What a fun pizza place! You can watch the pizza dough being thrown in the air while you sit at your table! It's pretty awesome. The New York style pizza is pretty tasty too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Style Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Rosie Jones
The pizza itself is pretty good! Compares pretty well to actual New York pizza. It’s very thin, piping hot, and good flavor. We also got a calzone and the cheese bread. The calzone was much flatter than you’d expect. It was okay, but the pizza was better. As for the cheese bread… I don’t know what they are going for, but it was not good. The bread was very dense. It was almost like a focaccia. It was reasonably priced and it was nice to be able to sit and eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Tom Mattingly
I ordered to go. It was ready on time. However I grabbed the box and screamed because it was so hot and then they said oh sorry it’s hot. Could have told me ahead of time. Tastes liked cardboard, tough and the pizza was bland except for the sausage that was way too hot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Rick Coleman
I love good pizza and this my go-to spot for pizza, they even sell it by the slice.
richard coleman
Without a doubt the pizza in the city and you can even buy it by the slice!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin Huber
I used to love coming here and genuinely enjoyed the pizza, but recently it seems like this place is obsessed with closing before they're actually closed. I get it if it were opened late on the weekends, but on a Monday before the sun is even down? Relax. Pay your people a little overtime to close when you actually close, instead of soft closing an hour prior to actually closing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jonathan Haley-Macedone
I recently visited Lucy’s New York Style Pizza; unfortunately, my experience left much to be desired.
From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere felt off. The young girl working the register barely acknowledged us. She was quiet and unengaged, giving the impression that our presence was more inconvenient than anything else. There was no greeting, no smile—just a blank stare and a rushed transaction. It set a disappointing tone right from the start.
I had high hopes for the pizza based on its name, but those hopes were quickly dashed. When lifted, the pizza was overwhelmingly greasy, so it leaked grease onto the paper plate. Instead of being crisp or chewy like you’d expect from New York style, the crust was hard and dry throughout. Each bite was a chore—it was barely edible. The flavor wasn't there even after blotting away some of the grease.
All in all, between the lackluster customer service and the poor quality of the food, I won’t be returning. There are too many better options in town to waste time or money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cortland Wells
I had the unfortunate experience of getting food poisoning from this establishment. Myself, and both my companions were incredibly sick following our visit to this restaurant. While their lunch prices are good, it is not worth the pain you experience later.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Zaida Malave
I ordered an 18” margherita pizza and it was very disappointing. It seem that the tomatoes were thrown on top at the last minute, they were cold and they put the ends of the tomatoes. The tomatoes are supposed to be cooked along with the pizza. I was basically eating cheese pizza, since I had to remove them, but paying for a Margheria pizza. Never again.
Food: 1
Elise Hopkins
Dude I’ve been to New York, this joint did not shame its origin. Super super good, I’m bringing my food snob friends.
I'm not sure about dining in but that take and bake pizza was amazing. A good size for the price and ready as soon as I got there!
Brandon Gull
Came at 8:53, I know having customers late sucks but if your hours are until 9, the doors should be open until 9. I called and was told that orders are only taken until 8:45. If that’s even true, put it on Google. I love this places food, and I come here all the time, but this is so frustrating that I might not come back. I had lost my keys just before, and tried to hurry over before 9, and I made it, but I was refused. Change your Google hours.
NICOLE AGUERO
Great food! If only I could eat it! Came at 8:53pm, would’ve come sooner but my boyfriend lost his car keys and it was a mess. I understand it’s late but if you’re open until 9:00pm then you’re open until 9:00pm. If you take orders until 8:45pm maybe change your open hours!
Ismael MTA
I ordered a calzone. The flavor was there, but it wasn't as fluffy as I expected. There was also what tasted like garlic butter or oil on top, which enhanced the flavor. I arrived 30 minutes before closing, and they wouldn't let us dine in. It is the first time in my life that a restaurant has refused to let me dine in with that much time before closing. The woman at the front desk seemed tired or unhappy, she wasnt as nice as I would have expected, considering she had 30 min free of duties. Long story short, nice place to eat but weird vibes.
Rem Case
The flavor was trash crust was rock hard. Bread sticks were funky tasting and it took 25 min for me to get my food and the place was empty. 3/10 over all will not be coming back
What a fun pizza place! You can watch the pizza dough being thrown in the air while you sit at your table! It's pretty awesome. The New York style pizza is pretty tasty too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New York Style Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
The pizza itself is pretty good! Compares pretty well to actual New York pizza. It’s very thin, piping hot, and good flavor. We also got a calzone and the cheese bread. The calzone was much flatter than you’d expect. It was okay, but the pizza was better.
As for the cheese bread… I don’t know what they are going for, but it was not good. The bread was very dense. It was almost like a focaccia.
It was reasonably priced and it was nice to be able to sit and eat
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
I ordered to go. It was ready on time. However I grabbed the box and screamed because it was so hot and then they said oh sorry it’s hot. Could have told me ahead of time. Tastes liked cardboard, tough and the pizza was bland except for the sausage that was way too hot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
I love good pizza and this my go-to spot for pizza, they even sell it by the slice.
Without a doubt the pizza in the city and you can even buy it by the slice!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to love coming here and genuinely enjoyed the pizza, but recently it seems like this place is obsessed with closing before they're actually closed. I get it if it were opened late on the weekends, but on a Monday before the sun is even down? Relax. Pay your people a little overtime to close when you actually close, instead of soft closing an hour prior to actually closing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
I recently visited Lucy’s New York Style Pizza; unfortunately, my experience left much to be desired.
From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere felt off. The young girl working the register barely acknowledged us. She was quiet and unengaged, giving the impression that our presence was more inconvenient than anything else. There was no greeting, no smile—just a blank stare and a rushed transaction. It set a disappointing tone right from the start.
I had high hopes for the pizza based on its name, but those hopes were quickly dashed. When lifted, the pizza was overwhelmingly greasy, so it leaked grease onto the paper plate. Instead of being crisp or chewy like you’d expect from New York style, the crust was hard and dry throughout. Each bite was a chore—it was barely edible. The flavor wasn't there even after blotting away some of the grease.
All in all, between the lackluster customer service and the poor quality of the food, I won’t be returning. There are too many better options in town to waste time or money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I had the unfortunate experience of getting food poisoning from this establishment. Myself, and both my companions were incredibly sick following our visit to this restaurant. While their lunch prices are good, it is not worth the pain you experience later.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered an 18” margherita pizza and it was very disappointing. It seem that the tomatoes were thrown on top at the last minute, they were cold and they put the ends of the tomatoes. The tomatoes are supposed to be cooked along with the pizza. I was basically eating cheese pizza, since I had to remove them, but paying for a Margheria pizza. Never again.
Food: 1
Dude I’ve been to New York, this joint did not shame its origin. Super super good, I’m bringing my food snob friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm not sure about dining in but that take and bake pizza was amazing. A good size for the price and ready as soon as I got there!
Came at 8:53, I know having customers late sucks but if your hours are until 9, the doors should be open until 9. I called and was told that orders are only taken until 8:45. If that’s even true, put it on Google. I love this places food, and I come here all the time, but this is so frustrating that I might not come back. I had lost my keys just before, and tried to hurry over before 9, and I made it, but I was refused. Change your Google hours.
Great food! If only I could eat it! Came at 8:53pm, would’ve come sooner but my boyfriend lost his car keys and it was a mess. I understand it’s late but if you’re open until 9:00pm then you’re open until 9:00pm. If you take orders until 8:45pm maybe change your open hours!
I ordered a calzone. The flavor was there, but it wasn't as fluffy as I expected. There was also what tasted like garlic butter or oil on top, which enhanced the flavor. I arrived 30 minutes before closing, and they wouldn't let us dine in. It is the first time in my life that a restaurant has refused to let me dine in with that much time before closing. The woman at the front desk seemed tired or unhappy, she wasnt as nice as I would have expected, considering she had 30 min free of duties.
Long story short, nice place to eat but weird vibes.
The flavor was trash crust was rock hard. Bread sticks were funky tasting and it took 25 min for me to get my food and the place was empty. 3/10 over all will not be coming back
Loading...