Ted's Pizza Shop

91 State St, Rutland
(802) 773-6368

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ali

Delightful pizza shop! The staff were so nice and friendly! We loooved their pizza and the two desserts we got that were made in house.

Samantha Raymond

This is the first time I have gotten food from here since the new owners. I have tried to call and order multiple times and either get put on hold and never answered again, or the phone is just never answered. I have not tried to pizza yet since the new owners. But i got the vodka sauce and it was the worst vodka sauce ive ever had in my life. All it tasted like was a bunch of cooked tomatoes blended up. My son got the spaghetti and liked it though.....

Briguygtr

This place is completely upside down, no clue of how to run an operation

Annora McGarry

Great pizza at a good price. Flavorful dough and sauce. Can’t wait to go back and try some of their specials!

M Glrd

I am a pizza enthusiast and always hated the original sauce from the Ted’s before. I’m from NY Queensbury area and always searched for the best pizza. I’ve worked at several Pizza places young in life. The new Ted’s has the best sauce and the best crust. All around best pizza I have ever had. Just try it once and you will see the reason for this review.

mtd 3

Great pizza ! Everything on the menu is pretty good. New management has improved the quality of the pizza in my opinion.

Memedealer

This place goes hard, this was my first time to Ted's, I got a chicken melt sub and an order of garlic bread with sauce.

I was blown away, this sammy was cheaper than subway, packed full of flavor, the fried chicken cutlet had actual flavor (some kind of seasoning or sauce, not just plain) and was tender, the bread, cheese and sauce mixed well and brought me a huge hit of dopamine.

The garlic bread was an entire sub roll, and loaded with actual fresh garlic and cheese (not garlic powder). I can't speak to their pizza yet but I will be back to try more food.

The atmosphere is definitely dated and older, but I don't even care because of how good the food was, and the staff were friendly and inviting.

Edit I went and had another toasted sub and was blown away again.

D. Burton

Never went in there till recently it was really good!

tom thaw

Pizza was overpriced and barley cooked. Take your money elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

I've Always Been Crazy

Best pizza around. Love the people. Try the sausage, meatballs and peppers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charlotte Loso

Amazing as always - wish you guys would deliver to England!!! 2 large pizzas between 3…didn’t last long.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Sausage Ham and Meatball Pizza, Cheese Pizza

G T

Cracker crust sweet sauce and. Ezzo cupping Pepperoni's ...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Reed DeRemer

I have heard rave reviews about Ted's for the last ten years I have lived in the area, but have never tried them. Sadly, Ted's did not live up to the hype. I ordered my go-to pie, Large Pepperoni. I was disappointed that their large is most places medium. The pie itself was cooked well, but the sauce tasted bland (like most jarred sauces.) The pepperoni was tastless and rubbery. The saving grace was the plentiful amount of cheese. Having eaten many pizzas in my day, both from east coast and west, I hoped for the best and nearly got the worst.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

David Graham

This place is a waste of money people go somewhere else You're better off by Tony's pizza and making it yourself Does this place screws you over and has no flavor

Dietary restrictions: This place is a rip-off

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Ted's Pizza Rutland Vermont

Joshua Knapp

Great authentic pizza!!!

Loading...