Brooklyn Brothers Pizza

We waited 15 years passing by this pizzeria - tried it tonight - and WOW!!!!! This pizza was phenomenal!!! Everything from the cheese, to the crust…. We will be recurring customers! Best pizza hands down!! Don’t miss out on 15 years like we did!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Some of the best pizza out there and you won't find more delicious meatballs anywhere! Service is always amazing and the employees are friendly.

My family and I stopped in to order takeout for dinner and Cody (apologies if misspelled) was so friendly and accommodating. Cody gave us everything we needed for our takeout order without us even asking. We ordered one of their specialty pies and it was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy and everything tasted fresh. The hospitality and pizza are definitely worth checking out.

They have a gf (gluten free) pizza 🍕 and as far as GF pizza goes, it is pretty good 👍🏻 thanks for the option, because I eat an entirely GF diet and wouldn't be able to order anything else here without it! This makes Brooklyn Brother's a great pick for the whole family 😊

Wonderful food and friendly staff. My family and I love this place!

Very clean. Friendly service. Good for kids. Food was fresh and hot. Couldn't really ask for much more.

Got the spaghetti meat sauce. Let's say gross no meat in the sauce. Won't be going back.

Great food and service! Loved it! Especially for my first time there! Will definitely be back.

We ordered the Rueben sandwiches. The corned beef was delicious. I didn't care for the thick crust on the bread. It didn't taste or look like rye bread which shows on the menu. The kraut was a little stringy. Also, the swiss cheese wasn't melted & kinda of rubbery. I would order again & ask for a different bread & no kraut & no cheese.

Wonderful service and food

Had the gluten white pizza. $17.59. Crust was probably frozen. Toppings were cheaply distributed. Nothing to call Home and tell Ma about.

Really great service, well done fries, and a gyro that's not thin sliced or shaved. super delicious!

The pizza, salads and appetizers are excellent whether you dine in or out. We live in Warrenton and have several places closer….we’ve tried them all, but the food here is great.

Enjoyed the Brooklyn Special Pizza. It was a meat lovers dream. I can not remember having better. It was delicious and paired with a Ceaser Salad made for an excellent meal. Fast service, friendly staff and a comfortable family friendly atmosphere made for a very enjoyable dinner.

Stopped in for lunch. The atmosphere is nice, slightly upscale and quiet. The menu is extensive. I opted for two slices of pepperoni, their lunch suggestion. Folks, this is authentic NY style pizza! It was amazing! And the price was incredible, landing in the fast food combo range.

Service was excellent and the owner was on the premises checking with folks to make sure they enjoyed their food.

I’ll be back!!