for daily slices (mostly basic flavors but a few specialties). When I reached the register, the worker said they were all out of slices. It was only 4PM!! Why aren’t they constantly making pizza to cut into slices? Or why isn’t it marked off the whiteboard menu? Don’t go unless you want to spend $30 plus on a pizza.
James Bratton
Stepping into this pizza joint feels like you've walked onto the set of a Wes Anderson film—nostalgic, meticulously simple, and quietly whimsical. The vibe is effortlessly cool, underscored by a soundtrack of mellow surf-rock that gently convinces you to linger a bit longer.
Staff members deliver easy-going charm, chatting you up as though you're regulars swapping indie album recommendations. But let’s talk pizza: the dough here is a chewy, yeast-driven masterpiece, boasting that perfectly airy bite pizza lovers dream of. The menu itself feels like an underground mixtape—curiously unique, with creative toppings and combinations that make you rethink everything you knew about pies.
This isn't just another slice spot; it’s a culinary playlist you'll want to keep on repeat.
The best in the area for so many reasons. The hot pickle slice is the best I've ever had
Shannon Gantert
Best pizza around. Highly recommend
Super Stone
Let me tell you..... Swing by and get some of this great pie! Nice, hot, tasty, and big slices! Super Friendly!
Kristina Decker
I had a slize of pepperoni and a slice of five cheese for lunch during the week. There are very few good NY style pizza places in Nashville - i think this is the closest I've had to the pizza I miss from NY. The pepperoni especially was so good!! The staff was super friendly as well. I'll definitely be back.
Jason Hendricks
The vibe here was amazing! Service was wonderful, and the slices put me in a better mood! Thanks! 👍
Best pizza we have had anywhere! So delicious. Yummy! Great food and service. Nice covered area to eat outside too with picnic tables. .
Feels a bit pricey but the pepperoni slices were good - pretty thin with a nice ratio of ingredients. The large pepperoni are nice - as far as my pizza eating has led me, Pinky Ring and Five Points are the best in/around Nashville. The two aren't comparable at all, totally different styles of pizza. You could eat both back to back and be happy without feeling like you've had too much pizza.
Tried the pizza, and honestly, it's pretty average. The restaurant is cute and the service was good but there are better places for pizza. The reason I ranked it a three stars though, was because when buying a whole pizza, they still charge you the the by the slice rate. I've never seen a pizza shop do this. What this means is that if you get a whole pizza there, it's going to be expensive. Bottom line, I think the place is fine to grab a slice to hang out, but I wouldn't get a pizza to go.
Delicious pizza. It’s a bit pricey but I’m so happy Madison has this delicious addition. Can’t wait to try the pickle pizza next!
So lucky to have the best pizza in Nashville in Madison. Long live Pinky Ring!
I got a half cheese half mushroom. The pizza was cooked very well but needed extra sauce, and cheese.
This is authentic New York City pizza, right down to the price. It cost me $38 with gratuity for a large, one-topping pizza, the same amount an identical pizza would have cost in the Big Apple. There was a slight problem: I was in Madison, TN. I really wanted to love this place but cannot. Light on cheese, light on toppings, through the roof on price. I will not be back. The value isn’t there.
Best pizza I’ve had in town yet. Super friendly staff, too! Will be back soon.
This establishment claims to be a NY-style pizza place. However, they do not consistently sell slices. I entered the restaurant and saw a small section for daily slices (mostly basic flavors but a few specialties). When I reached the register, the worker said they were all out of slices. It was only 4PM!! Why aren’t they constantly making pizza to cut into slices? Or why isn’t it marked off the whiteboard menu? Don’t go unless you want to spend $30 plus on a pizza.
Stepping into this pizza joint feels like you've walked onto the set of a Wes Anderson film—nostalgic, meticulously simple, and quietly whimsical. The vibe is effortlessly cool, underscored by a soundtrack of mellow surf-rock that gently convinces you to linger a bit longer.
Staff members deliver easy-going charm, chatting you up as though you're regulars swapping indie album recommendations. But let’s talk pizza: the dough here is a chewy, yeast-driven masterpiece, boasting that perfectly airy bite pizza lovers dream of. The menu itself feels like an underground mixtape—curiously unique, with creative toppings and combinations that make you rethink everything you knew about pies.
This isn't just another slice spot; it’s a culinary playlist you'll want to keep on repeat.
Restaurantji Recommends
The best in the area for so many reasons. The hot pickle slice is the best I've ever had
Best pizza around. Highly recommend
Let me tell you..... Swing by and get some of this great pie! Nice, hot, tasty, and big slices! Super Friendly!
I had a slize of pepperoni and a slice of five cheese for lunch during the week. There are very few good NY style pizza places in Nashville - i think this is the closest I've had to the pizza I miss from NY. The pepperoni especially was so good!! The staff was super friendly as well. I'll definitely be back.
The vibe here was amazing! Service was wonderful, and the slices put me in a better mood! Thanks! 👍
Loading...