Anthony's Pizza III

161 Warrior Dr, Stephens City
(540) 869-9055

Recent Reviews

Sort by
J B

Really love the fact that they have the large salad and drink special for 10.99 and when you're sharing with your husband it is perfect perfect size and full of toppings very happy with the way you guys make your salads
Love you guys

Lloyd De France

We had a small pizza, double pepperoni, and a small salad. Although the pizza was good, I wouldn't call it a double pepperoni pizza. There were maybe two or three very small pepperoni slices on each slice of pizza. In other places we've eaten, the pepperoni slices overlaped each other when we ordered double pepperoni. The salad was very good, and included olives and peppers, which is a nice choice. All in all, a good place to eat.

Ken Mcdonald

The food is Always yummy!

Jason Hinkle

In the area for work and stopped in yesterday and back today. Great food, great service, great price!

Jason Hinkle

I was in the area for work and was looking for a local spot to grab some lunch. I’m so glad Anthoney’s popped up. I just grabbed the lunch special #2 which was two slices, two toppings, and a drink… <$10
I’ve found a lot of time the slices specials can be funny as they pizza isn’t always so fresh. Anthony’s killed it today. Crust moist with a crisp, cheese nicely melted, and topping totally covering those slices!
I will be going back so we will see if they continue to meet the standard they set.

Virginia Basher

Yummy pizza (we love the Sicilian), and sweet service. Our toddler spilled and someone immediately came, talked about their kid, and empathized and helped clean it up.

Andrew Panitz

Just had pizza from here and definitely 1 of the worst pizza’s I ever tasted. It tasted so sweet, extremely thin and very floppy. When a restaurant describes their pizza as NY style that is usually the kiss of death. I lived in NY and by no stretch of the imagination is this NY style.

Kendall Mckee

Wow the best pizza I have had in a long time and the Chesse steak is to die for! Been coming here for a while now and the two boys (mangers) are so nice. I love coming in there and all the employees are so welcoming and they are always busy keeping that place clean! Well done everyone!

Stephanie clark

Service and staff is excellent! Great for team meals! Always willing to work with the community!

William Canaboa

My pizza was greasy and the manager is RUDE!!!

Henry J Shackleton

Once upon a time, this pizza place was a hidden gem—a spot where the perfect slice could make your heart skip a beat and the sides were just as enchanting. But today, it felt like my love story with this place came to an unfortunate end. We ordered two plates of fries, one promised to be draped in bacon and mozzarella, the other dressed with steak, bacon, and mozzarella. But what we received told a different story. The first was mostly a pile of sad, undercooked fries with barely a whisper of bacon or cheese. As for the second dish? It came overflowing with what was supposed to be steak—yet, to my dismay, it was clearly hamburger, not the tender, flavorful steak I'd envisioned. A mislabeling, perhaps? Whatever it was, it fell far short of expectation. And then, there was the pizza. Oh, how I had high hopes for that pepperoni and onion creation, a classic combination that, in the past, would have been reliable and satisfying. But today, something was terribly wrong. A fishy taste crept into the mix, turning a simple slice into something confusing and unpleasant. My heart sank with each bite, wondering how a once-beloved dish could lose its charm so completely. It was hard not to think of Roma’s, the place we usually go to, but it was closed today, leaving us no choice but to seek comfort here. Sadly, that comfort never arrived. I remember when this pizza place was dependable—a place where you could enjoy a meal and leave with a smile. But today felt like the end of an era, and it’s with a heavy heart that I say I won’t be returning. Sometimes, places change, and what once was magical fades away. It’s a shame, because this used to be a great spot. But now? It’s only a shadow of what it used to be.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Laurie May

Had deliver from here before .
Very good food . They have exact directions on how to find my house.

This time took over an hour and fifteen minutes to get food. Once he was able to locate our house. The subs was lukewarm and so soggy. I could not eat.
Terrible subs.
Really should get a credit for these subs.

Always where good . Don't understand.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Keyara McDowell

This place used to be good but they have gone down hill. Salads are brown and skimpy. They're forgetting items. Food isn't tasting the same. Something needs to be fixed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Natasha Timbers

very nice place to eat and order the staff are excellent there food is awesome and they have great deals once a warrior always a warrior.

Kid-friendliness: the kids have a great time and they get to watch tv

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak and Cheese, Chef Salad, Cheese Steak, Cheese Burger Sub

Josh Tanner

Always great food and service.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak and Cheese

Loading...