Save your money. You think you're getting a small cozy pizza place in a one stop light town. No it's a chain of cheaply made and over priced pizza. Nothing remotely stands out about the food. Brands of freezer pizza you would want to buy before wasting your time and money at the Pizza Plus. Follows Red Baron, DiGiorno, Screamn' Sicilian, Tombstone, and Motor City Pizza. Otherwise choose another chain. My order was wrong and the flavor was barely mediocre.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sara Cagle
Terrible customer service i ordered a pizza and jaiden gave us our pizza and shut the window right in our face. Charlotte is wonderful though phenomenal manager. Dont know why we got kicked out from behind the counter after climbing through the window..
Service: 1
Trish Starrett
Fantastic PIZZA !!! Great staff, food and the greatest salad Bar I’ve ever seen, clean !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janice Hawkins
Went there 7-18-25 when they opened and was shocked to see nasty yellow and brown lettuce in the bowl. At the price charged. I would think that customers should deserve better. They weren't even prepared for customers at 11. Doubt I'll be back. Big disappointment from my 2nd visit.
Food: 1
Jim Hodge
All was good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Miracle
Worst pizza that I have ever had. The sauce tasted like chef boy ardee. Crust was horrible. They couldn't even cut it right.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Natasha Lynn Heath
I did not visit this place and sure would not ever again
Michelle Ledford
We got there at about 1130 am to grab a quick bite. No pizza on the buffet, no staff contact.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Patti Haun
Too expensive. $35 for a large pizza and tip I can go to longhorn for 20$ out the door for steak. UPDATE: 5/1/25 Watch your credit and debit card charges. My card was used at this location without my permission. When I spoke to the manager Nancy she stated someone came and picked up a pizza. I have never been in this parking lot before in my life. I was then referred to corporate where Stephanie refused to give me her title and hung up in my face. I called back and left a VM with Kelly? Jenkins stating not only are you stealing my money but hanging up on me in the process. Never touching this place again. i suggest y'all use cash.
Justin Howey
This place is the worst. I agree with every review that I have read. I feel absolutely robbed. I just paid $50 for two sandwiches when I Live not even three minutes away from this restaurant and I have been a reoccurring customer always been good to you them. this is the one that’s on Rutledge Pike right next to the tobacco store and Dollar General so my mother dies two days ago they got my sandwich order completely wrong So so of course, as anybody would be, especially after going through a hard time, I simply called and asked for the lettuce and tomato that they forgot, but took them an hour a little bit over an hour to get to a place that was three minutes away. I read a few other reviews. They serve Rutledge Pike and somebody had to wait five hours just to get told that they don’t serve in Rutledge Pike and then the manager tried to blame them for it anyways they accept to bring me my lettuce and tomato but as I’m opening my BLT, it’s not like the picture shows where there’s slices of bacon on the sandwich. It look like as if there were bacon bits for a salad. And rather that’s the way that that works or not it just definitely did not look like the picture and they refused to replace the sandwich or even look at it. It barely had any bacon on it at all. It was just cheese and lettuce. I recommend nobody going to this place. and unknowingly even if you live three minutes away and then they’re going to take an hour and the sandwiches that I usually get that are like $10 a piece if I drive three minutes down the road to pick it up but when you tell them you want delivery, they show an attitude like they don’t want to do it and the cost of delivery compared to pick up is insane. I will be contacting the better business bureau tomorrow and I recommend other’s do the same. Let’s get this location shut down everyone! We deserve better!!
This place is awesome the food was always hot when it was delivered and they have delivered to us 2 even though we aren't in they're delivery area anymore. And it was the last time. We will miss having it delivered but we will go there and pick it up!! Tha is pizza plus!!!
michael ferraro
This place had the worst pizza ( if you can even call it that) that I ever tasted. How in the hell did this place get a 4.2 rating and a waste of $35.00. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Brandi Owens
Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Chicken Wings
Chris Burchell
The female employee that took my order by phone was professional even at pick up, but when I called to compliment them for the awesome food, the male employee was very rude and hung up on me twice.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 2
Hope Mills Warren
My family and I highly recommend Pizza Plus of Rutledge!!!! The restaurant is always clean!! The manager and employees are the sweetest. Their pizza and hoagie's are better than any place around!!! Our favorite pizza is the thin crust super deluxe, and our favorite sandwich is the chicken hoagie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Chicken Wings, Cheese Pizza with Mushrooms
Save your money. You think you're getting a small cozy pizza place in a one stop light town. No it's a chain of cheaply made and over priced pizza. Nothing remotely stands out about the food. Brands of freezer pizza you would want to buy before wasting your time and money at the Pizza Plus. Follows Red Baron, DiGiorno, Screamn' Sicilian, Tombstone, and Motor City Pizza. Otherwise choose another chain. My order was wrong and the flavor was barely mediocre.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Terrible customer service i ordered a pizza and jaiden gave us our pizza and shut the window right in our face. Charlotte is wonderful though phenomenal manager. Dont know why we got kicked out from behind the counter after climbing through the window..
Service: 1
Fantastic PIZZA !!! Great staff, food and the greatest salad Bar I’ve ever seen, clean !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there 7-18-25 when they opened and was shocked to see nasty yellow and brown lettuce in the bowl. At the price charged. I would think that customers should deserve better. They weren't even prepared for customers at 11. Doubt I'll be back. Big disappointment from my 2nd visit.
Food: 1
All was good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worst pizza that I have ever had. The sauce tasted like chef boy ardee. Crust was horrible. They couldn't even cut it right.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I did not visit this place and sure would not ever again
We got there at about 1130 am to grab a quick bite. No pizza on the buffet, no staff contact.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Too expensive. $35 for a large pizza and tip I can go to longhorn for 20$ out the door for steak. UPDATE: 5/1/25 Watch your credit and debit card charges. My card was used at this location without my permission. When I spoke to the manager Nancy she stated someone came and picked up a pizza. I have never been in this parking lot before in my life. I was then referred to corporate where Stephanie refused to give me her title and hung up in my face. I called back and left a VM with Kelly? Jenkins stating not only are you stealing my money but hanging up on me in the process. Never touching this place again. i suggest y'all use cash.
This place is the worst. I agree with every review that I have read. I feel absolutely robbed. I just paid $50 for two sandwiches when I Live not even three minutes away from this restaurant and I have been a reoccurring customer always been good to you them. this is the one that’s on Rutledge Pike right next to the tobacco store and Dollar General so my mother dies two days ago they got my sandwich order completely wrong So so of course, as anybody would be, especially after going through a hard time, I simply called and asked for the lettuce and tomato that they forgot, but took them an hour a little bit over an hour to get to a place that was three minutes away. I read a few other reviews. They serve Rutledge Pike and somebody had to wait five hours just to get told that they don’t serve in Rutledge Pike and then the manager tried to blame them for it anyways they accept to bring me my lettuce and tomato but as I’m opening my BLT, it’s not like the picture shows where there’s slices of bacon on the sandwich. It look like as if there were bacon bits for a salad. And rather that’s the way that that works or not it just definitely did not look like the picture and they refused to replace the sandwich or even look at it. It barely had any bacon on it at all. It was just cheese and lettuce. I recommend nobody going to this place. and unknowingly even if you live three minutes away and then they’re going to take an hour and the sandwiches that I usually get that are like $10 a piece if I drive three minutes down the road to pick it up but when you tell them you want delivery, they show an attitude like they don’t want to do it and the cost of delivery compared to pick up is insane. I will be contacting the better business bureau tomorrow and I recommend other’s do the same. Let’s get this location shut down everyone! We deserve better!!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is awesome the food was always hot when it was delivered and they have delivered to us 2 even though we aren't in they're delivery area anymore. And it was the last time. We will miss having it delivered but we will go there and pick it up!! Tha is pizza plus!!!
This place had the worst pizza ( if you can even call it that) that I ever tasted. How in the hell did this place get a 4.2 rating and a waste of $35.00. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Chicken Wings
The female employee that took my order by phone was professional even at pick up, but when I called to compliment them for the awesome food, the male employee was very rude and hung up on me twice.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 2
My family and I highly recommend Pizza Plus of Rutledge!!!! The restaurant is always clean!! The manager and employees are the sweetest. Their pizza and hoagie's are better than any place around!!! Our favorite pizza is the thin crust super deluxe, and our favorite sandwich is the chicken hoagie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Boneless Chicken Wings, Cheese Pizza with Mushrooms
Loading...