Red Button Vintage Creamery Treat Shop

I work with an author, and we’re both huge fans of Red Button Vintage Creamery! The creamy, nostalgic flavors are unmatched, and every scoop feels like a trip back to simpler, sweeter times. We’d be thrilled to feature your brand in his upcoming book—a perfect partnership that brings flavor to life on every page. Red Button, let’s make magic together and share the joy with readers everywhere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Discovered this delicious goodness while visiting Hagerman, Idaho. Thank you for such a delightful treat! I haven't spotted it near my home town yet but it will be like winning the lottery when I do!

Food: 5

Purchased from local grocery store, creamy and great for root beer

Food: 5

Not about the shop. Just the nasty ice cream. Pralines & Caramel. It appeared the ice had melted and was refrozen and the pralines were nasty…old…rancid. Won’t be wasting money on this brand again.

Food: 1

I am writing this review not because of the red button ice cream shop but because there’s no other way to get a hold of them. This is the second ice cream that I have purchased that there were issues with it. The first was a chocolate chip cookie dough that had no chocolate chips or cookie dough. This next one is a fudge brownie and peanut butter Melted and then refrozen and sold. Absolutely disgusting! I’ve never had so many issues with an ice cream brand before.

Cannot say enough good things about my experience. The ice cream is some of the best I've had (would absolutely recommend the caramel cashew). We got the loaded bubble waffles and the waffles were made when we ordered so they were fresh and warm when served. Employees were kind and helpful.Also, the prices for their soft serve are unbelievable

This place has all sorts of Ice Cream delights with all sorts of things to add. It is very popular and seems to be busy often. There are all sorts of ice cream flavours, milk Shakes, and even gourmet cookies. It is located in the Macey's Grocery Store - spotted it when we went in for something else so we grabbed a couple of treats. They were so good we had to go back again the next day

Cannot say enough good things about my experience. The ice cream is some of the best I've had (would absolutely recommend the caramel cashew). We got the loaded bubble waffles and the waffles were made when we ordered so they were fresh and warm when served. Employees were kind and helpful.Also, the prices for their soft serve are unbelievable

I have purchased this ice cream numerous times (and I mean numerous). The last 3 times I have purchased cookies and cream, there literally have been no cookies, seriously. No complaints until now (of course, except for price ????). I have contacted Red Button with my concern/complaint with NO response. I would but vanilla if I wanted vanilla, but am expecting cookies too! And would appreciate a company response to a private concern/complaint.

We drove two hours to come try this place out because it’s my favorite ice cream brand and the people were nice and gave good suggestions when asked.We got the jar with all the crazy stuff and it was so cute !! But the doughnut was so stale and hard !!The candy was also stale and gross :((Anything other than the ice cream was pretty bad !But the ice cream was delicious and very soft / creamy !!!Just disappointed with how much the jar cost just for us not to eat any of it

The workers are so pleasant and helpful, the jar shakes are sooo over the top but worth it all! And when you just want a bite, the torch kong cone is your best friend.. cookies, soft serve, shakes and more!! Check them out!

Great little spot to meet up for a small ice cream cone with friends! I was pleasantly surprised!