This is only 1 of 2 eat-in restaurants on the island, and it was closed when we stayed there. It looked like it would have been a good choice. Wish it were open.
Loni Renee
We especially love the bread sticks with the homemade marinara sauce. The hoagies are made with such high quality meats. Everything we have tried has been exceptional.
Eli Parks
I've always wanted a coffee stop on the island and Muddy Toes met those expectations and then some!! The food and desserts are amazing as well, and when it comes to good people, go no further than the staff here at Muddy Toes Cafe. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Rutkowski
Great place for lunch on Tangier Island! The crab dip and the Brie/bacon/blackberry jam sandwich were delicious. Everyone behind the counter was super friendly.
Paul King
Lovely place. Really enjoyed the sandwiches and coffee here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzanna Shackelford
It was delightful speaking with the owners.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Amanda Parks
Truly this is the best place to go on the island. Delicious meals, scrumptious desserts, refreshing cold beverages, and so much more! The locals like myself are in love with this quaint Cafe. If you're visiting Tangier or plan to do so then I highly recommend that you stop by to enjoy a wonderful treat. You'll be pleased that you did. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Moore
Very friendly staff, amazing coffee and pastries
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kat J
Such a sweet cafe! The women serving were very friendly, the coffee and scone I had for breakfast were the best I had since being on the Chesapeake for the last 2 weeks and our lunch we took to go (crab and shrimp Salad) scrumptious! I only wish I had discovered it earlier on our stay!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jana Shockley
For sandwiches, this is the place to go on the island. You've got ice cream treats at Four Brothers, Dinner at Lorraine's and Breakfast / Lunch needs at Muddy Toes :) They carry lunch meat and can make you a pretty decent sub. Perfect to take to go for a beach or kayak picnic!
I stopped in here several times for a coffee and iced cold brew along with a slice of pound cake for breakfast. Decently priced and honestly very good.
Staff are friendly and helpful. We just needed some milk the one day (the grocery store was closed) and they fixed us up with a cup to go -- no problem :) and the inside has a decent amount seating and is nicely cooled with AC, which is much needed on a hot day!
A great cafe for your on the go needs or to just simply hang out and relax.
The Food: I had a "Sweet Vanilla Creme Marsh Mud Cold Brew" and a "Iced Lemon Pound Cake". The coffee was absolutely delicious! And for the price, it was very fair. The sweet vanilla flavor paired very well with the cold brew and a bite from the lemon cake was fulfilling.
The Service: Service was great! Staff were so friendly and welcoming. Our order was done in a timely manner.
The Atmosphere: Very nicely decorated and spacious. A good mount of seating for people to hang out with some cold AC.
Overall, a 5/5! Enjoyed my time here at Muddy Toes. Definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Faith Hurley
This is THE place on TI. The women who run the place and the food are equally great. Don't miss it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
266rudyb
The owners were very nice and engaging. The coffee tasted good and the pastries were delicious. It’s probably a 7 minute walk from the seafood restaurant- that’s with a high heat index. They have plenty of seating and also offer free Wi-Fi. Definitely a good place to stop to get out of the heat and have a good cup of coffee.
Brooklyn Griffin
We stopped by for some much needed coffee after getting off of the ferry, and it was such a lovely place! The coffee and food were great, and the women working there were all so nice! We'll definitely be coming here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Shaffery
Great place for coffee, quiche, scones, sandwiches and Virginia hospitality. Feels like you are visiting longtime friends. You can’t call it a visit to Tangier Island without stopping by Muddy Toes Cafe.
This is only 1 of 2 eat-in restaurants on the island, and it was closed when we stayed there. It looked like it would have been a good choice. Wish it were open.
We especially love the bread sticks with the homemade marinara sauce. The hoagies are made with such high quality meats. Everything we have tried has been exceptional.
I've always wanted a coffee stop on the island and Muddy Toes met those expectations and then some!! The food and desserts are amazing as well, and when it comes to good people, go no further than the staff here at Muddy Toes Cafe. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for lunch on Tangier Island! The crab dip and the Brie/bacon/blackberry jam sandwich were delicious. Everyone behind the counter was super friendly.
Lovely place. Really enjoyed the sandwiches and coffee here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was delightful speaking with the owners.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Truly this is the best place to go on the island. Delicious meals, scrumptious desserts, refreshing cold beverages, and so much more! The locals like myself are in love with this quaint Cafe. If you're visiting Tangier or plan to do so then I highly recommend that you stop by to enjoy a wonderful treat. You'll be pleased that you did. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very friendly staff, amazing coffee and pastries
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a sweet cafe! The women serving were very friendly, the coffee and scone I had for breakfast were the best I had since being on the Chesapeake for the last 2 weeks and our lunch we took to go (crab and shrimp
Salad) scrumptious! I only wish I had discovered it earlier on our stay!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For sandwiches, this is the place to go on the island. You've got ice cream treats at Four Brothers, Dinner at Lorraine's and Breakfast / Lunch needs at Muddy Toes :) They carry lunch meat and can make you a pretty decent sub. Perfect to take to go for a beach or kayak picnic!
I stopped in here several times for a coffee and iced cold brew along with a slice of pound cake for breakfast. Decently priced and honestly very good.
Staff are friendly and helpful. We just needed some milk the one day (the grocery store was closed) and they fixed us up with a cup to go -- no problem :) and the inside has a decent amount seating and is nicely cooled with AC, which is much needed on a hot day!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
5/5!
A great cafe for your on the go needs or to just simply hang out and relax.
The Food: I had a "Sweet Vanilla Creme Marsh Mud Cold Brew" and a "Iced Lemon Pound Cake". The coffee was absolutely delicious! And for the price, it was very fair. The sweet vanilla flavor paired very well with the cold brew and a bite from the lemon cake was fulfilling.
The Service: Service was great! Staff were so friendly and welcoming. Our order was done in a timely manner.
The Atmosphere: Very nicely decorated and spacious. A good mount of seating for people to hang out with some cold AC.
Overall, a 5/5! Enjoyed my time here at Muddy Toes. Definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is THE place on TI. The women who run the place and the food are equally great. Don't miss it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owners were very nice and engaging. The coffee tasted good and the pastries were delicious. It’s probably a 7 minute walk from the seafood restaurant- that’s with a high heat index. They have plenty of seating and also offer free Wi-Fi. Definitely a good place to stop to get out of the heat and have a good cup of coffee.
We stopped by for some much needed coffee after getting off of the ferry, and it was such a lovely place! The coffee and food were great, and the women working there were all so nice! We'll definitely be coming here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for coffee, quiche, scones, sandwiches and Virginia hospitality. Feels like you are visiting longtime friends. You can’t call it a visit to Tangier Island without stopping by Muddy Toes Cafe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...