Old Chicago Pizza & Taproom

Great fast service. Thin crust is terrible. It may be homemade but it tastes and has the mouth feel of a frozen, pre-made crust. I ordered the Supreme Individual pizza for dinner. It is supposed to have 6 toppings. It had 6 different toppings but they gave 1/6 portion of each. This was the thinnest "Supreme" pizza I've had in my life.

I was disappointed. Pizza wasn't cut throughly ended up ripping the pizza. A little more on the bland side of taste. Might try again since it was a take out order.

The staff went out of their way to take care of me on the day of my fathers passing. Great personalities and kind. I highly suggest the spicy fried pickles and order all the sauces to dip. You won't regret coming here. The bartender with long dark brown and phenomenal eye makeup was the angel I needed that day. I think her name starts with an A. God bless you lady. Thanks for the hug.

25 cent beer shot tasters, awesome. Tara has been our server twice now and she is attentive to keeping our waters filled and our beers coming. She is knowledgeable with the menu selections and gives great suggestions. She also knows her beers and mixed drinks, so she is helpful with suggestions in choosing what kind of cocktail or beer your are to enjoy with your meal. And with the 25 cent tasters you might just find a new favorite brew. Hoppy beers to ya!

Amazing place to eat and drink. Italian nachos are my favorite here. No other place comes close.

With my lifestyle change of eating healthier they've got great salads to choose from!!! My favorite is the Sweet Thai Chicken but everything I've seen from the burgers to pizza look amazing as well and my cohorts/lunch mates have nothing but good things to say. Highly recommend!

First visit, had great experience. Great sports bar vibe. Food was very good, especially the artichoke dip appetizer. Nice menu selection, wide variety. Great service by all! Definitely recommend!

I love the manicotti at this place and the Ceasar salad is divine!! No matter when I go, the food is perfection! I had a Gnome Eggnog this time as well and it was delish!!

Two horrible experiences in a row. What did they have in common, same horrible manager. 45 minutes, no meal, no appetizers, only our beers. Manager only offers excuses, no accountability. All the other times have been amazing food and service. Too bad this place is going down the toilet.

A most impressive variety of brews from local, regional and National breweries paired with excellent pizza makes Old Chicago a winning formula!

Ordered in on a Saturday evening. First impression, great atmosphere. The appetizers were delicious and quick to arrive at our table. The tall order of wings had great quantity, and the wings tasted very delicious, excellent crispness without suffering the meat to be dry.However, when asked for some extra Firehouse sauce (I have a high spice tolerance) I was given chilled hot sauce and had to get the waiters attention (twice) after I explicitly stated to have an extra cup with my order. My food got cold and it got colder with the additional sauce.I will be ordering wings here again, but not for the heat, nor will I ask for any additional requests as it seems the waiters can only keep track of menu items. Not bad service, but was disappointed to be served a hot sauce chilled without disclosure and requesting the attention of the waiter several times over the same thing.In writing a fair review, I will disclose everyone else in my group enjoyed their meals.

Delicious food! And yummy cocktails! My favorite is the build your own Mac and the cheesy garlic bread ?The wait is worth it.This is their drink special right now! ❤️

My wife just ate at our favorite pizza place. I think this was the BEST PIZZA ever. The cauliflower crust option is so delicious and they cook it just right to order. If you ask for a little extra well done they make it just right. The chicken Caesar salad was cold, crisp the meat was good the cheese was perfect it was all very very good. Hooray for Chicago pizza. They finally are getting their act together and the cooks obviously have been trained and are doing good things. The service was great. And the Cowboys won. Thank you!!!

The pizza was good but did not stand out. We prefer thin crust but accidentally ordered thicker crust so our opinion might be off by a bit. That said, we didn’t find anything special other than very good service. For Utah, they have a good selection of beverages although on tap beer is still limited to 5% thus limiting that category. Did not try or inspect their canned and bottled beers.

Great beer…Great service by Mason