This pizza was so good! We got the meat lovers, and it was worth every penny. The 16" is a small, which everywhere else is like a large. I go to several pizza places all over so I have high standards. It's my fav food, after all. One slice was filling for me and normally I can eat 3 slices of a regular hand-tossed pizza elsewhere. We also got the garlic knots and they were tasty. The knots were pretty big as well. Gone before I could get a pic. They were running a special, so we got those free. They had MANY bottled drink options and also fountain drinks. It is a very small cozy place. Wish it was a little bigger, but we were the only ones inside the restaurant at the time. They were very helpful. When we were almost finished, they asked us how everything was. Great! Will be back again.
TRAVIS De Villers
Friendly food was good however a slice of pizza and a drink is 5$ but if you get 2 slices it's 15$Parking: It's on the court square very limited parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wendy McDonough
Best pizza anywhere! Don't forget to try the subs!!Vegetarian options: Just ask and they will accomplish almost anything!Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating to dietary restrictions!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, Small Calzone, Pepperoni Roll, Meat Lovers 16in, 1 Topping Slice, Calzone, Tony Soprano, Don Corleone, Chicken Alfredo 20 In
Amelia Woolard
Great food, service was friendly but not highly knowledgeable. Restaurant is small - better for takeout.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers 16in, Calzone
Sam Bates
This place has a really neat, unique atmosphere. The food is delicious and the staff are really nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon Bott
With over 10 orders under my belt, the only certainty at this pizzeria seems to be its inconsistency. Whether it's a delightful surprise or a letdown, the element of unpredictability adds a unique twist to each dining experience. The fluctuating quality might leave you questioning the hefty bill, especially on the off days when the pizza falls short. While the ambiance and occasional culinary triumphs can justify the cost, be prepared for a hit-or-miss affair that might leave your wallet feeling lighter than your satisfaction.My recent order from this pizzeria left much to be desired. Unfortunately, the pizza was not just inconsistent; it was downright inedible due to being extremely undercooked. The dough resembled a raw state more than a crisp crust, and the toppings lacked the flavor that a properly cooked pizza should offer. It's a disappointing turn that raises serious concerns about the kitchen's attention to detail and overall quality control.Every visit is a gamble on what the pizza gods have in store for your taste buds. I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Heather Adams
Easily the best pizza in Paris, TN. Giant pizzas for a fair price make this place a go-to for a busy weeknight, no dishes meal. Love the little extras that come with the specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers 16in
Remarkable Relaxation
I lived near New Haven CT for a few years and New York and CT had some of the best pizza Ive ever had. I was in the area and saw this restaurant and decided to give it a try. When I tell you, I haven’t had pizza like that in ten years (since I was last in NYC) believe it! It was incredible! I am so happy to have found this amazing restaurant and will be doing extra reps each week to make up for the extra calories Im bound to be consuming now!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lou
We ordered 7 pizzas for a party we were having. Every pizza was perfect, Thank you! Customer service is top notch also. Give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janice Brown
They had a bunch of pizza and desert to choose from. It was almost overwhelming the amount of pizza and desert choices there were. The young lady behind the counter was very sweet.Vegetarian options: The veggie pizzaKid-friendliness: They had video games for the kids to play
The white pizza and the calzone were absolutely incredible and reminded me of home! I've yet to find a great calzone outside of NY until today.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Calzone, White Pie
Kayla Miller
I ordered my pizza at 6:11. It was to be done in 30 minutes. I showed up at 6:45 for my pizza. It was not done. 10 minutes later they said it would still be another 7 minutes.So we waited.Ten minutes later they inform my husband they dropped our pizza on accident so it will be another 10 minutes17 minutes later we finally got our pizza... AFTER WAITING THERE FOR 35 MINUTES AFTER THE TIME OF PICK UP. We were expecting some sort of discount or coupon but an apology was all.Probably will never be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pamela B.
We heard so much about this place. So we came from Huntingdon to paris to try it. When we got there. We were so disappointed. No seating. Take outs only. I asked the girl there if it was take out only and she told me. If I could fund a chair we could sit. Other then that it was take out. I looked around only 2 tables. And no chairs. So we left
Jennifer Young
Recently, my family fell on hard times due to a medical emergency I had, and I’m still suffering from.We were blessed with 2 large pizzas at no cost to us one particular night when we were struggling to feed our kids and here’s how:??????????????????????????????Nonni’s N.Y. Pizzeria has an angel pizza tree.What it is all about is that customers in our community can pre-pay for pizzas and/or meal combos. Whatever has been pre-paid is written on a card that’s in the shape of a pizza slice and hung on the tree.ANYONE CAN GO INTO THE PIZZERIA AND TAKE THEIR NEED OFF OF THE TREE AND TURN IT IN AND ORDER WITH NO QUESTIONS ASKED.Anyone that knows Chef Andy and his wife knows that is just a typical beautiful thing that they would do.They are a wonderful asset to our community and we are so lucky they chose to call Henry Co home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JMBthe1
Excellent food, portions are crazy huge, order a large and you better have a truck to bring it home! Great people and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Calzone, Pepperoni Roll, Meat Pizza,
This pizza was so good! We got the meat lovers, and it was worth every penny. The 16" is a small, which everywhere else is like a large. I go to several pizza places all over so I have high standards. It's my fav food, after all. One slice was filling for me and normally I can eat 3 slices of a regular hand-tossed pizza elsewhere. We also got the garlic knots and they were tasty. The knots were pretty big as well. Gone before I could get a pic. They were running a special, so we got those free. They had MANY bottled drink options and also fountain drinks. It is a very small cozy place. Wish it was a little bigger, but we were the only ones inside the restaurant at the time. They were very helpful. When we were almost finished, they asked us how everything was. Great! Will be back again.
Friendly food was good however a slice of pizza and a drink is 5$ but if you get 2 slices it's 15$Parking: It's on the court square very limited parking
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza anywhere! Don't forget to try the subs!!Vegetarian options: Just ask and they will accomplish almost anything!Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating to dietary restrictions!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata, Small Calzone, Pepperoni Roll, Meat Lovers 16in, 1 Topping Slice, Calzone, Tony Soprano, Don Corleone, Chicken Alfredo 20 In
Great food, service was friendly but not highly knowledgeable. Restaurant is small - better for takeout.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers 16in, Calzone
This place has a really neat, unique atmosphere. The food is delicious and the staff are really nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
With over 10 orders under my belt, the only certainty at this pizzeria seems to be its inconsistency. Whether it's a delightful surprise or a letdown, the element of unpredictability adds a unique twist to each dining experience. The fluctuating quality might leave you questioning the hefty bill, especially on the off days when the pizza falls short. While the ambiance and occasional culinary triumphs can justify the cost, be prepared for a hit-or-miss affair that might leave your wallet feeling lighter than your satisfaction.My recent order from this pizzeria left much to be desired. Unfortunately, the pizza was not just inconsistent; it was downright inedible due to being extremely undercooked. The dough resembled a raw state more than a crisp crust, and the toppings lacked the flavor that a properly cooked pizza should offer. It's a disappointing turn that raises serious concerns about the kitchen's attention to detail and overall quality control.Every visit is a gamble on what the pizza gods have in store for your taste buds. I won't be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Easily the best pizza in Paris, TN. Giant pizzas for a fair price make this place a go-to for a busy weeknight, no dishes meal. Love the little extras that come with the specials.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers 16in
I lived near New Haven CT for a few years and New York and CT had some of the best pizza Ive ever had. I was in the area and saw this restaurant and decided to give it a try. When I tell you, I haven’t had pizza like that in ten years (since I was last in NYC) believe it! It was incredible! I am so happy to have found this amazing restaurant and will be doing extra reps each week to make up for the extra calories Im bound to be consuming now!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered 7 pizzas for a party we were having. Every pizza was perfect, Thank you! Customer service is top notch also. Give them a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They had a bunch of pizza and desert to choose from. It was almost overwhelming the amount of pizza and desert choices there were. The young lady behind the counter was very sweet.Vegetarian options: The veggie pizzaKid-friendliness: They had video games for the kids to play
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1 Topping Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
The white pizza and the calzone were absolutely incredible and reminded me of home! I've yet to find a great calzone outside of NY until today.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Calzone, White Pie
I ordered my pizza at 6:11. It was to be done in 30 minutes. I showed up at 6:45 for my pizza. It was not done. 10 minutes later they said it would still be another 7 minutes.So we waited.Ten minutes later they inform my husband they dropped our pizza on accident so it will be another 10 minutes17 minutes later we finally got our pizza... AFTER WAITING THERE FOR 35 MINUTES AFTER THE TIME OF PICK UP. We were expecting some sort of discount or coupon but an apology was all.Probably will never be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We heard so much about this place. So we came from Huntingdon to paris to try it. When we got there. We were so disappointed. No seating. Take outs only. I asked the girl there if it was take out only and she told me. If I could fund a chair we could sit. Other then that it was take out. I looked around only 2 tables. And no chairs. So we left
Recently, my family fell on hard times due to a medical emergency I had, and I’m still suffering from.We were blessed with 2 large pizzas at no cost to us one particular night when we were struggling to feed our kids and here’s how:??????????????????????????????Nonni’s N.Y. Pizzeria has an angel pizza tree.What it is all about is that customers in our community can pre-pay for pizzas and/or meal combos. Whatever has been pre-paid is written on a card that’s in the shape of a pizza slice and hung on the tree.ANYONE CAN GO INTO THE PIZZERIA AND TAKE THEIR NEED OFF OF THE TREE AND TURN IT IN AND ORDER WITH NO QUESTIONS ASKED.Anyone that knows Chef Andy and his wife knows that is just a typical beautiful thing that they would do.They are a wonderful asset to our community and we are so lucky they chose to call Henry Co home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food, portions are crazy huge, order a large and you better have a truck to bring it home! Great people and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Calzone, Pepperoni Roll, Meat Pizza,