Great customer service however the prices/value are not. I purchased my daughter’s birthday cake here and paid $89 and it was literally the size of a can of beans or something. Extremely small…. I was shocked to say the least. However she said supposedly it was enough to feed 12 people… absolutely not. Also the shortbread cookies that were on the cake had no flavor whatsoever and weren’t even sweet ... Never again.
Kim R.
Best wedding cake and cupcakes! Fresh homemade and perfect. Awesome people ensuring I got what I was looking for. Just wonderful.
Robbie Pond
One of the best bakeries I have ever tried and I usually always look for bakeries, cupcake shops, or donut shops for a sweet treat when visiting somewhere. Was at Christmas Town in Warsaw and stopped in for just a couple cookies and truffles. Came back an hour later to load up on more holiday treats to take home. Everything tasted so fresh and delicious. Need to go back to get some whole pies and cakes.Dietary restrictions: I saw some gluten free options and snacks for pets.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies with Decorations
Vicke Brice
We ordered cakes and cupcakes from Michelle’s for our daughter’s baby shower. The cakes were delicious, decorated beautifully and the guests raved about the taste and how moist and incredible they were! Several guests from New York even commented that they were better than anything they had had in the better restaurants there. I am definitely going to be a return customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Diesel
A quality American pastry shop, right in "downtown". One of the few good reasons to make the trip into Warsaw. Love the cheesecake varieties, danishes, and cream puffs.
Bob Dennis
Everything Pumpkin ? I got a mini pumpkin loaf, pumpkin scone, and a iced oatmeal cookie.
Richard Knapp
The absolute top drawer on everything she offers, with a staff to boot! What an accomplishment for Michelle.
trishbyrne
We got both bread and pies from Michelle’s Sweet Treats today and everything was outstanding. The bread and bread rolls were delicious and fresh (apparently Thursday is bread day). The pimento cheese was delicious. The key lime pie was tart and silky. But best of all the coconut cream pie was a revelation: Creamy, sweet but not too sweet, coconutty but not overwhelming, and the pastry cream was perfect in flavor and texture as was the deliciously flaky crust. Would 100% recommend and will be looking for an excuse to come back. We haven’t gotten into the cinnamon rolls yet (saving them for breakfast tomorrow) but we are really looking forward to breakfast.
Eric Carr
Loved the coconut cream pie! The crust was flaky and the filling creamy smooth. Key lime pie was nice and tart. Also try the fresh baked bread on Thursdays.
Sandy Clark
Delicious treats of all kinds. Her shop is a work of art!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies with Decorations, Doughnut
Amazing selection of special treats. Helpful and friendly staff. Will be back often.
Chad Isabelle
Picked up a French apple pie from here that was out of this world!!! Went in just for a pie but I came out with cookies and truffles and more. Everything I saw looked so good. Can’t wait to go back and pick up some other items.
Terry Gruchow
Yum.Loved the cinnamon raisin bread with those sweet golden raisins.Get some.Now.GO!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug Mangas
The best cream puffs ever so good and blast full of cream!!
Great customer service however the prices/value are not. I purchased my daughter’s birthday cake here and paid $89 and it was literally the size of a can of beans or something. Extremely small…. I was shocked to say the least. However she said supposedly it was enough to feed 12 people… absolutely not. Also the shortbread cookies that were on the cake had no flavor whatsoever and weren’t even sweet ... Never again.
Best wedding cake and cupcakes! Fresh homemade and perfect. Awesome people ensuring I got what I was looking for. Just wonderful.
One of the best bakeries I have ever tried and I usually always look for bakeries, cupcake shops, or donut shops for a sweet treat when visiting somewhere. Was at Christmas Town in Warsaw and stopped in for just a couple cookies and truffles. Came back an hour later to load up on more holiday treats to take home. Everything tasted so fresh and delicious. Need to go back to get some whole pies and cakes.Dietary restrictions: I saw some gluten free options and snacks for pets.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies with Decorations
We ordered cakes and cupcakes from Michelle’s for our daughter’s baby shower. The cakes were delicious, decorated beautifully and the guests raved about the taste and how moist and incredible they were! Several guests from New York even commented that they were better than anything they had had in the better restaurants there. I am definitely going to be a return customer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A quality American pastry shop, right in "downtown". One of the few good reasons to make the trip into Warsaw. Love the cheesecake varieties, danishes, and cream puffs.
Everything Pumpkin ? I got a mini pumpkin loaf, pumpkin scone, and a iced oatmeal cookie.
The absolute top drawer on everything she offers, with a staff to boot! What an accomplishment for Michelle.
We got both bread and pies from Michelle’s Sweet Treats today and everything was outstanding. The bread and bread rolls were delicious and fresh (apparently Thursday is bread day). The pimento cheese was delicious. The key lime pie was tart and silky. But best of all the coconut cream pie was a revelation: Creamy, sweet but not too sweet, coconutty but not overwhelming, and the pastry cream was perfect in flavor and texture as was the deliciously flaky crust. Would 100% recommend and will be looking for an excuse to come back. We haven’t gotten into the cinnamon rolls yet (saving them for breakfast tomorrow) but we are really looking forward to breakfast.
Loved the coconut cream pie! The crust was flaky and the filling creamy smooth. Key lime pie was nice and tart. Also try the fresh baked bread on Thursdays.
Delicious treats of all kinds. Her shop is a work of art!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies with Decorations, Doughnut
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing selection of special treats. Helpful and friendly staff. Will be back often.
Picked up a French apple pie from here that was out of this world!!! Went in just for a pie but I came out with cookies and truffles and more. Everything I saw looked so good. Can’t wait to go back and pick up some other items.
Yum.Loved the cinnamon raisin bread with those sweet golden raisins.Get some.Now.GO!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best cream puffs ever so good and blast full of cream!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great variety to choose from! Always delicious!