We were in NY for a week. So thankful we happened upon this diner! We had brunch there 2 days, and drinks before a play. The food was amazing, as were the drinks, but the best part was the staff!! I loved the vinaigrette on the brunch greens that accompanied my omelet. Would LOVE to know the brand or the recipe! Eat here! You'll be happy you did!
Amber Tolias
Made reservations morning of and was sat within minutes of getting there. Love that they have a kids menu. Food came out very quickly and was so good! One of my favorite breakfast meals I had while in NYC. Had a vanilla latte that was very good as well. Can’t wait to go back!
Iffy Eats
If you’re looking for a top-notch dining experience, Carnegie Diner and Cafe delivers in every way! From the moment you walk in, the cozy yet modern atmosphere welcomes you with a sense of comfort and style. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure your every need is met without being overbearing.
As for the food—simply outstanding. Every dish is thoughtfully prepared, bursting with flavor, and made with the highest quality ingredients. Whether you’re enjoying a classic diner favorite or something a bit more inventive, there’s something on the menu for everyone. The portions are generous, and the presentation is spot-on. The mix of hearty comfort food and lighter, more refined options ensures there’s a dish for any craving.
Overall, Carnegie Diner and Cafe is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates delicious food, a welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional service. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dalton Reeves
Great service. Everyone here was so friendly and helpful. The food was so good! I was pleasantly surprised by the choices offered. I would definitely come back! Great for lunch with friends and family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Kwon
The experience was, to sum it up, average. Food feels like it was pre-made and heated up, and for exorbitant prices, definitely not worth your time. Atmosphere is great though, and hadn't got a chance to try one of their cakes, which are plentiful here. If you come here, make sure not to get carried away, lest you be spending upwards of $100.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: -
Janelle Gozum
Went here for the first time on thanksgiving with my family. The food was okay, nothing worth coming back for. The service was horrible since our server took way too long with everything from taking our order, checking on us, taking away dishes we were done with and for the check. We kept seeing her talking and laughing in the hallway by the kitchen with her other coworkers. We ended up ordering dessert to go with how long she took. I was super excited to try the 24 layer chocolate cake, gourmet red velvet cake, and strawberry cheesecake but they were all horrible and not worth the amount we paid for. The chocolate cake had egg shells in it and overall the taste was not that good. I've had chocolate cake from the grocery store taste better than that. The red velvet cake wasn't even red it was basically grey brown with whipped frosting and tasted horrible. The cheesecake also tasted horrible, it barely tasted like cheesecake. We really wanted to like this place since the locations in NY are popular but it is not worth coming back to. The place is also super small and the seating arrangements are honestly awful if you're not able to get a full booth seating. I for sure don't see this place lasting long here. You're better off going to iHop or Bob and Ediths!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Melissa Alba
My daughter & family had a wonderful time at Carnegie. All the staff were super kind and attentive. The food was delicious and huge portions. Christopher, greeted & made our lunch experience a great one. Will def be back! Katie makes the cutest latte art as well. Only suggestion would be to expand the hot drink options by adding a chai or matcha option. Those would def sell ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, 24 Layer Chocolate Cake, French Fries
Jennine Cemovic
My family and I have become regulars. Great service from the bar! Tyler and Jason are always on point. Food is classic New York. Shout out to Phoebe and Christopher for running a tight ship.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie M
Amazing food with great staff! Even on thanksgiving the wait for food was perfect and everything was delicious. Their steaks were cooked to perfection! 10/10
Our server Ferhad, was so pleasant, big smile. The food was insanely great. Highly recommend Carnegie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastrami Sandwich
Venetis Pallikaras
We have been there multiple times both for Breakfast and Lunch. Their food quality and variety is simply amazing. I would really recommend you try their 24-layer chocolate cake. Both Christoforos and the people working were very polite and helpful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
•JessicaOwnsThis •
The food is 10/10. Pictures is the BLT Chicken and the Brownie Milkshake. Everything was delicious and worth the price in my opinion. The fries were crispy and I liked how the sandwiches included a salad. My sister ordered the Alfredo and she enjoyed it. The crispy chicken was different but in a good way. The chicken wings were delicious even though they were not that spicy. I would go back again for the food, especially the 24 layer cake. Service on the other hand was pretty slow. What I noticed is that our waitress would attend everyone else first and made us wait 20 mins before taking our drink orders. It took longer to even get the water that is for everyone. They did not leave the water pitcher so I asked our waitress for more water and she never came back. What seemed like the manager finally gave us the water and was more attentive than our waitress was. She finally gave us actual service towards the end when it was time to pay.
The restaurant is a renovated bank. It's beautifully decorated. Highly recommend reservations during brunch as it's always crowded. My first time dining and very impressed with service and food quality/portions. The apple pie, my only complaint is that it's cold but I asked to warm it up and of course they did. Mimosas fresh OJ were 5.00. Only serve beer and wine until liquor license received.
Recommend the California breakfast. All food coming put of the kitchen looked delicious. Great place for brunch.
We were in NY for a week. So thankful we happened upon this diner! We had brunch there 2 days, and drinks before a play. The food was amazing, as were the drinks, but the best part was the staff!! I loved the vinaigrette on the brunch greens that accompanied my omelet. Would LOVE to know the brand or the recipe! Eat here! You'll be happy you did!
Made reservations morning of and was sat within minutes of getting there. Love that they have a kids menu. Food came out very quickly and was so good! One of my favorite breakfast meals I had while in NYC. Had a vanilla latte that was very good as well. Can’t wait to go back!
If you’re looking for a top-notch dining experience, Carnegie Diner and Cafe delivers in every way! From the moment you walk in, the cozy yet modern atmosphere welcomes you with a sense of comfort and style. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure your every need is met without being overbearing.
As for the food—simply outstanding. Every dish is thoughtfully prepared, bursting with flavor, and made with the highest quality ingredients. Whether you’re enjoying a classic diner favorite or something a bit more inventive, there’s something on the menu for everyone. The portions are generous, and the presentation is spot-on. The mix of hearty comfort food and lighter, more refined options ensures there’s a dish for any craving.
Overall, Carnegie Diner and Cafe is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates delicious food, a welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional service. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service. Everyone here was so friendly and helpful. The food was so good! I was pleasantly surprised by the choices offered. I would definitely come back! Great for lunch with friends and family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The experience was, to sum it up, average. Food feels like it was pre-made and heated up, and for exorbitant prices, definitely not worth your time. Atmosphere is great though, and hadn't got a chance to try one of their cakes, which are plentiful here. If you come here, make sure not to get carried away, lest you be spending upwards of $100.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: -
Went here for the first time on thanksgiving with my family. The food was okay, nothing worth coming back for. The service was horrible since our server took way too long with everything from taking our order, checking on us, taking away dishes we were done with and for the check. We kept seeing her talking and laughing in the hallway by the kitchen with her other coworkers. We ended up ordering dessert to go with how long she took. I was super excited to try the 24 layer chocolate cake, gourmet red velvet cake, and strawberry cheesecake but they were all horrible and not worth the amount we paid for. The chocolate cake had egg shells in it and overall the taste was not that good. I've had chocolate cake from the grocery store taste better than that. The red velvet cake wasn't even red it was basically grey brown with whipped frosting and tasted horrible. The cheesecake also tasted horrible, it barely tasted like cheesecake. We really wanted to like this place since the locations in NY are popular but it is not worth coming back to. The place is also super small and the seating arrangements are honestly awful if you're not able to get a full booth seating. I for sure don't see this place lasting long here. You're better off going to iHop or Bob and Ediths!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
My daughter & family had a wonderful time at Carnegie. All the staff were super kind and attentive. The food was delicious and huge portions. Christopher, greeted & made our lunch experience a great one. Will def be back! Katie makes the cutest latte art as well. Only suggestion would be to expand the hot drink options by adding a chai or matcha option. Those would def sell ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, 24 Layer Chocolate Cake, French Fries
My family and I have become regulars. Great service from the bar! Tyler and Jason are always on point. Food is classic New York. Shout out to Phoebe and Christopher for running a tight ship.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food with great staff! Even on thanksgiving the wait for food was perfect and everything was delicious. Their steaks were cooked to perfection! 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Our server Ferhad, was so pleasant, big smile. The food was insanely great. Highly recommend Carnegie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastrami Sandwich
We have been there multiple times both for Breakfast and Lunch. Their food quality and variety is simply amazing. I would really recommend you try their 24-layer chocolate cake. Both Christoforos and the people working were very polite and helpful
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is 10/10. Pictures is the BLT Chicken and the Brownie Milkshake. Everything was delicious and worth the price in my opinion. The fries were crispy and I liked how the sandwiches included a salad. My sister ordered the Alfredo and she enjoyed it. The crispy chicken was different but in a good way. The chicken wings were delicious even though they were not that spicy. I would go back again for the food, especially the 24 layer cake.
Service on the other hand was pretty slow. What I noticed is that our waitress would attend everyone else first and made us wait 20 mins before taking our drink orders. It took longer to even get the water that is for everyone. They did not leave the water pitcher so I asked our waitress for more water and she never came back. What seemed like the manager finally gave us the water and was more attentive than our waitress was. She finally gave us actual service towards the end when it was time to pay.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, 24 Layer Chocolate Cake, Desserts
The restaurant is a renovated bank. It's beautifully decorated. Highly recommend reservations during brunch as it's always crowded.
My first time dining and very impressed with service and food quality/portions. The apple pie, my only complaint is that it's cold but I asked to warm it up and of course they did. Mimosas fresh OJ were 5.00. Only serve beer and wine until liquor license received.
Recommend the California breakfast. All food coming put of the kitchen looked delicious. Great place for brunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love that they have gluten free options!
Loading...