Food, outstanding. Table service, outstanding. Ladies at the front left something to be desired. Didn't like being seated by the food pick up window where the wait staff gathered. Ask to be moved by the hostess, but she made a big deal about it so we sat there. Anniversary didn't get acknowledged - not that we were looking for anything free, but don't ask if it's a special occasion and not acknowledge. Would definitely go back, making sure to get a different table.
Robert
Been here many times for special occasions mainly. Food is always great and service is usually good to great I do recommend Sicilia Mia.
Gerardo Villena
One of the best experience ever lasagna and pasta was the best, how ever the service that Noah provide was outstanding not just offering advise of combinations but as well providing experience. Will definetly advise come with time to enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isabel
My husband and I came in for dinner. We made a reservation for 8:30pm. We spent the time before walking around a local mall. This place is right by a grocery store, which made it feel even more local.
We were given bread service and offered a variety of waters. I ordered the take on linguine and clams, my husband got their ribeye, and we shared the octopus.
The pasta was house made and was thick. The sauce it came with was also a very creamy, decant, butter sauce. I enjoyed it throughly. My husband enjoyed the flavor of the ribeye. He did regret getting the full serving of butter on the steak though. The octopus was flavorful, but it could have been a bit more tender. I really did enjoy the sauce it came with though.
All in all, we thought it was worth the money we spent. I would come back and try something new, if we ever come back to Salt Lake City.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nick
I rarely leave reviews for places but I feel this is an important one. My sweet wife and I are celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary this week and we choose Sicilia Mia as the place of choice to celebrate. This is the first time we have dined at this restaurant, and have heard great things from friends and I must say, we were not disappointed. From the moment we walked in, to the minute we left, we had the most amazing experience. Our server, Natani, was the most amazing server we have ever had, and the food and drinks are truly second to none. Thank you so much for making our night a very special one!!! We will indeed be back soon. And thanks to the Manager, Jake, for your hospitality. God bless!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica
Drove 20 minutes to eat here since it said open on Google but when we got here it was closed. It was Saturday and they’re open 11-2 then 4:30-10
Larry
The food was very good. The disappointment was this was a birthday celebration and the waiter knew it but at the end there was nothing but a bill and it was hard watching other tables celebrate.
Dayana
Our first experience at Sicilia Mía was outstanding. Customer service and attention to detail from our waitress, the atmosphere, warmed welcome, and exquisite food and drink taste all made up for the ultimate enjoyable anniversary date.
Josh Hamilton
Stein is the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Caprese
Miriam Vargas
A great please great atmosphere our waiter was so sweet. He shared stories of Denmark and made us feel very welcomed. Place is cozy and personal.
Excellent dinner! Our first time here and it was definitely delicious. Great food, nice choice of wines and drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clara Sofia Contreras Diaz
We went without a reservation, and had to wait for the hostess to take call after call while we were just standing there. In a way that we all perceived as rude. When she finally addressed us, she let us know that the only available spot was 2 hours later. While I understand that we should have made a reservation I do not agree with the hottest attitude
Atmosphere: 5
Mark
The food is absolutely outstanding. Our server, Jacob, was also outstanding. He let us know that we could have the Carbonara as an appetizer, so our four top could all try their house specialty and still each order another fabulous entree. Overall, just a fabulous restaurant.
Emily Garland
Kate was the best! So nice and attentive. And the food was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
.
Everything was Amazing! By far the Best Sicialian/Italian food & experience I've had anywhere. The food is so good take a bite close your eyes and you can almost smell the Mediterranean. Im not a dessert guy but I like cannolis, theirs is on a level that no other cannoli comes close. So glad I found Sicilia Mia, Grazie!!
Food, outstanding. Table service, outstanding. Ladies at the front left something to be desired. Didn't like being seated by the food pick up window where the wait staff gathered. Ask to be moved by the hostess, but she made a big deal about it so we sat there. Anniversary didn't get acknowledged - not that we were looking for anything free, but don't ask if it's a special occasion and not acknowledge. Would definitely go back, making sure to get a different table.
Been here many times for special occasions mainly. Food is always great and service is usually good to great I do recommend Sicilia Mia.
One of the best experience ever lasagna and pasta was the best, how ever the service that Noah provide was outstanding not just offering advise of combinations but as well providing experience. Will definetly advise come with time to enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I came in for dinner. We made a reservation for 8:30pm. We spent the time before walking around a local mall. This place is right by a grocery store, which made it feel even more local.
We were given bread service and offered a variety of waters. I ordered the take on linguine and clams, my husband got their ribeye, and we shared the octopus.
The pasta was house made and was thick. The sauce it came with was also a very creamy, decant, butter sauce. I enjoyed it throughly. My husband enjoyed the flavor of the ribeye. He did regret getting the full serving of butter on the steak though. The octopus was flavorful, but it could have been a bit more tender. I really did enjoy the sauce it came with though.
All in all, we thought it was worth the money we spent. I would come back and try something new, if we ever come back to Salt Lake City.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I rarely leave reviews for places but I feel this is an important one. My sweet wife and I are celebrating our 25th wedding anniversary this week and we choose Sicilia Mia as the place of choice to celebrate. This is the first time we have dined at this restaurant, and have heard great things from friends and I must say, we were not disappointed. From the moment we walked in, to the minute we left, we had the most amazing experience. Our server, Natani, was the most amazing server we have ever had, and the food and drinks are truly second to none. Thank you so much for making our night a very special one!!! We will indeed be back soon. And thanks to the Manager, Jake, for your hospitality. God bless!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drove 20 minutes to eat here since it said open on Google but when we got here it was closed. It was Saturday and they’re open 11-2 then 4:30-10
The food was very good. The disappointment was this was a birthday celebration and the waiter knew it but at the end there was nothing but a bill and it was hard watching other tables celebrate.
Our first experience at Sicilia Mía was outstanding. Customer service and attention to detail from our waitress, the atmosphere, warmed welcome, and exquisite food and drink taste all made up for the ultimate enjoyable anniversary date.
Stein is the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Caprese
A great please great atmosphere our waiter was so sweet. He shared stories of Denmark and made us feel very welcomed. Place is cozy and personal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent dinner! Our first time here and it was definitely delicious. Great food, nice choice of wines and drinks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went without a reservation, and had to wait for the hostess to take call after call while we were just standing there. In a way that we all perceived as rude. When she finally addressed us, she let us know that the only available spot was 2 hours later. While I understand that we should have made a reservation I do not agree with the hottest attitude
Atmosphere: 5
The food is absolutely outstanding. Our server, Jacob, was also outstanding. He let us know that we could have the Carbonara as an appetizer, so our four top could all try their house specialty and still each order another fabulous entree. Overall, just a fabulous restaurant.
Kate was the best! So nice and attentive. And the food was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was Amazing! By far the Best Sicialian/Italian food & experience I've had anywhere. The food is so good take a bite close your eyes and you can almost smell the Mediterranean. Im not a dessert guy but I like cannolis, theirs is on a level that no other cannoli comes close. So glad I found Sicilia Mia, Grazie!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...