The Seafood Shack

10744 Buckley Hall Rd, Mathews
(804) 725-6934

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sig N

New to the area! Love it!! So good!! Everyone was so sweet! Food was 10/10

David Cooper

I picked up a dozen oysters in the shell and they are nice and salty and the crab and shrimp salad is the best. Thanks for the great food.

Sarah Jones

Delicious food and friendly staff

Jeremy Shaarda

Awesome food and customer service. Until I tried this place today, I would drive elsewhere for oysters. Not anymore. The food was amazing and the owner made it a point to speak with me. Will definitely be back soon and will be a new regular spot

Cindy Varnado

People here are very nice.Was in earlier and bought some crab meat and crab dip.Had dinner here tonight.Ava was our waitress Very nice,and attentive.We had the soft shell 🦀 basket.It was good,but being fried in Tempura batter,was on the greasy side.It would have been much better fried in a lighter batter.

Jacky Fitzgerald

The service, food, drinks and quality was AWESOME, I had the oyster tacos and definitely recommend, my boyfriend had the bloody mary and the ribs, best bloody mary and Ribs hes ever had, definitely a 10/10

Crystal Swanson

We decided to stop in after seeing this restaurant/market from the road. We were greeted immediately and asked if we wanted to shop the market or if we were there to dine in. Once we let the waitress know we were there to dine in, we were seated immediately. The menu had something for everyone, and I was pleasantly suprised to find some great cocktails listed. We ordered an appetizer and two entrees and all of the food was amazing. I sadly didn't get a lot of photos here, but everything was excellent. Our waitress even was concerned since we weren't able to eat much (we had eaten lunch only a few hours before, it was NOT due to the quality of our meals!). If I find myself in the area again, we will definitely be patronizing this great spot for both picking up fresh market seafood to cook and dining in!

Rosemarie Vea-Hunt

Light lunch of side salads, hushpuppies and 1lb. steamed shrimp. Everything was very fresh and the shrimp were large, deveined, and cooked perfectly. We spent about $40 for the two of us before tip.

Daniel Asencios

Quaint seafood market + restaurant big on flavor and freshness. Dine indoors, bar-side, or on the front porch. They sell Boar's Head deli meats and fillet cuts of salmon, tuna, snapper, and more. We stopped in for lunch on a weekday ordering the fried oyster po boy plus steamed crab legs and shrimp. The po boy was top notch--woulda preferred it with apple/carrot slaw instead of lettuce but yummy nonetheless. Seafood was steamed to perfection. Orange crushes we're refreshing too! If this place was on the waterfront it'd be five stars all-around.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bradley Carr

Best seafood and service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Evie M

My friends had the crab tip, shrimp tacos and shrimp roll 🔥 I had this delicious lemon, blueberry, ricotta cake. Great food! The Painkiller cocktail surprised with orange blackberry notes. A definite yes, please let's do this again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Cochran

Great local joint!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Nycum

Stopped here to both have lunch and see what seafood they had for sale. Lunch was good, had the cod sandwich which was sizable and the cole slaw was an excellent side. Sat at the bar and the young lady was very attentive. Not much to choose from in the seafood case so was disappointed there.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kelly Spicer

Omg! Had the most amazing food. Crab Legs cooked perfect and the hush puppies! Yummy! 10 out 10! Extra bonus the waitress was excellent and her name was Kelly Ann!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pippi Frazier

My step mom dropped her food on the table and didn't get a new one or a discount and she had too pick it up off of the table and eat it

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Loading...