Ordered two coconut cream pies for a birthday party and no one at the party could eat more than a few bites of their slice. The middle was so thick and very sweet. It was closer to the consistency of chess pie. There was hardly no coconut flavor. They were awful! I had a lot of leftovers and ended throwing them in trash because even the biggest sweet lovers could not eat it. I spent $27 each because it was a special occasion. i wish I would of bought the Marie Callender's from Kroger that I had bought before but since it was a special party I went to a pie shop.
Lisa Edelstein
I received a coupon for a free pie on my birthday as I do every year but when I went to use it the person working said they weren’t honoring them because they couldn’t afford it. Then why send it? I’m the future when faced with where to go get dessert who do you think I’ll choose? The cake place who gave me a free cake and wished me happy birthday with a smile OR the pie place that sent me a coupon but refused to honor it. I tried to contact the business first before leaving a review but got no response.
Julia Beasley
Every pie I’ve tried here is delicious! As someone who is usually in a hurry, this place is my go to stop to get pies before family events! They are always a hit
Michael Martin
Nice people but not my idea of a quality product. I know that reviews are totally subjective, but this is my experience. The coconut cream pie was cloyingly sweet, too heavy-handed use of coconut extract and the crust was basically a butter cookie, not a pastry in the least. I was really hoping for a top notch pie bakery in Murfreesboro but this wasn't it.
Mandy Johnson
Stopped in to see what it's all about and ended up with 4 small pies for $19 (+tax).The place was clean, the staff was friendly, and the price was reasonable to me.The packaging is a lot. It's in an aluminum tin that's suspended in essentially a bubble of plastic. If you follow me, you know I try to avoid that type of thing, but I get it. They're to protect the pie.We got 1 pumpkin, 1 peanut butter chocolate, 1 chocolate cream, and 1 buttermilk.My partner loved his PB one. The chocolate cream was really good with a chocolate crust ?The pumpkin was lackluster to me. No punch of pumpkin; the crust and little sugary pumpkin on top overwhelmed the filling flavor.We haven't had the buttermilk yet, but it has the same crust as the pumpkin, so I am assuming it'll be similar.In sum: I liked it, but not enough to seek it out again and risk the barley for it. If you like sugar cookie style crust, though, this is your place!
mae9183
No longer accept bday coupons, even though they email the birthday coupon out. They should at least send an email to rescind the coupon. Will never shop here again. It’s the principle. Made a special trip to get my birthday pie.
Ashley M.
We got a small key lime pie and a small chocolate cream pie. Cute little shop but the pies were in the fridge to long I think cause the chocolate cream pie was more like chocolate fudge pie which wasn't that great. The key lime pie my husband says was really tart compared to others he has had. Glad we tried this place out but we won't be back. Price for the size is descent.
Thomas B.
I go here about once a month or so and buy a small pie. I signed up for some email club through this company. I received a buy one get one free pie coupon. I go by there to use it, and an told they no longer accept these. Supposedly they told corporate to stop sending them out or something. I walked out and said it was bs, because it is. I don't want to hear excuses, and don't care about internal issues with the company. If you can't honor a coupon, you shouldn't have them to begin with. It's really crappy to treat your customers like that. I spent the gas to go by there, and get told they don't take them. I will never go to any of your stores ever again!
Trey
Many Pies to choose from and they are absolutely delicious. A little pricer than picking up a pie at a grocery store, but it is freshly made with a “made from scratch” type of taste. Once inside, there is this farmhouse Industrial atmosphere with the opportunity to buy decorations and items such as Coffee Mugs if desired.
Jennifer Painter
My daughter and I were traveling home from visiting family and wanted to get a pie in honor of my husband's birthday. This was his first birthday since he passed away 10 months ago and we wanted to do something to help honor his memory. He LOVED peanut butter pie and often had it for his birthday. We called several places while on the road but no one had one except the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. The lady on the phone was extremely nice, friendly, and helpful. They had a pie and held it for us until we could get there to get it. Thank you for helping us to honor him in this way. The pie traveled another 4 hours before we could eat it. It had gotten soft since we couldn't keep it chilled, but it was delicious. We chilled it overnight and it tasted freshly made. Thank you for such a wonderful pie!!!! I highly recommend this place and will buy from them again if I have an opportunity to.
Very good! Their strawberry pie is very good as well as the coconut cream. I will be back!!!
Danys C.
Buttermilk pies is a very cute store! They also have such cute looking pies. I think the pies are really good but I wish the crust had a little more flavor! Over all very great place to go for a little sweet treat!
Mary W.
If you are a pie lover, then this is the place to try. My first time visiting this business but I will return when in the area. The associate was friendly and helpful with suggestions. We purchased the 4-pie deal so we could try different flavors-not a bad choice!! The decor was very pleasing and the store was super clean. Great experience.
Steven Boehm
Really cool little pie shop we stumbled upon. The guy working was really nice and explained all the pies. I grabbed a small coconut cream and a chocolate pie. Both were really good. A little too much on the SWEET side so if you are overly sensitive to sweets, I would skip the pies. I wish they had a dairy free option so my wife could of tasted. Overall, I felt they were fair priced, and tasty. I would come back and try another one if I found myself in the area.
Dan Paden
Always has great pies... that's what we come to get!Staff is warm and helpful.
Ordered two coconut cream pies for a birthday party and no one at the party could eat more than a few bites of their slice. The middle was so thick and very sweet. It was closer to the consistency of chess pie. There was hardly no coconut flavor. They were awful! I had a lot of leftovers and ended throwing them in trash because even the biggest sweet lovers could not eat it. I spent $27 each because it was a special occasion. i wish I would of bought the Marie Callender's from Kroger that I had bought before but since it was a special party I went to a pie shop.
I received a coupon for a free pie on my birthday as I do every year but when I went to use it the person working said they weren’t honoring them because they couldn’t afford it. Then why send it? I’m the future when faced with where to go get dessert who do you think I’ll choose? The cake place who gave me a free cake and wished me happy birthday with a smile OR the pie place that sent me a coupon but refused to honor it. I tried to contact the business first before leaving a review but got no response.
Every pie I’ve tried here is delicious! As someone who is usually in a hurry, this place is my go to stop to get pies before family events! They are always a hit
Nice people but not my idea of a quality product. I know that reviews are totally subjective, but this is my experience. The coconut cream pie was cloyingly sweet, too heavy-handed use of coconut extract and the crust was basically a butter cookie, not a pastry in the least. I was really hoping for a top notch pie bakery in Murfreesboro but this wasn't it.
Stopped in to see what it's all about and ended up with 4 small pies for $19 (+tax).The place was clean, the staff was friendly, and the price was reasonable to me.The packaging is a lot. It's in an aluminum tin that's suspended in essentially a bubble of plastic. If you follow me, you know I try to avoid that type of thing, but I get it. They're to protect the pie.We got 1 pumpkin, 1 peanut butter chocolate, 1 chocolate cream, and 1 buttermilk.My partner loved his PB one. The chocolate cream was really good with a chocolate crust ?The pumpkin was lackluster to me. No punch of pumpkin; the crust and little sugary pumpkin on top overwhelmed the filling flavor.We haven't had the buttermilk yet, but it has the same crust as the pumpkin, so I am assuming it'll be similar.In sum: I liked it, but not enough to seek it out again and risk the barley for it. If you like sugar cookie style crust, though, this is your place!
No longer accept bday coupons, even though they email the birthday coupon out. They should at least send an email to rescind the coupon. Will never shop here again. It’s the principle. Made a special trip to get my birthday pie.
We got a small key lime pie and a small chocolate cream pie. Cute little shop but the pies were in the fridge to long I think cause the chocolate cream pie was more like chocolate fudge pie which wasn't that great. The key lime pie my husband says was really tart compared to others he has had. Glad we tried this place out but we won't be back. Price for the size is descent.
I go here about once a month or so and buy a small pie. I signed up for some email club through this company. I received a buy one get one free pie coupon. I go by there to use it, and an told they no longer accept these. Supposedly they told corporate to stop sending them out or something. I walked out and said it was bs, because it is. I don't want to hear excuses, and don't care about internal issues with the company. If you can't honor a coupon, you shouldn't have them to begin with. It's really crappy to treat your customers like that. I spent the gas to go by there, and get told they don't take them. I will never go to any of your stores ever again!
Many Pies to choose from and they are absolutely delicious. A little pricer than picking up a pie at a grocery store, but it is freshly made with a “made from scratch” type of taste. Once inside, there is this farmhouse Industrial atmosphere with the opportunity to buy decorations and items such as Coffee Mugs if desired.
My daughter and I were traveling home from visiting family and wanted to get a pie in honor of my husband's birthday. This was his first birthday since he passed away 10 months ago and we wanted to do something to help honor his memory. He LOVED peanut butter pie and often had it for his birthday. We called several places while on the road but no one had one except the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. The lady on the phone was extremely nice, friendly, and helpful. They had a pie and held it for us until we could get there to get it. Thank you for helping us to honor him in this way. The pie traveled another 4 hours before we could eat it. It had gotten soft since we couldn't keep it chilled, but it was delicious. We chilled it overnight and it tasted freshly made. Thank you for such a wonderful pie!!!! I highly recommend this place and will buy from them again if I have an opportunity to.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good! Their strawberry pie is very good as well as the coconut cream. I will be back!!!
Buttermilk pies is a very cute store! They also have such cute looking pies. I think the pies are really good but I wish the crust had a little more flavor! Over all very great place to go for a little sweet treat!
If you are a pie lover, then this is the place to try. My first time visiting this business but I will return when in the area. The associate was friendly and helpful with suggestions. We purchased the 4-pie deal so we could try different flavors-not a bad choice!! The decor was very pleasing and the store was super clean. Great experience.
Really cool little pie shop we stumbled upon. The guy working was really nice and explained all the pies. I grabbed a small coconut cream and a chocolate pie. Both were really good. A little too much on the SWEET side so if you are overly sensitive to sweets, I would skip the pies. I wish they had a dairy free option so my wife could of tasted. Overall, I felt they were fair priced, and tasty. I would come back and try another one if I found myself in the area.
Always has great pies... that's what we come to get!Staff is warm and helpful.