I came in last minute with a work event, and without missing a beat the girl behind the counter told me it wasn't a problem, she would see what was on hand. She then put together a 60 cookie order with a couple of requests for allergies even. You guys are awesome and so prepared for anything!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free and nut free options available!Kid-friendliness: It's literally a candy store!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Gluten Free Red Velvet Cakebites
Jake Lawlor
Went for the first time, cupcakes were okay, the cake bites were so bad…couldn’t even eat them.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
K. Obert
Always decadent, the staff is wonderful, the facilities are adorable and clean
I remember coming years ago when it first opened in orem and the cake bites were amazing (2011-2012ish) but when back about 1 year ago and the cake bites tasted stale and dry. It was so sad :( my husband and I used to love the salted caramel cake bite.-Aubrey Messick
Emily Sanders
I got the peanut butter cupcake. It was good, but kind of forgettable. There are a few cupcakes in my life that I dream about, and I was hoping to find that here, but I didn't. That's okay. I wouldn't be sad if someone gifted me cupcakes from here, but I probably don't need to go back.
Julie B
I live out of state and made a special trip to the shop in Orem. I entered the store and was in there for several minutes before an employee even came out from the back. No welcome. I noticed that 1/3 of the s***** containers didn't have flavors listed and went I asked the employee she said she didn't know but guessed it would be ... That was the answer I got for all the questions I had regarding flavors until I just realized she really didn't know much at all about the product. I picked a couple and left. The s***** I tried was good but nothing to recommend. They had other things in the dessert case and things on display but honestly a lot of it looked old. I won't be going back in and can't recommend this place.
Shauna M.
I tried the funfetti cake bites at an event this past weekend, and fell in love. Now, this is a big deal because I HATE every cakebite and cake pop I’ve ever had. Today I drove to Sweet Tooth Fairy in search of them. I had the best experience. The customer service was phenomenal, and although they were out of the cake bites I wanted, I did get an amazing sugar cookie, thick delicious chocolate chip cookie, and like seven old fashioned lollipops—which by the way, I highly recommend. They have the best flavors and they taste so natural! Looking forward to becoming a regular!
Megan W.
I'm not a cupcake person, and these cupcakes are so good. They're moist, flavorful, unique and not too sweet. Sending a dozen is a perfect gift! The inside of the shop is cute and usually quiet. Don't forget you get a free cupcake on your birthday with your ID!
Jamie Olsen
We ordered our wedding cake here and it was phenomenal! Moist cake and addictive frosting. They decorated it exactly like the reference photo I gave them. We also ordered 5 dozen cupcakes and they decorated them perfectly like little succulents to match my wedding theme! We came back a year later to order cupcakes in the same flavors for our anniversary and they were just as delicious.
Visited because a friend has gluten allergies and was not disappointed. Their staff is nice and friendly with a small sweet shop feel
Patty Macias
Some of the best cupcakes we've ever had! You need to try these! We sampled give different flavors and they were all fantastic. The frosting won't too sweet. The cake is the perfect consistency. Price is on point; affordable!
kamal Ahmmad
Too sweet. The level of sweetness is similar to what we find in typical grocery stores like walmart. Don’t think they are worth the price.
Heather C.
I am not much of a dessert person overall but I do love a good treat here and there. In this specific area, there is all kinds of awesome places to eat so it only makes sense to also have a dessert stop close by.The sweet tooth fairy has a wide variety of options--they have all kinds of cookies and bars to choose from. It was sort of overwhelming if I am being honest. For most people, this is one of those spots where "you can't just choose one". As for the business itself, I really really loved it. I thought the set up was really beautiful and pristine. For a dessert shop, they really do a great job at keeping everything organized and spotless. I loved all the different treats you were able to choose from. They also had other awesome features like gift bags, when you are in a hurry to get a last minute gift or they even make awesome bags for friends during the holidays. As I said, I am not much of a 'sweet' person but I will say, I enjoyed the treats that I bought from The Sweet Tooth Fairy! They were made perfectly and very "instagrammable" ;)
emerald green
cakepops is just a sugar rush and no flavor. place isn’t as good as it used to be. would rather harmons
I came in last minute with a work event, and without missing a beat the girl behind the counter told me it wasn't a problem, she would see what was on hand. She then put together a 60 cookie order with a couple of requests for allergies even. You guys are awesome and so prepared for anything!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free and nut free options available!Kid-friendliness: It's literally a candy store!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Gluten Free Red Velvet Cakebites
Went for the first time, cupcakes were okay, the cake bites were so bad…couldn’t even eat them.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Always decadent, the staff is wonderful, the facilities are adorable and clean
Tasty treats. Good variety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies, Sweet Tooth Fairy Cupcakes
I remember coming years ago when it first opened in orem and the cake bites were amazing (2011-2012ish) but when back about 1 year ago and the cake bites tasted stale and dry. It was so sad :( my husband and I used to love the salted caramel cake bite.-Aubrey Messick
I got the peanut butter cupcake. It was good, but kind of forgettable. There are a few cupcakes in my life that I dream about, and I was hoping to find that here, but I didn't. That's okay. I wouldn't be sad if someone gifted me cupcakes from here, but I probably don't need to go back.
I live out of state and made a special trip to the shop in Orem. I entered the store and was in there for several minutes before an employee even came out from the back. No welcome. I noticed that 1/3 of the s***** containers didn't have flavors listed and went I asked the employee she said she didn't know but guessed it would be ... That was the answer I got for all the questions I had regarding flavors until I just realized she really didn't know much at all about the product. I picked a couple and left. The s***** I tried was good but nothing to recommend. They had other things in the dessert case and things on display but honestly a lot of it looked old. I won't be going back in and can't recommend this place.
I tried the funfetti cake bites at an event this past weekend, and fell in love. Now, this is a big deal because I HATE every cakebite and cake pop I’ve ever had. Today I drove to Sweet Tooth Fairy in search of them. I had the best experience. The customer service was phenomenal, and although they were out of the cake bites I wanted, I did get an amazing sugar cookie, thick delicious chocolate chip cookie, and like seven old fashioned lollipops—which by the way, I highly recommend. They have the best flavors and they taste so natural! Looking forward to becoming a regular!
I'm not a cupcake person, and these cupcakes are so good. They're moist, flavorful, unique and not too sweet. Sending a dozen is a perfect gift! The inside of the shop is cute and usually quiet. Don't forget you get a free cupcake on your birthday with your ID!
We ordered our wedding cake here and it was phenomenal! Moist cake and addictive frosting. They decorated it exactly like the reference photo I gave them. We also ordered 5 dozen cupcakes and they decorated them perfectly like little succulents to match my wedding theme! We came back a year later to order cupcakes in the same flavors for our anniversary and they were just as delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
Visited because a friend has gluten allergies and was not disappointed. Their staff is nice and friendly with a small sweet shop feel
Some of the best cupcakes we've ever had! You need to try these! We sampled give different flavors and they were all fantastic. The frosting won't too sweet. The cake is the perfect consistency. Price is on point; affordable!
Too sweet. The level of sweetness is similar to what we find in typical grocery stores like walmart. Don’t think they are worth the price.
I am not much of a dessert person overall but I do love a good treat here and there. In this specific area, there is all kinds of awesome places to eat so it only makes sense to also have a dessert stop close by.The sweet tooth fairy has a wide variety of options--they have all kinds of cookies and bars to choose from. It was sort of overwhelming if I am being honest. For most people, this is one of those spots where "you can't just choose one". As for the business itself, I really really loved it. I thought the set up was really beautiful and pristine. For a dessert shop, they really do a great job at keeping everything organized and spotless. I loved all the different treats you were able to choose from. They also had other awesome features like gift bags, when you are in a hurry to get a last minute gift or they even make awesome bags for friends during the holidays. As I said, I am not much of a 'sweet' person but I will say, I enjoyed the treats that I bought from The Sweet Tooth Fairy! They were made perfectly and very "instagrammable" ;)
cakepops is just a sugar rush and no flavor. place isn’t as good as it used to be. would rather harmons