Great pizza and great service. We got there 15 minutes before they opened and he let us right in. We had our pizza and we're sitting down eating before they were even scheduled to open. The pizza was delicious.
Eddie de Pool
I took my daughter here for a daddy-daughter date night and found this pizza to be really good. Customer service was absolutely top-notch and they were incredibly friendly and kind and very much helpful in every way.I wish I remember the name of the lady that helped us because she was incredibly helpful and kind.The atmosphere in this place is definitely cool and I found it to have a very inviting vibe. I like that they brought the stand out to put the pizza on as it definitely made it easy for us to be able to eat pizza without it having an entire pizza on the actual table considering the size that we ordered.Probably the only thing I was a little disappointed with was the garlic bread. The price seemed fair but it definitely was a bit underwhelming in contrast to what I normally expect when getting something like cheesy bread or garlic knots but I definitely think it was really good.
glam girl
I’ve tried to give this place a multiple chances. Ordered multiple times and every time I have received a pizza with no sauce. Drenched in grease and zero flavor. As a native New Yorker this place always disappoints.
Matt Campbell
Place was clean with nice vibes but the pie was lackluster and failed to reach the appeal of authentic New York Pizza! I would give this place another try when. I wouldn't go put of my way to try a slice!
Julie B
I wanted to love this pizza! I ordered a vegetarian pizza. It looked nothing like the picture on the menu! It was missing ingredients for sure! I also ordered a pepperoni pizza. Both pizzas were lacking in sauce and flavor. The wings were meeehhh….. The cannolis though…..Yum! It was $100 ill spent.
Bekah H
Kids begged me for pizza after target and I happened to look over and see this place on the way out.Pizza was awesome, the cook and the cashier guy were so nice & friendly. We will definitely stop by again and tell our friends & fam about this place.
richard bell
The very worst pizza ever that I wasted 20 bucks for . Anyone who says or think otherwise has no clue and probably liar . Pizza hut looks like 5 star compared to this place . If there was a zero star that would be my impression . how this place stay in business I have no clue . Worse than BAD food . Cheap ingredients and did not think it possible to slice peperonie that thin . Cheese is like glue . About a total of maybe 1 tablespoon sauce if can call it sauce . Sprinkled with some sort fake pepper . I think could put a slice of this between couple 2x4s and would replace liquid nail .
lindsay gonzalez
Me and my boyfriend came here for the frist time sunday and was blown away how the only guy up there was doing everything by his self. Every chance he got, he would check on us to see if everything is ok the food was nice and crispy. Very tasty, and a super clean environment definitely coming back every chance we get!!!!
Angela Carter
This place is hit or miss. One night you'll get a delicious pizza cooked just right. Another night, you'll get a burnt chewy mess. We are pizza lovers and it would be great to make this our go to spot, but when you spend $75 on pizzas and they are delivered burnt...that's just bad business to let food leave your restaurant that way.
Michael Powers
Phenomomal service, the young men working simply cared about the quality of the experience of every patron entering the pizzeria.Garlic knots and pepperoni pinwheels were very good. Toppings on our pizza were very fresh and of high quality. I was born and raised in NYC so I have a high standard for pizza and this place met that standard.Alot of these poor reviews seem to be from when the restaurant first opened. Seems like they've been figuring things out since then and are now hitting their stride.
Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni & asked if they would make a fresh pie since the 2 slices on the shelf looked tired & rumpled after prolonged exposure to the elements and the long ago loss of their pie-mates. The response from the back was "I ain't gonna make a pepperoni right now". I'm afraid making a fresh pie may have interfered with the staff's loud conversation & cavorting? Who knows? #typicalmtjulietservice So, it was all fun & games until the food poisoning symptoms (to not be too descriptive) hit after midnight. And thus bringing 2 stars to 1. #I'mnotgoingback. EDIT 5/3/22 The owner reached out to me and was very apologetic about the entire situation and resolved to keep it from happening again.
Kathy Tack
We ate here with some friends last night. The pizza was great. I was really impressed with the guys working there. They seemed to take a lot of pride in their work and made sure we were happy with everything.
Lauren Didier
NY pizzeria had a friendly and attentive staff, it was clean and cozy inside and most importantly… wow the food was incredible. Pizza thin and crispy with perfect crust, the salads were excellent and the wings were crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside with awesome sauce. Will definitely be going back!
Virginia M
Three and a half. The pizza might be the best in town. But in the last order my husband went and picked up, the knots were raw in the middle. And there was only six in one order and five in the other order. Well try it again because my husband lives the pizza so much but....
Jennifer Sanchez
After a day of shopping I saw this conveniently located pizzeria and am so glad I went inside. The pizza was delicious and the prices are decent. Highly recommend if you’d just like a slice or two.
Great pizza and great service. We got there 15 minutes before they opened and he let us right in. We had our pizza and we're sitting down eating before they were even scheduled to open. The pizza was delicious.
I took my daughter here for a daddy-daughter date night and found this pizza to be really good. Customer service was absolutely top-notch and they were incredibly friendly and kind and very much helpful in every way.I wish I remember the name of the lady that helped us because she was incredibly helpful and kind.The atmosphere in this place is definitely cool and I found it to have a very inviting vibe. I like that they brought the stand out to put the pizza on as it definitely made it easy for us to be able to eat pizza without it having an entire pizza on the actual table considering the size that we ordered.Probably the only thing I was a little disappointed with was the garlic bread. The price seemed fair but it definitely was a bit underwhelming in contrast to what I normally expect when getting something like cheesy bread or garlic knots but I definitely think it was really good.
I’ve tried to give this place a multiple chances. Ordered multiple times and every time I have received a pizza with no sauce. Drenched in grease and zero flavor. As a native New Yorker this place always disappoints.
Place was clean with nice vibes but the pie was lackluster and failed to reach the appeal of authentic New York Pizza! I would give this place another try when. I wouldn't go put of my way to try a slice!
I wanted to love this pizza! I ordered a vegetarian pizza. It looked nothing like the picture on the menu! It was missing ingredients for sure! I also ordered a pepperoni pizza. Both pizzas were lacking in sauce and flavor. The wings were meeehhh….. The cannolis though…..Yum! It was $100 ill spent.
Kids begged me for pizza after target and I happened to look over and see this place on the way out.Pizza was awesome, the cook and the cashier guy were so nice & friendly. We will definitely stop by again and tell our friends & fam about this place.
The very worst pizza ever that I wasted 20 bucks for . Anyone who says or think otherwise has no clue and probably liar . Pizza hut looks like 5 star compared to this place . If there was a zero star that would be my impression . how this place stay in business I have no clue . Worse than BAD food . Cheap ingredients and did not think it possible to slice peperonie that thin . Cheese is like glue . About a total of maybe 1 tablespoon sauce if can call it sauce . Sprinkled with some sort fake pepper . I think could put a slice of this between couple 2x4s and would replace liquid nail .
Me and my boyfriend came here for the frist time sunday and was blown away how the only guy up there was doing everything by his self. Every chance he got, he would check on us to see if everything is ok the food was nice and crispy. Very tasty, and a super clean environment definitely coming back every chance we get!!!!
This place is hit or miss. One night you'll get a delicious pizza cooked just right. Another night, you'll get a burnt chewy mess. We are pizza lovers and it would be great to make this our go to spot, but when you spend $75 on pizzas and they are delivered burnt...that's just bad business to let food leave your restaurant that way.
Phenomomal service, the young men working simply cared about the quality of the experience of every patron entering the pizzeria.Garlic knots and pepperoni pinwheels were very good. Toppings on our pizza were very fresh and of high quality. I was born and raised in NYC so I have a high standard for pizza and this place met that standard.Alot of these poor reviews seem to be from when the restaurant first opened. Seems like they've been figuring things out since then and are now hitting their stride.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni & asked if they would make a fresh pie since the 2 slices on the shelf looked tired & rumpled after prolonged exposure to the elements and the long ago loss of their pie-mates. The response from the back was "I ain't gonna make a pepperoni right now". I'm afraid making a fresh pie may have interfered with the staff's loud conversation & cavorting? Who knows? #typicalmtjulietservice So, it was all fun & games until the food poisoning symptoms (to not be too descriptive) hit after midnight. And thus bringing 2 stars to 1. #I'mnotgoingback. EDIT 5/3/22 The owner reached out to me and was very apologetic about the entire situation and resolved to keep it from happening again.
We ate here with some friends last night. The pizza was great. I was really impressed with the guys working there. They seemed to take a lot of pride in their work and made sure we were happy with everything.
NY pizzeria had a friendly and attentive staff, it was clean and cozy inside and most importantly… wow the food was incredible. Pizza thin and crispy with perfect crust, the salads were excellent and the wings were crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside with awesome sauce. Will definitely be going back!
Three and a half. The pizza might be the best in town. But in the last order my husband went and picked up, the knots were raw in the middle. And there was only six in one order and five in the other order. Well try it again because my husband lives the pizza so much but....
After a day of shopping I saw this conveniently located pizzeria and am so glad I went inside. The pizza was delicious and the prices are decent. Highly recommend if you’d just like a slice or two.
Loading...