Benny Stivale's

328 W Main St, Waynesboro
(540) 221-4554

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Hot Lips Veggie Special Cherry Peppers Banana Peppers and Pineapple Pizza
Sausage Pizza Mushroom Garlic Pizza and Beer Cheese Broccoli Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice & Cheese Pizza Slice
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza Slice
50 50 Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Sriracha Sausage Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Mushrooms Pizza
Cheese Pizza with Sausage
Spinach Feta Pizza Slice
Single Slice Pizza Slice

Menu

Pizza
The Angry Dwarf Pizza (Whole 28")
Roasted red peppers and garlic pesto.
Cheese Pizza (sls)
Pepperoni Pizza(sls)
Pepperoni Pizza (sls) or Italian Sausage Pizza
The Angry Dwarf Pizza(sls)
Roasted red peppers and garlic pesto.
Italian Sausage Pizza(sls)
Garlic Mushroom Pizza(sls)
Cheese Pizza (Whole 28")
Pepperoni Pizza (Whole 28") or Italian Sausage Pizza (Whole 28")
Pepperoni Pizza (Whole 28")
Half Cheese (Whole 28") or Half Garlic Mushroom (Whole 28")
Garlic Mushroom Pizza (Whole 28")
Half Cheese (Whole 28") or Half Pepperoni Pizza (Whole 28")
Half Cheese (Whole 28") or Half Sausage Pizza(Whole 28")
Pizza 1/2 and 1/2 (Create Your Own) (Whole 28")

Drinks
IBC Rootbeer
Mt. Dew (Can)
IBC Black Cherry
Coke (Can)
Diet Coke (Can)
Bottled Water

Dipping Sauces and Extras
Marinara (Cup)
Ranch (Cup)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+37 photos
Photo credit: google
+36 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place is awesome. The People are so friendly. I’m re writing this review because I just found out the wonderful gentleman’s name that took care of me today. John. Shout out to that guy he’s a great soul and really knows how to make people smile. With great service and a great attitude. He made my day.
June 2025
If you are looking for value and great tasting pizza without all the “BS”… this is the place! I have never had a bad slice at this location. The staff are always polite and welcoming.
May 2025
Best pizza / large 28” Highly recommended,great pizza,staff is amazing/and Kind ❤️💙🍕best pizza I had! 7 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🙃 Price is so on point!🙃💙
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Stella Bella & Lucy's - 327 W Main St
American, New American, Vegetarian
The Gumbo Hut - 403 W Main St
Seafood, Cajun/Creole, Soul Food
The Green Leaf Grill - 415 W Main St
American, Chicken Wings, Gluten-Free, Seafood, Vegan

Benny Stivale's

328 W Main St, Waynesboro, VA 22980
(540) 221-4554