Papa Johns Pizza

8455 Crestway Dr Ste. 111, Converse
(210) 655-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Angelica Correa

I want to hop in a give a good rating mainly to the cashier in the front that was there today after 5pm. Everyone in the lobby was extra rude and impatient and she stayed so respectful. That’s not easy. Big ups to her and the crew for keeping it together.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Cartter

This location doesn't have in house delivery anymore, my last three attempts were all redirected to door dash unprompted and all arrived missing items or cold. This time I couldn't even eat because it was so badly made.

CNC CP 2022

They sent me BURNT pizza. Aweful taste. I did not get what I requested except for the generic topping. Do your self a favor & skip this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lisa Nelson

I've had their wings they're not too bad but I would say their pizzas are pretty decent for the price even though they're more priceier than other locations like Domino's and stuff but I am disappointed today when I ordered the heart-shaped pizza I ordered it from Little Caesars before and it was actually a decent size and I thought with Papa John's and the price of about $12 it would be a good decent size for medium and it's like thin crust and it looks small I'm not sure if Pizza Hut has a larger size because Pizza hut's looked a lot better than this one. But I guess it's a good thing I ordered two pizzas because one would not have been enough for four people

Update delivery order. Delivery was good. But ordered half pepperoni, Roma tomatoes, and spinach. It literally looks like I just threw it on myself, like I bought baby spinach leaves and chopped up tomatoes and tossed it. I think I prefer Marcos over this.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Yisel Pilar

I do not recommend this place, the lady who is working today, Wednesday 12/03/25, has a very bad way of treating customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris

Food is fine but it takes forever for them to complete orders, even carry out orders. Took them over 40 minutes to have my carry out ready despite the person on the phone saying it would only take 15 minutes. Go to a different location.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Ebony Walker

This is location is beyond horrible…I placed an order at 5:43pm and my order wasn’t delivered until 7:02pm…and then when I looked at the box it was not even my order…So I go to the store and I am met by several other patrons who have clearly been standing there longer then they would have liked on a Friday night. I am finally acknowledged by a kid who is clearly clueless and I let him know I received the wrong order. This kid then proceeds to ask me what my name was, I told him and he goes oh we don’t have your order….ummmm no crap Sherlock! Somebody probably got my order like I received someone else’s….He then finds my order and of course it’s cold because it’s been sitting out for over an hour….he also then has the nerve to ask me if I want a cold pizza! Seriously? I guess we just hire anybody these days why would I want a cold pizza when I paid for a hot one? Make it make sense. I am done with Papa John’s you guys need to get your crap together….it’s not Rocket Science you are slinging pizzas and putting them in a box which is proving to be a bit of a challenge for the crew there…maybe we consider some type of training program on how not to piss off customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ethan Glammeier

Yikes. I am glad I checked the reviews after the lady yelled at me in Spanish and then hung up while trying to place an order. Shame because I love this pizza.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Xaveria “Tang” Tucker

I believe there is a need for classes on professionalism at this establishment. No one greeted me or spoke to me during my visit. While I enjoyed the food, I was turned off when I saw the manager making my pizza without wearing gloves. After he walked away, another employee continued working without gloves as well. I politely declined and decided to leave. It's absolutely unacceptable to prepare food without proper hygiene practices.

Karolina Rivera

Might want to let people know when the store only has one oven working. The app will let anyone order so it will back order everything and have people waiting longer than the app states.

Brice Fritter

If you want food poisoning come here. Managers are a joke
I have a laywer involved now. 13 days in the hospital over this place
STAY AWAY!!!!!! IF YOU WANT TO

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kayla Weber

Don’t bother ordering HOURS in advance. You will wait another hour + for one pizza and some bread sticks. Yall suck and the little girl who wanted to tell me everyone’s been here a long time. That’s a BS response. If you run a promotion then be prepared to fill the orders!

Service: 1

Rebecca Miley

The pizza was not that good nor bad. It was just something to out in our stomachs for the moment. I was disappointed because I typically like Papa Johns ( im Dallas area)

Food: 3

Service: 4

Arnesha Moore

Horrible horrible customer service I had to call because they called me and told me that they was canceling my order because I wasn’t in their area which the app google my location as I put in my GPS they were only eight minutes away. I called back to get clarification and ask for the supervisor. The guy act like he didn’t want me to talk to the supervisor and kept saying he could help me I had to ask over three times then when I talk to Savannah, she informed me that oh it’s a glitch. It was saying that my address was over 1000 miles away, but I can re-order but y’all have a refunding me back my money that’s gonna take 2 to 5 business days and you want me to purchase again very unacceptable.

cancer moon Sun Virgin

I love pizza 🤤

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...