Cara Mia's

50 Strongs Ave, Rutland
(802) 747-9001

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Explosion Cake
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan
Stuffed Sheiis Parmeson
Cannoli Filled to Order
Large Cheese Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Green Mountain
Ham and Cheese
Chicken Wings

Menu

Oven Baked Entrees
Stuffed Shells Parmesan
Three jumbo shells packed with cheese.
Lasagna
Lots of layers and lots of cheese.
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan
Eggplant Parmesan
Eggplant Rollatini
Family recipe with ricotta, mozzarella, and asiago cheeses.
Meatballs Parmesan
Three smothered with mozzarella.

Subs
Italian Sub
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, oil, and vinegar.
Hot Italian Sub
Ham, capicola, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, hot peppers, oil, and vinegar.
Turkey Sub
Lettuce and tomatoes.
Ham and Cheese Sub
Lettuce and tomatoes.
Chicken Cutlet Sub
Lettuce and tomatoes.

Pizza
White Pizza
Herb-washed crust, ricotta, mozzarella, romano, and asiago. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Caramia Pizza
Red pesto, broccoli, grilled chicken, sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, and asiago. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Veggie Pizza
Red sauce, ricotta, tomatoes, spinach, black olives, portobello mushrooms, garlic, mozzarella, and asiago. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Roman Pizza
Herb-washed crust, tomatoes, mozzarella, asiago, basil, and oregano. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Clam Casino Pizza
Chopped clams, garlic, bacon, tomatoes, and spinach. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Sicilian Pizza (Large)
Thick and square and delicious. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Green Mountain Pizza
Maple sauce, ham, tomatoes, and cobot cheddar. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.
Johnnies Favorite Pizza
Hot herb wash, Italian sausage, capicola, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, and asiago. We hand spin fresh dough, spread our own original red tomato sauce, top with grande mozzarella cheese, season, and bake directly on hot bricks.

Wings
Chicken Wings

Desserts
Cannoli
Chocolate Explosion Cake
Chocolate brownie, mousse, fudge, and chips.
Creamy NY Cheesecake
Buttery graham cracker crust.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+32 photos
Photo credit: google
+31 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Cara Mia’s is quickly becoming our favorite pizza spot in Rutland. Pizza and salads are consistently great and tastes just like my hometown pizza shop in NY (in the best way). Staff are always super friendly and professional, whether it’s ordering over the phone, picking up take out and getting delivery. Highly recommend!
January 2026
this is the best pizza in Rutland and anybody that tells you otherwise is a hater or hasn’t tried it. Yes, the delivery times can take a while, yes, the pizza is pricey, but great work takes time and You get what you pay for. It’s worth it. This pizza is phenomenal!!!
January 2026
I have always enjoyed Cara Mia's and still do . I order the chef salad almost every time we get pizza . I was disappointed with it the last couple of times I ordered as it was mostly lettuce . I thought maybe prepared by someone new. Tonight I get another salad (sadly my last )and it looked amazing at first . Sprinkled with bits of scraps for the meats 2 tomatoes. I get food costs are up but does that mean skimmping on ingredients ? Too much money for lettuce
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Angler Pub - 52 Strongs Ave
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Sports Bar
Muckenschnabel's - 45 Madison St
Bar, Pubs
Gill's Delicatessen - 68 Strongs Ave
Deli, Italian, Pizza, American

Cara Mia's

50 Strongs Ave, Rutland, VT 05701
(802) 747-9001