While visiting family in Lynchburg, they suggested we go to Mr. goodies. It was a beautiful Saturday afternoon with great weather, so they were crowded, but we found a table and placed our orders. We had everything from ice cream cones to the brownies and the apple dumplings with ice cream. Everything was delicious. It was fun to share with family. Great atmosphere in the outdoors watching families and people with dogs. Everyone was there for the common goal of having a great time and Mr. goodies delivered. We can’t wait to go back.Parking: Mr. Goody’s is a food court or food truck as we call it in other places. On a parking lot so plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone, Strawberry, Brownie, Apple Dumpling
Keith R.
As far as I can tell - this is the best soft serve ice cream option in Lynchburg. I'm particularly fond of the Banana Nutella Malted Milkshake (don't knock it until you try it). You do have to ask they be extra thorough on mixing it though. Their other options are good as well. I'm personally not a fan of their brownies, but I see others like them.
Stephanie Bushway
The best ice cream in the entire world, not to mention the cutest truck, and the sweetest employees. My husband and I have gone on “Goodies Dates” for years. I just had a baby this past year and I am determined that his first taste of ice cream is going to be mister goodies. 100/10
If you are on a trip I definitely recommend!! This place is so good any time I got an iced or ice cream it was good. There was a line but it was worth it. Also the service was very fast and sweet. You should go!!!
Felicia Dobyns
I was in love with the fact they rolled my ice cream cone in fruity pebbles and the had the soft serve mixed ice cream but they have several different soft serve flavors and they have different kinds of cereal to pick
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Torie P.
The absolute best place for ice cream in Lynchburg!!!! Mister Goodies is a LYH staple!
Syndi Caruvana
Dude. This is the best ice cream. The servings are massive. It's like going to a fair without actually having to go to a fair. We've gone the last two nights in a row and will probably go back tomorrow night. I got a hot fudge sundae and it comes with whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry as well. I got it both nights and will probably get it again. I haven't been able to finish it either night, there's so much (I'm getting a small). They have forty bajillion things on their menu, and all the items my group has tried so far have been great.Definitely a great low-key casual date place to share some ice cream.
Mark Morrison
My first visit & I'm impressed with the service & quality of their signature offering the chocolate fudge brownie topped with vanilla ice cream chopped nuts whipped cream & cherry on top!Warm brownie helped melt the ice cream! Delicious! I ate the whole thing! Big one!
Visiting from Ohio. My son said it’s a Liberty favorite!! This is a Ooey-Gooey PB sundae. So good!!
Brandi Loan (Starenska)
The ice cream creations are outstanding here! The sherbet texture was not smooth, but it was a minor fact against the other great ice cream selections. A must try!
LaTisha E.
My family LOVES Mister Goodies for their pleasant service, friendly atmosphere, and excellent ice cream. This is the perfect place to go because each of us has different tastes: from vegan/non-dairy options, to salty/sweet, to traditional soft serve cones and sundaes! We love being personally greeted and told about the newest flavors. We go as often as we can before the season comes to an end!
Aubrey J.
I can't believe it has taken me so long to review one of my favorite establishments. Mister Goodies has perhaps the best soft serve ice cream I have ever had. I am frequently blown away by how good the limited edition soft serve options are with the ability to make two of the flavors into a twist (shout out to my favorite, coffee and cookie butter), but I am also a massive fan of their chocolate soft serve that is always available. Believe me when I say that the portions are very generous, and their prices are overall very affordable! Additionally, the staff is always friendly; the cashiers are usually young girls that are likely college students or even high school students. I also love to eat outside when the weather is nice and watch all the dogs (and sometimes cats) that other customers bring. Mister goodies has always been a wonderful place to meet up with friends and to bring family to when they're in town. Mister goodies is one of the places I will miss most since moving away recently.
Lori Kingrey
Cones are massive! A large is like 6 inches tall over top of the cone. I opted for the kids cone, and it was perfect. It's like a McDonald's regular cone. A very good price for the amount that you get!
Huge portions! WOW! Great flavors!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ooye Goodey Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae
Always
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
While visiting family in Lynchburg, they suggested we go to Mr. goodies. It was a beautiful Saturday afternoon with great weather, so they were crowded, but we found a table and placed our orders. We had everything from ice cream cones to the brownies and the apple dumplings with ice cream. Everything was delicious. It was fun to share with family. Great atmosphere in the outdoors watching families and people with dogs. Everyone was there for the common goal of having a great time and Mr. goodies delivered. We can’t wait to go back.Parking: Mr. Goody’s is a food court or food truck as we call it in other places. On a parking lot so plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: Very family friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone, Strawberry, Brownie, Apple Dumpling
As far as I can tell - this is the best soft serve ice cream option in Lynchburg. I'm particularly fond of the Banana Nutella Malted Milkshake (don't knock it until you try it). You do have to ask they be extra thorough on mixing it though. Their other options are good as well. I'm personally not a fan of their brownies, but I see others like them.
The best ice cream in the entire world, not to mention the cutest truck, and the sweetest employees. My husband and I have gone on “Goodies Dates” for years. I just had a baby this past year and I am determined that his first taste of ice cream is going to be mister goodies. 100/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone, Ooye Goodey Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae, Ice Cream Strawberry Cheescake, Cake Batter Ice Cream
If you are on a trip I definitely recommend!! This place is so good any time I got an iced or ice cream it was good. There was a line but it was worth it. Also the service was very fast and sweet. You should go!!!
I was in love with the fact they rolled my ice cream cone in fruity pebbles and the had the soft serve mixed ice cream but they have several different soft serve flavors and they have different kinds of cereal to pick
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
The absolute best place for ice cream in Lynchburg!!!! Mister Goodies is a LYH staple!
Dude. This is the best ice cream. The servings are massive. It's like going to a fair without actually having to go to a fair. We've gone the last two nights in a row and will probably go back tomorrow night. I got a hot fudge sundae and it comes with whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry as well. I got it both nights and will probably get it again. I haven't been able to finish it either night, there's so much (I'm getting a small). They have forty bajillion things on their menu, and all the items my group has tried so far have been great.Definitely a great low-key casual date place to share some ice cream.
My first visit & I'm impressed with the service & quality of their signature offering the chocolate fudge brownie topped with vanilla ice cream chopped nuts whipped cream & cherry on top!Warm brownie helped melt the ice cream! Delicious! I ate the whole thing! Big one!
Restaurantji Recommends
Visiting from Ohio. My son said it’s a Liberty favorite!! This is a Ooey-Gooey PB sundae. So good!!
The ice cream creations are outstanding here! The sherbet texture was not smooth, but it was a minor fact against the other great ice cream selections. A must try!
My family LOVES Mister Goodies for their pleasant service, friendly atmosphere, and excellent ice cream. This is the perfect place to go because each of us has different tastes: from vegan/non-dairy options, to salty/sweet, to traditional soft serve cones and sundaes! We love being personally greeted and told about the newest flavors. We go as often as we can before the season comes to an end!
I can't believe it has taken me so long to review one of my favorite establishments. Mister Goodies has perhaps the best soft serve ice cream I have ever had. I am frequently blown away by how good the limited edition soft serve options are with the ability to make two of the flavors into a twist (shout out to my favorite, coffee and cookie butter), but I am also a massive fan of their chocolate soft serve that is always available. Believe me when I say that the portions are very generous, and their prices are overall very affordable! Additionally, the staff is always friendly; the cashiers are usually young girls that are likely college students or even high school students. I also love to eat outside when the weather is nice and watch all the dogs (and sometimes cats) that other customers bring. Mister goodies has always been a wonderful place to meet up with friends and to bring family to when they're in town. Mister goodies is one of the places I will miss most since moving away recently.
Cones are massive! A large is like 6 inches tall over top of the cone. I opted for the kids cone, and it was perfect. It's like a McDonald's regular cone. A very good price for the amount that you get!