Charley's Mill Street Sweets

218 Mill St, Farmville
(434) 392-9883

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Naomi Johnson

Ordered a pumpkin pie and half a carrot cake for Thanksgiving dinner. Everyone raved about them! The carrot cake especially was beautiful and delicious. Management has changed recently here, so older reviews mentioning rude service is not the current owners. The staff were very helpful when I ordered and picked up.

K Latham

Bought 2 cupcakes and 1 chocolate cookie. Was charged $13. We didn’t realize until after the charge went through. The server gave herself a $3 tip. Shame on us for not asking about the prices before ordering. Cupcake and cookies were smaller than you’d make yourself and they were just ok. There was also a limited supply of treats and the only beverage they had was coffee. Not worth the $$

J Marie

Their lemon bars are amazing, so good. I often get my Mom gluten free baked goods from here and they are always good.

Issy M

The carrot cake was heaven & the employees were pleasant

Kelly Leslie

Delicious, beautiful cakes!

Jessica Overton

We were excited to try some of the deserts from this location but we're greeted incredibly rude! Not friendly at all! So ended up leaving without ordering.The store was also run down and not clean at all!

Melinda T

Was looking forward to visiting after looking at pictures online but the pie slices we bought tasted terrible. Crust had a chalky mouthfeel and the filling tasted very artificial. It did not taste like it was made in house. Sorry I tried.

Courtney Campbell

Best place in town to get gluten free baked goods! The GF brownies were amazing, as well as the GF chocolate chip cookies. Hubby got the regular German chocolate cake and said it was the best he'd ever had. Love this place!!

natalie kay

Amazing peanut butter woopie pie

craftywriter

The cutest little sweet shop on the main street in Farmville. I could gain 20lbs just sitting there looking at all the goodies. We took a few to go with us. Vanilla cupcake, Strawberry cheesecake, and M&M cookie - sooo good! We were in Farmville to see Longwood University and the server was so nice. She was vegan, my daughter has a milk allergy so she tends to find vegan things that she can eat. It was like we were meant to meet her - so she could tell my daughter all the best places to find vegan stuff.

Michael Sosnkowski

Amazing place wonderful donuts and Tommy is the best couldn’t be happier getting sweets cakes and cookies here!! And he loves dogs!

Roland D

Stopped by for a sweet treat and coffee. They had a selection of cakes, cookies, and other sweets. We got 2 coffees, 1 scone, 1 eclair, and 1 cookie for less around $13. It is a must try.!

Karrah Kramer

This is by far my favorite sweet shop that we have visited durring our travels.

WEGL185

Loved this place! Tried six different treats and all were awesome. I do not think you could go wrong with any of the wonderful selections they had. Prices were very fair and the staff was very helpful and patient while we decided which to choose. Highly recommend this place. A must-stop for anyone with a sweet tooth.

darryl evans

Great service !!! Wonderful staff!! And AMAZING I MEAN AMAZING CUPCAKES, CAKES, COOKIES, AND THE CREAMSLICE CHEESECAKE WILL BRING BACK YOUR CHILDHOOD

Loading...

Charley's Mill Street Sweets

218 Mill St, Farmville, VA 23901
(434) 392-9883