Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.

A popular place. Waited in line for about 20 min (the first warm evening since the start of winter). The four of us had a wide selection of flavors (berry cheesecake, lavender and honeycomb, snicker doodle, chocolate). Everything was rich, sweet, unctuous and thoroughly enjoyed! Best ice cream I've ever had, no; worth the 30 mile drive, yes.
Looking forward to returning and exploring other choices.

Pinolo's Gelato, Portland OR is my favorite.

Stopped here while in Salt Lake. We had never heard of it. Glad we found it. They let you do a split single so you can have two flavors in the single size. I got the cold brew mocha and caramel cookie. My wife got the gooy buttercake and berry cheesecake. All were delicious. The eating area is up a flight of stairs allowing a view from above. Very good

I've tried almost every flavor on this menu! Their monthly flavors are must trys!

The campfire smores is by far their best flavor, its toasted marshmallows and graham crackers with a chocolate sauce and vanilla ice cream. Tastes exactly like a smore.

The marshmallows are toasted with a blow torch so you get that authentic taste!

I dream about Blacksmith Ice Cream! Love their sampler flight to try out multiple flavors. Very creative flavors that always impress!

Wow BEST ICE CREAM I've had in MY ENTIRE LIFE! Felt euphoric tasting it. I'm not high though, the ice cream is just REALLY GOOD 🤤

Delicious!

Hands down our favorite ice cream in salt lake! They have vegan and dairy options with so many fun flavors.

PLEASE MAKE PISTACHIO FLAVOR JUST PISTACHIO!! My personal plea, and I think all pistachio lovers would agree.

Otherwise this is the best ice cream shop of all time!

The best ice cream in town, with fantastic quality comparable to Handel’s. What sets it apart is the unique texture—slightly chewy and incredibly satisfying. You can really taste the difference their hands-on, small-batch method makes—it definitely pays off. My wife and I have tried four different sampler flavors so far, and every single one was delicious!

Both my wife and I are definately revisiting soon.

The ice cream is excellent.

I went here today with some coworkers and it was incredible. Easily the best ice cream I have eaten in the valley, and maybe the best I’ve ever had anywhere. Absolutely delicious, I highly recommend the Honeybud flavor. The pricing was very reasonable for the quality of product provided.

A bonus is that my friend was able to pay using Glint, so he payed with a digital gold transaction.

This is the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Every time I go I feel joy. However, one star removed because I miss dough and cookies (the best flavor). Thank you for your delicious ice cream.

Best ice cream in salt lake! Heck I think it’s the best ice cream in the country. They keep you hooked with their monthly flavors and of course they have delicious regular flavors as well!!

My favorites are cookie avalanche, grilled pineapple, and blueberry huckleberry!!

Fantastic ice cream in a fun setting.

Truly exceptional ice cream. Hand churned to perfection, offering a smooth, creamy texture, ensuring a rich, dense mouthfeel. I haven’t ice cream this good in many years. I loved the Fudge Brownie and Chewy Gooey Buttercake flavors. And the Honeybud flavor, made of lavender and honey ice cream with homemade honeycomb candy pieces, is unique and flavorful. Highly recommended. Makes me sad I don’t live in Utah!