Just back from a family vacation and had Nottingham Seafood one evening. We ordered crabs and shrimp steamed by Nottingham, got oysters that we grilled, clams that we steamed, and oysters that we broiled. (Also had local steamed corn.) Prices reasonable within resort context and by local comparison. Everything tasted fresh and turned out great. This is the second year that we have placed a big order and both have turned out perfect. Plan on returning next year.
Robert H
Purchased the Little neck class & 2 pounds of shrimp for dinner. Great Seafood and good prices here.
Krisna Hoffman
Love getting seafood from here! Always fresh, great quality, and good prices.
Teena Lurlene
Great folks. Always fresh. Super helpful. Call ahead, your order will be waiting.
James Spratley
Bought flounder from them right before they closed for the season. Fish was spoiled when they sold it. Went back when they reopened, and basically told us thought luck that was last season. It istoyallywrong to knowingly sell bad fish. Never will return.
Tony H.
Not a restaurant but shows up when I specifically use "restaurant". Yelp needs to reorganize their stuff. This is aggravating. I hope Google is better. This is NOT an isolated case.
Atiyah A
Worth the drive, didn't get crabs but the shrimps finger licking good ?
Romeo Thakoer
I drove from NYC to here to pick up a half bushel of live blue crabs, 100 middle neck clams, and 50 oysters and it all came out to around $140 which is what just the oysters would have cost me here. I called the day before to let them know what I wanted just to make sure they had everything in stock. I got there the staff was friendly and they had my order ready to go. I literally drove 5 hours, spent 5 minutes in the show, and drove 5 hours back. My family and neighbors have pretty much decided that it's now a tradition that I'll be making this trip every summer so I'll definitely be back.
Good clean seafood the store smells clean also
This is a great Cape Charles seafood shop!
Just back from a family vacation and had Nottingham Seafood one evening. We ordered crabs and shrimp steamed by Nottingham, got oysters that we grilled, clams that we steamed, and oysters that we broiled. (Also had local steamed corn.) Prices reasonable within resort context and by local comparison. Everything tasted fresh and turned out great. This is the second year that we have placed a big order and both have turned out perfect. Plan on returning next year.
Purchased the Little neck class & 2 pounds of shrimp for dinner. Great Seafood and good prices here.
Love getting seafood from here! Always fresh, great quality, and good prices.
Great folks. Always fresh. Super helpful. Call ahead, your order will be waiting.
Bought flounder from them right before they closed for the season. Fish was spoiled when they sold it. Went back when they reopened, and basically told us thought luck that was last season. It istoyallywrong to knowingly sell bad fish. Never will return.
Not a restaurant but shows up when I specifically use "restaurant". Yelp needs to reorganize their stuff. This is aggravating. I hope Google is better. This is NOT an isolated case.
Worth the drive, didn't get crabs but the shrimps finger licking good ?
I drove from NYC to here to pick up a half bushel of live blue crabs, 100 middle neck clams, and 50 oysters and it all came out to around $140 which is what just the oysters would have cost me here. I called the day before to let them know what I wanted just to make sure they had everything in stock. I got there the staff was friendly and they had my order ready to go. I literally drove 5 hours, spent 5 minutes in the show, and drove 5 hours back. My family and neighbors have pretty much decided that it's now a tradition that I'll be making this trip every summer so I'll definitely be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best oyster prices in the USA
Good selection of local seafood. Employees were very friendly
Best price around on delicious fresh oysters!
Only ordered fresh shrimp to take home to cook.
Bought scallops to take back to the rental to cook. Seemed of good quality and fresh. Good price. Would go back.