New York City Pizza

Cedar Dr, Sterling
(703) 956-9065

Recent Reviews

Samantha Bettis

First time trying after getting flyer in the mail. Don't use this place. Took almost 2 hours to get a XL pizza and 10 wings. I live 2 miles from this place! We called 3 times asking where it was each time it was 10 minutes away. It gets here and it's cold. Tasted blah.. Not worth the money out taster. Didn't even offer to Fix it. Lesson learned. Never again.

Chris Hawkes

Thought they might be fake reviews but it was on time, hot, correct and good. I ordered delivery online with no issues.

Sandy S.

Ordered from them through Door Dash and the quoted delivery time of 30-35 minutes ended up being 70-75 minutes. The delivery guy shoved them pizza at me while talking on his phone and it was stone cold. This is a place to eat pizza at the restaurant vs. delivery. I won't ever order from Santini's again and wish I determine the tip after the deliver.

Ellie Parsa

We ordered their house special for the first time last night and we loved it.

Sari Schray

Great place. We have ordered three times from them and each time arrived on time, hot and tasty! I love that it is Halal! Our first order we got a small pizza and a pepperoni stromboli! My granddaughter is the pickest eater and scarfed down the pizza. The second time the hubby and I order a meat filled stromboli and wings

Sari S.

I haven't been inside but have ordered online 3 times now and have been extremely impressed! Arrived exactly on time and was hot and delicious! On top of this, it is halal! Definitely recommend this place.

Scot Hatt

Pizza is on point with a great tasting crust. We've tried buffalo, pepperoni and cheese separately and the family have enjoyed them all. Wings are meaty and standard Buffalo style which I prefer. Delivery ordering is a breeze, courteous and always on time. We have tried all of the other pizza joints in the area over the years and this one is currently making a better pie and providing a better experience.

Tracy V.

The pizza is pretty good, not amazing pizza. The sauce is on the sweet side- which I personally really like!

Mike Langford

I ordered via Grubhub on Thanksgiving not knowing that it was closed. The owner personally called me to make sure it wasn’t an order by mistake and made/delivered my order. It really made my day and truly appropriate his willingness to make my order when he had other plans.

Tabish M.

Ordered a crispy chicken sandwich, waited 10 minutes it was just a chicken patty it looked like they just warmed up no taste. Really a rip off. Wouldn't go back.

nada khalil

I tried this place it’s truly New York City pizza style and me and my family we tried calzone and it was yummy we’re definetly coming back

Jacqueline Paradiso

Tried this place after reading a lot of great reviews! I love New York style pizza but it almost impossible to find around here. Crust is fantastic. Crisp with a good chew. I think I found my new pizza place! Also, the person who took my order over the phone, as well as the delivery gentleman were very friendly. :)

Robin B

This place is a great find, not only is the pizza very tasty, but the owner is very helpful and nice. The pizza crust and sauce is great just off RT 7 easy to get in and out of. Please go check it out!

Rob Rose

Great Pizza Great People! Very friendly and really good food. I highly recommend.

Ann R.

Delicious pizza and gorgeous calzones! Calzones take a little time to prepare, but they're totally worth it. Will be back to try their lunch specials. Surprised by the negative reviews about service. I've only had very pleasant, polite interactions with the staff there.

Load More