Cutler's Cookies & Sandwiches

The best cookies anywhere, bar none.

Very fun cookies and good sandwiches

it took 30 minutes to get a side of pasta salad. and there was only ONE person in front of me

They show their hours until 8:30pm. Showed up at 8pm and said they would not serve us sandwiches because they had already packed everything up. Don’t advertise your hours as closing at 8:30 if your not going to serve your customers.

Excellent, friendly service & delicious and cheap food😋

I recently visited Cutler’s Cookies & Sandwiches, and I was really impressed! The sandwiches were fresh and delicious, made with quality ingredients. But the real highlight for me was the cookies — soft, rich, and full of flavor. The staff was friendly and quick, and the place was very clean and welcoming. Definitely a great spot for a quick lunch or sweet treat. I highly recommend it!

Me and my wife went in here, we were the only customers at the time the two sandwiches we ordered took almost 15 minutes to come out.

I had the barbecue beef, it was very underwhelming, it tasted like something you can buy in the frozen food section of the grocery store and reheat. It was okay, not worth the money though.

There were no napkins on the tables, just one set of napkins over by the garbage cans. Although that we were the only ones in the restaurant they didn't bring us the food or set it on the front counter, they put it out in the window on the other side of the dining room from us and called our number.

Service was just bad. While they were making our sandwiches one other lady came in the restaurant and waited about 5 minutes for someone to respond to her until she called out to them to tell them she just wanted a lemonade.

Restaurant seemed pretty clean. I would just hate to go there if there was more than two customers because the wait would have been forever.

Great sandwiches!

Used to be great. Now I’m being charged $.75 for cranberry sauce subbed for dressing. I just went through the drive-through and asked if I could substitute it and if it would be an extra cost. The girl said no it would not be an extra cost to substitute. Then I get to the window and pay and it’s a full $.75 per sandwich for the substitution. Prices are already high. I want to support local business, but I don’t love being misled or exorbitantly charged. 👎👎

There are three Cutlers owned by different family members. The one in Centerville is my favorite. It is owned and operated by a lovely married couple who work together daily. How sweet is that?!
Their prices are the cheapest of the three locations and their food is the best. The soup is all homemade and delicious. The sandwiches are thick with at least 3 ounces of daily-sliced fresh meat on them.
They offer home-made pasta and potato salad that are both really yummy. They also sell a raspberry walnut chicken salad with glazed walnuts!
The food here is delicious and healthy and doesn’t leave me feeling heavy and greasy afterwards.
The cookies are beautiful and tasty and fresh.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is calm and clean and homey. I feel like I’m at grandmas house at Cutlers. Also, they got a bathroom remodel recently and they look amazing!

I picked up a Chicken Salad croissant sandwich today and it was amazing! The woman said she made it with love and I could taste it 💕 10/10 🙌🏻

Cookies are good. Each cookie cost about $3.25.They have raised the prices again. $$$

This salad stinks, the cucumber is definitely forming white gooey stuff and it is very soggy/stinky. There’s not even enough cucumbers or tomatoes in this salad.

Delicious cookies, soup, and chicken salad.

Great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey Cranberry Sandwich