This is seriously the best place I have ever eaten in my life. The food is SO good- especially the Italian soup, Reuben sandwich and Texas sheet cake. We don’t live in this area but we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Liza Grudzinski
Our meal at Cherry Pie & Co exceeded all expectations! The atmosphere is beautiful with so much natural light and a wonderful place for lunch with friends or even a private event. We had the chicken salad, the turkey club, and the grilled chicken salad. Everything was absolutely delicious and it was so clear it was all made with so much love and the highest quality, fresh ingredients. We were stuffed after our meal, but got scones and cookies to go and the baked goods were amazing! Highly recommend this locally owned business that goes above and beyond to deliver its customers delicious and high quality food!
Liza Imobersteg
Our meal at Cherry Pie & Co exceeded all expectations! The atmosphere is beautiful with so much natural light and a wonderful place for lunch with friends or even a private event. We had the chicken salad, the turkey club, and the grilled chicken salad. Everything was absolutely delicious and it was so clear it was all made with so much love and the highest quality, fresh ingredients. We were stuffed after our meal, but got scones and cookies to go and the baked goods were amazing! Highly recommend this locally owned business that goes above and beyond to deliver its customers delicious and high quality food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary Hammons
Everything about this place is good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leo Menchaca
Great Gluten Free sandwich’s! They will occasionally have a GF pie or pastry, which is nice too.
D Marricle
Discovered this quaint eatery in Decatur recently. Located in a cute historical house...the food was delicious and served promptly. Staff was extra friendly and courteous. Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Helm
Amazing food!!! Love the Monte Cristo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Henri Castelain
Terrific little place with parking across the street or on street. Order at the counter, find a table and wait for your food. Met a friend for a snack on a Sunday about 1130. Great sandwiches. Came with chips and one person did a soup & sandwich. Ice tea and some drinks in a glass front fridge if that's your choice. Reasonable prices, would go back if in Decatur.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Lyndsi Vann
The best monte cristo I’ve ever had!!! 10000/10! Also, the girls in here are so kind. Love this place!
Stopped in today and it was the most charming little place,the food was amazing. I had the club, the bread was absolutely delicious and everything was so fresh. Can’t wait to stop in again, such a jewel!
Barb Henderson
Have eaten there 3 times. Each time the food was a bit worse. Had the combo today. The tomato soup was oily and lukewarm. The bread on the sandwich was inedible. Could not cut through the crust. Chips also hard. I told the waitress....she brought me a half a slice of bread and said it should be softer !!!! We will NOT be going back.
S Davis
We drove an extra 20 minutes out of our way in search of pie and charm, but unfortunately found little of either.
Despite the name Cherry Pie & Co., this is not a pie shop in any meaningful sense. They did not have cherry pie—nor any true selection of pie at all. Just a couple of tired-looking slices of strawberry pie sitting uneasily in a display case. To brand oneself around pie and then offer so little of it feels, at best, misleading.
The salad was excellent—fresh spinach topped generously with strawberries, avocado, pistachios, slivered almonds, and feta. Well-balanced and genuinely satisfying. The pastries were also decent. Unfortunately, the Reuben sandwich was a letdown: chewy meat, soggy marbled rye, and runny sauces that soaked through the paper beneath. Not enjoyable.
The interior is quaint, and the natural lighting in our room was lovely—but the air conditioning was not functioning in that part of the building. It was around 80°F at our table, which made for an uncomfortable meal. The restroom was clean and nicely kept, though it lacked a changing table for infants, which forced us to take our baby to another business nearby just to change a diaper.
For a salad, a Reuben with chips, a cookie, and two drinks, the total came to nearly $41 after tip. That price point demands excellence or at least a memorable experience. We received neither.
In sum: a charming location, but a disappointing meal, a misleading name, and very poor value. We will not return. 2 stars.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Dawn Latour
My daughter-in-law, my granddaughter, and I stopped in today for lunch. It was amazing!!! The sandwiches were delicious, the cookies were delicious, and the staff were amazing. 💖
Alexis Ambriz
We just had Cherry Pie and Co. for the first time, and wow! Literally so good, not only was the food amazing, but the staff was the sweetest. We stopped when the google photos caught my eye, the cottage looked appealing, and once we entered; everything felt so homey. We met the owner and one of her daughters and you could just feel the love and pride in their food. We ordered the burrito, breakfast bowl, and waffle and each item tasted so good and homemade. Also if you get a chance, try their strawberry pie! They brought it out once we were leaving and I’m so glad we grabbed a piece! It will definitely be our new travel spot.
Great restaurant ran by great people!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is seriously the best place I have ever eaten in my life. The food is SO good- especially the Italian soup, Reuben sandwich and Texas sheet cake. We don’t live in this area but we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our meal at Cherry Pie & Co exceeded all expectations! The atmosphere is beautiful with so much natural light and a wonderful place for lunch with friends or even a private event. We had the chicken salad, the turkey club, and the grilled chicken salad. Everything was absolutely delicious and it was so clear it was all made with so much love and the highest quality, fresh ingredients. We were stuffed after our meal, but got scones and cookies to go and the baked goods were amazing! Highly recommend this locally owned business that goes above and beyond to deliver its customers delicious and high quality food!
Our meal at Cherry Pie & Co exceeded all expectations! The atmosphere is beautiful with so much natural light and a wonderful place for lunch with friends or even a private event. We had the chicken salad, the turkey club, and the grilled chicken salad. Everything was absolutely delicious and it was so clear it was all made with so much love and the highest quality, fresh ingredients. We were stuffed after our meal, but got scones and cookies to go and the baked goods were amazing! Highly recommend this locally owned business that goes above and beyond to deliver its customers delicious and high quality food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything about this place is good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Gluten Free sandwich’s! They will occasionally have a GF pie or pastry, which is nice too.
Discovered this quaint eatery in Decatur recently. Located in a cute historical house...the food was delicious and served promptly. Staff was extra friendly and courteous. Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food!!! Love the Monte Cristo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrific little place with parking across the street or on street. Order at the counter, find a table and wait for your food. Met a friend for a snack on a Sunday about 1130. Great sandwiches. Came with chips and one person did a soup & sandwich. Ice tea and some drinks in a glass front fridge if that's your choice. Reasonable prices, would go back if in Decatur.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
The best monte cristo I’ve ever had!!! 10000/10! Also, the girls in here are so kind. Love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in today and it was the most charming little place,the food was amazing. I had the club, the bread was absolutely delicious and everything was so fresh. Can’t wait to stop in again, such a jewel!
Have eaten there 3 times. Each time the food was a bit worse. Had the combo today. The tomato soup was oily and lukewarm. The bread on the sandwich was inedible. Could not cut through the crust. Chips also hard. I told the waitress....she brought me a half a slice of bread and said it should be softer !!!! We will NOT be going back.
We drove an extra 20 minutes out of our way in search of pie and charm, but unfortunately found little of either.
Despite the name Cherry Pie & Co., this is not a pie shop in any meaningful sense. They did not have cherry pie—nor any true selection of pie at all. Just a couple of tired-looking slices of strawberry pie sitting uneasily in a display case. To brand oneself around pie and then offer so little of it feels, at best, misleading.
The salad was excellent—fresh spinach topped generously with strawberries, avocado, pistachios, slivered almonds, and feta. Well-balanced and genuinely satisfying. The pastries were also decent. Unfortunately, the Reuben sandwich was a letdown: chewy meat, soggy marbled rye, and runny sauces that soaked through the paper beneath. Not enjoyable.
The interior is quaint, and the natural lighting in our room was lovely—but the air conditioning was not functioning in that part of the building. It was around 80°F at our table, which made for an uncomfortable meal. The restroom was clean and nicely kept, though it lacked a changing table for infants, which forced us to take our baby to another business nearby just to change a diaper.
For a salad, a Reuben with chips, a cookie, and two drinks, the total came to nearly $41 after tip. That price point demands excellence or at least a memorable experience. We received neither.
In sum: a charming location, but a disappointing meal, a misleading name, and very poor value. We will not return. 2 stars.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
My daughter-in-law, my granddaughter, and I stopped in today for lunch. It was amazing!!! The sandwiches were delicious, the cookies were delicious, and the staff were amazing. 💖
We just had Cherry Pie and Co. for the first time, and wow! Literally so good, not only was the food amazing, but the staff was the sweetest.
We stopped when the google photos caught my eye, the cottage looked appealing, and once we entered; everything felt so homey. We met the owner and one of her daughters and you could just feel the love and pride in their food. We ordered the burrito, breakfast bowl, and waffle and each item tasted so good and homemade. Also if you get a chance, try their strawberry pie! They brought it out once we were leaving and I’m so glad we grabbed a piece!
It will definitely be our new travel spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...