Avoid - quality is not even close what it used to be.
Been a patron for many years, went for Valentine’s Day and it was really disappointing.
The seafood dish was tasteless, also advised as “Seared Jumbo shrimp, Scallops, and clams”
The manicotti was also undercooked and rubbery - lifeless.
Shrimp were about a quarter in size, very small, not seared (advertised as Jumbo seared shrimp) and the scallops were shriveled up smaller than a dime. Tasted super frozen.
Sent a PM to the restaurant, explaining my concerns and no response at all. Not even “sorry for your bad experience…”
Explained to the server the dish as just bad, no visit from the manager and the staff was more concerned with sitting by the bathrooms on Cell phones instead of making a memorable experience for a long time customer.
Mike Reuter
had to stop in for a recess at court. got Italian sub and side of pasta salad. pretty good! feeling full. Thank You!! Great service from the younger of the two waitresses.
Siuvhne Fitzclansai
I was underwhelmed. Rave reviews from locals. We ordered the scallops. For $25 you get 6 and a small scoop of Risotto. The texture of the Risotto was more mushy than creamy, and the scallops relied heavily on the cream sauce for flavor ... which quite frankly might not have been the right flavor profile, but that's purely subjective. I can't speak to the pizza because, sadly, we were not advised that it was primarily a pizza place.
Food: 3
S P
$4.50 for a soda with no refills?!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Bill Bullock
We always have great food at this location versus the location on Bridge Road location.
David
Make sure you try the bruschetta. Best I've ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Perham-Lippman
My son and ate dinner at Amici’s and the service was great, but the food was absolutely terrible. He ordered a 10” inch cheese pizza that arrived undercooked, doughy in spots and lukewarm. I ordered caprese bites which came with mozzarella that was rubbery and tasted like it was expired. It was inedible. I also ordered a steak tip salad. The steak was prepared medium rare as requested and had a great flavor. The salad itself tasted like “Burger King Foot Lettuce” and was also inedible. The best part of our meal was the lovely service provided by Skyler and if we ever came again would probably just stick with the water.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
S Claud
The one star is pushing it. I don’t think everyone is welcome to this establishment. Just my opinion. Customer service as well sucks. They got my order wrong twice. Keep in mind I had to leave work TWICE and still was disappointed. Brown gooey substance in my shrimp scampi
Cyndie Fourdraine - Farnsworth
They make great pizza BUT- on a quiet afternoon with an hour and a half lead time they lost half our order. I had to wait, standing At the counter with no discount, seat while waiting or offer of refreshment for my inconvenience
First time here and had a great experience! Food was Delicious! Service was so friendly and prompt. Try the Hot Caprese Queso Appetizer, you won't regret it. It was soooo good! I liked how we can do half of one kind and half another kind on one large pizza. We can't wait to come back and try more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Darr
Walking in you can tell it's old and slightly rundown. Your typical small town pizza place. We get sat outside and order our drinks and pizza. I get a 10in pepperoni (which in the pic I had already taken a bite) and my wife get a 10in margarita. My pizza was just ok. Very much tasted like a lot of other small town pizzas, seems like a Sysco product tbh. My wife's pizza for a margarita was weird. Typically a margarita pizza has thin slices of whole tomatoes with fresh basil and melted slabs of mozzarella. This was basically a cheese pizza with basil and diced tomatoes thrown on top. Pizza is pizza, but this wasn't the best, also not the worst I've had.
Never go wrong with fig and prosciutto! And love the doughball for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Samantha Ledford Linneman
We were there 35 minutes before my daughter got her drink, despite asking several times. Then it was another 35 minutes after my husband and I got our dinner before my daughter got hers. She completely forgot to put her dinner order in until we asked. We ended up taking hers to go. By the time we got home, she didn't want it. People who came in after us got their apps, dinner, and left before we got our apps.
The same waitress boxed our food up in the back and forgot to give us one of our pizzas. SHE NEVER APOLOGIZED, NOT EVEN ONCE. I don't mind paying premium for dinner out, but when the service is this poor, it ruins the evening out. I will not bother to go back. She had two tables and acted like my 19 year old daughter wasn't even there.
Avoid - quality is not even close what it used to be. Been a patron for many years, went for Valentine’s Day and it was really disappointing. The seafood dish was tasteless, also advised as “Seared Jumbo shrimp, Scallops, and clams” The manicotti was also undercooked and rubbery - lifeless. Shrimp were about a quarter in size, very small, not seared (advertised as Jumbo seared shrimp) and the scallops were shriveled up smaller than a dime. Tasted super frozen. Sent a PM to the restaurant, explaining my concerns and no response at all. Not even “sorry for your bad experience…” Explained to the server the dish as just bad, no visit from the manager and the staff was more concerned with sitting by the bathrooms on Cell phones instead of making a memorable experience for a long time customer.
had to stop in for a recess at court. got Italian sub and side of pasta salad. pretty good! feeling full. Thank You!! Great service from the younger of the two waitresses.
I was underwhelmed. Rave reviews from locals. We ordered the scallops. For $25 you get 6 and a small scoop of Risotto. The texture of the Risotto was more mushy than creamy, and the scallops relied heavily on the cream sauce for flavor ... which quite frankly might not have been the right flavor profile, but that's purely subjective. I can't speak to the pizza because, sadly, we were not advised that it was primarily a pizza place.
Food: 3
$4.50 for a soda with no refills?!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
We always have great food at this location versus the location on Bridge Road location.
Make sure you try the bruschetta. Best I've ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son and ate dinner at Amici’s and the service was great, but the food was absolutely terrible. He ordered a 10” inch cheese pizza that arrived undercooked, doughy in spots and lukewarm. I ordered caprese bites which came with mozzarella that was rubbery and tasted like it was expired. It was inedible. I also ordered a steak tip salad. The steak was prepared medium rare as requested and had a great flavor. The salad itself tasted like “Burger King Foot Lettuce” and was also inedible. The best part of our meal was the lovely service provided by Skyler and if we ever came again would probably just stick with the water.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
The one star is pushing it. I don’t think everyone is welcome to this establishment. Just my opinion. Customer service as well sucks. They got my order wrong twice. Keep in mind I had to leave work TWICE and still was disappointed. Brown gooey substance in my shrimp scampi
They make great pizza BUT- on a quiet afternoon with an hour and a half lead time they lost half our order. I had to wait, standing At the counter with no discount, seat while waiting or offer of refreshment for my inconvenience
Nice place to sit & enjoy some great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
First time here and had a great experience!
Food was Delicious! Service was so friendly and prompt.
Try the Hot Caprese Queso Appetizer, you won't regret it. It was soooo good!
I liked how we can do half of one kind and half another kind on one large pizza.
We can't wait to come back and try more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walking in you can tell it's old and slightly rundown. Your typical small town pizza place. We get sat outside and order our drinks and pizza. I get a 10in pepperoni (which in the pic I had already taken a bite) and my wife get a 10in margarita. My pizza was just ok. Very much tasted like a lot of other small town pizzas, seems like a Sysco product tbh. My wife's pizza for a margarita was weird. Typically a margarita pizza has thin slices of whole tomatoes with fresh basil and melted slabs of mozzarella. This was basically a cheese pizza with basil and diced tomatoes thrown on top. Pizza is pizza, but this wasn't the best, also not the worst I've had.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Margherita Pizza
Never go wrong with fig and prosciutto! And love the doughball for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were there 35 minutes before my daughter got her drink, despite asking several times. Then it was another 35 minutes after my husband and I got our dinner before my daughter got hers. She completely forgot to put her dinner order in until we asked. We ended up taking hers to go. By the time we got home, she didn't want it. People who came in after us got their apps, dinner, and left before we got our apps. The same waitress boxed our food up in the back and forgot to give us one of our pizzas. SHE NEVER APOLOGIZED, NOT EVEN ONCE. I don't mind paying premium for dinner out, but when the service is this poor, it ruins the evening out. I will not bother to go back. She had two tables and acted like my 19 year old daughter wasn't even there.
Absolutely nothing to complain about!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...