This is our favorite pizza in Arlington, we love this place! 2 large or 1 LG 1 med pizza on ubereats will run about $50+, but again it's so good.
Muhammad Goondall
I had high expectations when visiting NY Pizzeria, especially with a name that claims to offer “New York-style” pizza. Unfortunately, the experience fell significantly short of that promise.
The pizza lacked flavor, particularly in the tomato sauce, which was noticeably bland. The meat toppings were extremely sparse, and the vegetables were not properly diced—rather, they were roughly chopped, which made the overall eating experience awkward and unpleasant. The crust was overly thin, to the point where the cheese would slide off with each bite, making the pizza difficult to enjoy.
While I didn’t try their sub sandwiches, which may potentially be better, the pizza alone was a major letdown. As someone who has had authentic New York-style pizza, I can say with confidence that this is not even close. It more closely resembles something you’d expect from a fast-food arcade chain, or worse, something akin to cardboard. To be honest, even CiCi’s Pizza offers a better experience—and at a lower price point.
In terms of atmosphere, while the staff were friendly and courteous, the space itself is small and quite congested. There are only one or two tables available outside, which doesn’t do much to improve the limited capacity and cramped feeling inside.
Spending nearly $18 for a 12-inch pizza of this quality felt like a waste, and I regret not heeding the reviews I had read prior to visiting. I gave it a try in hopes of being pleasantly surprised, but unfortunately, I was left disappointed and dissatisfied.
M Hared
Their pizza is delicious 😋 with clean ingredients! My kids love eating here and we never had any problems with it. Thank you!
Brandon Van Cleave
Being from Brooklyn and pizza being life. I had to try this spot. The atmosphere is not the best and had a bit of a smell to it that needs to be fixed. First time there so could have been something unusual vs that’s the norm but as all true nyc people know if it’s a little sketchy it’s probably fire. As for the pizza I was a little concerned when I seen the domino’s pizza oven set up but overall not bad. Cheese was spot on and the texture of it was good. The crust was a little on the thinner side so it reminded me of the dollar slice spots in NYC but it was double the size so I’ll take it. When i didn’t see any crushed red peppers out I was a bit sad but they had it in the to go pack. Nice finding a spot you can still get a slice and for a good price. Pizza was solid. Definitely makes the list for a quick bite to get that pizza fix. 6 out of 10 which is not bad at all. Good job!!!
alex garcia
Please recommend you guys don’t ever eat this trash 🚮 the tomatoes, Alfredo sauce and pizza had no favor at all and make things worse the pizza was completely dry 😑. Rather go to little Caesar’s and get the hot ready. Please don’t waste your money in this place
Ghostrider 5576
Best pizzeria experience ever watched the fight and ate pizza on Valentine’s Day with my special other highly recommended
Rafael Rondon
I love this pizza and I absolutely LOVE the beef pepperoni…. YUMMMMMM
Javier Caballero
Great little hole in the wall place. The food is great, prices are good and the guys are pretty cool. We love this place.
ubadah1
This place has the best pizza and the best people! Family owned and operated, this place has been a staple for myself and my family for the last decade. Even though I live in Austin now, I still come by for a pizza when I’m in town. The cherry on top is the food is Halal! Enjoy the pepperoni and Canadian Bacon!
Ahdiya Tayyab
The taste was superb! Just like papa johns but halal! The guy working there was soo nice and helpful. We had such a good time. Would definitely recommend and come back 100%
Although he said halal before, it turn out they meant there is no pork in the food only. That doesn’t make it halal. It is (NOT HALAL).
Princess Of TMH
Haven’t gotten anything else from this restaurant but the “Chicken Aristocrat” is ON POINT!!! This meal is enough for two or leftovers for later. Hospitality of the employees are great and welcoming when greeted and served.
Noor Alyousef
Let's be real this is a cheese pizza has nothing to do with buffalo especially after asking for extra sauce 999times but the pizza still dry and it's just doesn't taste like a buffalo it's too thin as well. Wish you guys all the best 👍 but for me never again
Chris Grimm
This place has great pizza. My wife and love coming here.
Glynn Sugg
The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the cheese is gooey and delicious. Every bite is pure bliss.
But it's not just the pizza that makes this place special. The owners are incredibly friendly and welcoming, always making you feel like family. They even went the extra mile and sold me some dough to take home, so I could try my hand at making my own pizza and cinnamon rolls without having to deal with the struggle of making the dough.
If you're a pizza lover, you absolutely must try NY Pizzeria. You won't be disappointed!
This is our favorite pizza in Arlington, we love this place! 2 large or 1 LG 1 med pizza on ubereats will run about $50+, but again it's so good.
I had high expectations when visiting NY Pizzeria, especially with a name that claims to offer “New York-style” pizza. Unfortunately, the experience fell significantly short of that promise.
The pizza lacked flavor, particularly in the tomato sauce, which was noticeably bland. The meat toppings were extremely sparse, and the vegetables were not properly diced—rather, they were roughly chopped, which made the overall eating experience awkward and unpleasant. The crust was overly thin, to the point where the cheese would slide off with each bite, making the pizza difficult to enjoy.
While I didn’t try their sub sandwiches, which may potentially be better, the pizza alone was a major letdown. As someone who has had authentic New York-style pizza, I can say with confidence that this is not even close. It more closely resembles something you’d expect from a fast-food arcade chain, or worse, something akin to cardboard. To be honest, even CiCi’s Pizza offers a better experience—and at a lower price point.
In terms of atmosphere, while the staff were friendly and courteous, the space itself is small and quite congested. There are only one or two tables available outside, which doesn’t do much to improve the limited capacity and cramped feeling inside.
Spending nearly $18 for a 12-inch pizza of this quality felt like a waste, and I regret not heeding the reviews I had read prior to visiting. I gave it a try in hopes of being pleasantly surprised, but unfortunately, I was left disappointed and dissatisfied.
Their pizza is delicious 😋 with clean ingredients! My kids love eating here and we never had any problems with it. Thank you!
Being from Brooklyn and pizza being life. I had to try this spot. The atmosphere is not the best and had a bit of a smell to it that needs to be fixed. First time there so could have been something unusual vs that’s the norm but as all true nyc people know if it’s a little sketchy it’s probably fire. As for the pizza I was a little concerned when I seen the domino’s pizza oven set up but overall not bad. Cheese was spot on and the texture of it was good. The crust was a little on the thinner side so it reminded me of the dollar slice spots in NYC but it was double the size so I’ll take it. When i didn’t see any crushed red peppers out I was a bit sad but they had it in the to go pack. Nice finding a spot you can still get a slice and for a good price. Pizza was solid. Definitely makes the list for a quick bite to get that pizza fix. 6 out of 10 which is not bad at all. Good job!!!
Please recommend you guys don’t ever eat this trash 🚮 the tomatoes, Alfredo sauce and pizza had no favor at all and make things worse the pizza was completely dry 😑. Rather go to little Caesar’s and get the hot ready. Please don’t waste your money in this place
Best pizzeria experience ever watched the fight and ate pizza on Valentine’s Day with my special other highly recommended
I love this pizza and I absolutely LOVE the beef pepperoni….
YUMMMMMM
Great little hole in the wall place. The food is great, prices are good and the guys are pretty cool. We love this place.
This place has the best pizza and the best people! Family owned and operated, this place has been a staple for myself and my family for the last decade. Even though I live in Austin now, I still come by for a pizza when I’m in town. The cherry on top is the food is Halal! Enjoy the pepperoni and Canadian Bacon!
The taste was superb! Just like papa johns but halal! The guy working there was soo nice and helpful. We had such a good time. Would definitely recommend and come back 100%
Restaurantji Recommends
Although he said halal before, it turn out they meant there is no pork in the food only. That doesn’t make it halal. It is (NOT HALAL).
Haven’t gotten anything else from this restaurant but the “Chicken Aristocrat” is ON POINT!!! This meal is enough for two or leftovers for later. Hospitality of the employees are great and welcoming when greeted and served.
Let's be real this is a cheese pizza has nothing to do with buffalo especially after asking for extra sauce 999times but the pizza still dry and it's just doesn't taste like a buffalo it's too thin as well.
Wish you guys all the best 👍 but for me never again
This place has great pizza. My wife and love coming here.
The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the cheese is gooey and delicious. Every bite is pure bliss.
But it's not just the pizza that makes this place special. The owners are incredibly friendly and welcoming, always making you feel like family. They even went the extra mile and sold me some dough to take home, so I could try my hand at making my own pizza and cinnamon rolls without having to deal with the struggle of making the dough.
If you're a pizza lover, you absolutely must try NY Pizzeria. You won't be disappointed!
Loading...