New Brother's Pizza

Best pizza and cheese steak in town- - take out

The BEST customer service ever. My favorite place to order from!!!

I can only comment on the pizza as that was all I got. It was about a 30 minute wait on a Friday night, which was not bad. It was ready when I got there. Staff were very friendly. The quality of the ingredients was fantastic; I haven't had cheese like that on a pizza in a long time.

I will definitely stop by the next time I find myself in this area.

Excellent Italian food! Service is fantastic. You can't go wrong with anything from here.

Amazing pizza and great prices!

Pineapple, onion, mushrooms & black Olives delivered in a timely manner. Perfect pizza, I'll be ordering from New Brothers Pizza again!

I love food. I love GOOD food. It took me 41 years to finally eat here and I'm making up for lost time and hoping I kick the bucket face first in a dish of pasta! I've told everyone... This is the best tortellini I've had in decades. And it's not an exaggeration. It's perfect. The description says with peas, spinach and tomatoes. And then you get it and there's... Peas, spinach and tomatoes in it? Grand slam. It's definitely something someone came up with late one night and it was awesome so they decided to put in on the menu and man, am I glad they did. The portion is huge, however I much regrettably admit I've crushed whole dishes during an episode of my favorite cartoons. It's positively perfect. And the burgers and fries are not to be left out. Cheaper than going to the fast food drive thru and a zillion times better. If there's a number bigger than a zillion, that's what I mean. Awesome. Spectacular. Incredible. That's what New Brother's is.

The BEST extra grilled shrimp ive ever tasted and I asked for well done onion rings and they were perfecto!!!

I never write reviews , butttt I have come to absolutely loooove this place! Food is Always fresh and hot. Delivery is fast , price✨great. In my opinion the best in the area. Never disappoints!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza here is wonderful. It's pick up or delivery only, but I don't find that to be a problem. It's right off a main street, which makes finding it pretty easy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great dinner again.

Food: 4

Service: 4

This is hands down the best pizza place in this Augusta County and city of Staunton!!!
Reminds me of home. NY pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Very good! Drove through town and the pizza was nice and hot. Not greasy!!

Food: 5

Staying at a hotel in the area, decided to order delivery. Food was great, pizza and fried pickles were still hot on delivery. The person who took my order and my delivery person were great. Highly recommend this place.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza ever! I’m a pizza lover and the supreme Sicilian is Devine. You can’t stop eating it lol and it’s huge! Best steak cheese sandwiches too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Stuffed Pizza, Supreme Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza