Great pizza prob the best in Utah so far that I’ve had
Antonis Panayiotou
Great Pizza! Not like the other Pizza joints in the area which offer bbq chicken trash pizza. This is the real stuff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Management Team
Spectacular. If you are looking for east coast pizza this is the place. Worthy of high rankings on One Bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hanna Nez
Garlic knots were really hard and burned. I was looking forward to trying this place but don’t know if I’ll go back.
Deshavoo M
Pizza is great. Garlic knots were stale though and burnt☹️
Taylor Safford
We have ordered pizza from them before and it was great. This time they didn't put any sauce on it, burnt the bottom and it was like eating a flavorless piece of burnt bread. Disappointed!
Ray Grover
Good Day! As the future Mayor of Springville I Ray Grover highly recommend A Slice of NY Pizza as the absolute best (sorry Two Jacks!) pizza this side of Selinsgrove, PA! The quality is always constantly top notch as is the prompt service with the perfect Main Street location and an authentic East Coast pizzeria ambiance. The place always has me coming back for more and will you too! If you haven't tried the place yet give them a whirl, you won't regret it!
Liz Thibault
The pizza does remind me of NY style. I appreciated the sauce, it had the taste of San Marzano tomatoes. The crust was also very good and has a think and floppy consistency. It was not too greasy, but I would have loved it to be just slightly more well-done, or to have been asked if I would like it baked to well-done. Wish the service was me streamlined. Took the employee quite a while to pause what they were doing in the corner to acknowledge us.
Kasyn Gross
Husband went to boston couple months ago and said this establishments pizza was just like the ones over there. Margherita pizza was amazing!
Joe Leventhal
It's my favorite pizza place. 10 out of 10 pizza.. always clean and the service is amazing. You should go try it. I can't say enough good stuff about this place.
Honestly, it was fast food pizza. Nothing going to change your life here, but a fun place to try. The pizza doesn’t look that appetizing (some better lighting might go a long way), but it tasted great after it was heated up.
The decor sort of tries to be hip on one wall and the seating is good there. The other 90% of the place feels like a converted 7/11 and kind of haphazardly put together as an afterthought.
I’ve been here several times. They changed the lunch special, so the included drink is limited to a much smaller selection of canned drinks, but still a decent deal for a slice, drink, and a couple garlic knots.
aaron mangini
I wanted the traditional crispy crust that is associated with a good NY style pie, but the crust here was floppy and I even asked for them to baked it for a little longer to make sure I got a crispy crust. Which it was not. The young ladies behind the bar were great. The good thing is that a slice of pizza is inexpensive at only 3.50. maybe it was just the slice that I got, but Iight try it again due to the prices
Milo Valentine
used to come here for lunch twice a week maybe more. so good. owner was funny af the one time i saw him. just check his replies to reviews. again so good
Justin Pinegar
It’s either the best or worst pizza in town, depending on who is working. If the adults are there, it’s been great. When the young teens are working, it ranges from just ok to not edible.
For context, some of the younger workers messed up/burned my last two orders, so they gave me a free pizza to apologize. I thought that was pretty cool until I got home to find that free one was also burned and inexplicably made without sauce. So it was a little aggravating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Shelley Throckmorton
I love NY Style pizza. The concept here is great. Only problem is that it’s hit or miss when it comes to getting a good slice of pizza. I’ve had some really good slices there, but then I’ve also experienced picking up a slice to go- only to find that when I got home, it was burnt on the bottom from having been heated in their oven for too long. Be sure to check the bottom before you leave the store.
Great pizza prob the best in Utah so far that I’ve had
Great Pizza! Not like the other Pizza joints in the area which offer bbq chicken trash pizza. This is the real stuff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spectacular. If you are looking for east coast pizza this is the place. Worthy of high rankings on One Bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garlic knots were really hard and burned. I was looking forward to trying this place but don’t know if I’ll go back.
Pizza is great. Garlic knots were stale though and burnt☹️
We have ordered pizza from them before and it was great. This time they didn't put any sauce on it, burnt the bottom and it was like eating a flavorless piece of burnt bread. Disappointed!
Good Day! As the future Mayor of Springville I Ray Grover highly recommend A Slice of NY Pizza as the absolute best (sorry Two Jacks!) pizza this side of Selinsgrove, PA! The quality is always constantly top notch as is the prompt service with the perfect Main Street location and an authentic East Coast pizzeria ambiance. The place always has me coming back for more and will you too! If you haven't tried the place yet give them a whirl, you won't regret it!
The pizza does remind me of NY style. I appreciated the sauce, it had the taste of San Marzano tomatoes. The crust was also very good and has a think and floppy consistency. It was not too greasy, but I would have loved it to be just slightly more well-done, or to have been asked if I would like it baked to well-done. Wish the service was me streamlined. Took the employee quite a while to pause what they were doing in the corner to acknowledge us.
Husband went to boston couple months ago and said this establishments pizza was just like the ones over there. Margherita pizza was amazing!
It's my favorite pizza place.
10 out of 10 pizza.. always clean and the service is amazing.
You should go try it.
I can't say enough good stuff about this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Honestly, it was fast food pizza. Nothing going to change your life here, but a fun place to try. The pizza doesn’t look that appetizing (some better lighting might go a long way), but it tasted great after it was heated up.
The decor sort of tries to be hip on one wall and the seating is good there. The other 90% of the place feels like a converted 7/11 and kind of haphazardly put together as an afterthought.
I’ve been here several times. They changed the lunch special, so the included drink is limited to a much smaller selection of canned drinks, but still a decent deal for a slice, drink, and a couple garlic knots.
I wanted the traditional crispy crust that is associated with a good NY style pie, but the crust here was floppy and I even asked for them to baked it for a little longer to make sure I got a crispy crust. Which it was not. The young ladies behind the bar were great. The good thing is that a slice of pizza is inexpensive at only 3.50. maybe it was just the slice that I got, but Iight try it again due to the prices
used to come here for lunch twice a week maybe more. so good. owner was funny af the one time i saw him. just check his replies to reviews. again so good
It’s either the best or worst pizza in town, depending on who is working. If the adults are there, it’s been great. When the young teens are working, it ranges from just ok to not edible.
For context, some of the younger workers messed up/burned my last two orders, so they gave me a free pizza to apologize. I thought that was pretty cool until I got home to find that free one was also burned and inexplicably made without sauce. So it was a little aggravating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I love NY Style pizza. The concept here is great. Only problem is that it’s hit or miss when it comes to getting a good slice of pizza. I’ve had some really good slices there, but then I’ve also experienced picking up a slice to go- only to find that when I got home, it was burnt on the bottom from having been heated in their oven for too long. Be sure to check the bottom before you leave the store.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...