McGillicuddy's Alehouse

28 Walnut St, Williston
(802) 857-5908

Recent Reviews

Maine Mama

My husband and I absolutely loved this place. It's St. Patricks Day, so we tried the ruben egg rolls, I fell in love with them. He had the Philly and onion rings, and I had the American burger. Itwas the best burger I have ever had while eating out 10/0. It was huge! My husband said his Philly was a 10/10 also. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the staff was amazing. Our food was extremely fast getting to the table. We are not from Vermont, but we come several times a year. And this will now be our go-to place to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: American Burger, Cheesesteak

Beth Smith

We came into town not knowing where to eat and settled for some bar food. The bartender Brian was super personable and quick to keep us happy. The beer selection was pretty awesome.The hubs got wings with a house hot sauce/BBQ which was delish. I got a chicken sandwich and was extremely underwhelmed by it. The bun itself was bigger than the measley piece of chicken and the fries weren't fully cooked. Too expensive for $15 imo.For drinks and some apps, I bet this place is fantastic. We enjoyed the 90s music selection and had a nice convo with the bartender. Will try again if we're in the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Game Day

James Simmons

Bryan the bartkeep is top notch. Fast, friendly, and great with the drinks!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

William Y.

The beer is good but the food is terrible. The price is outrageous and the quality is poor. Don't be expecting any Irish food as the don't even have spuds!

Bill Shappy

Always great food and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vermont Burger, Cajun Chicken Wings

Gavin L.

Me and a buddy both ordered a sip of sunshine. They came out looking and tasting very different. Waitress and bartender said it was just the glass making it look different. I ordered the vermont maple chicken sandwich and it just tasted like a regular chicken sandwich with a sticky bun. Very disappointing

Dale Whitney

Good food great Staff ...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

John Seward

Great service! Great food. No more to say.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vermont Burger, Fish Tacos

Patrick Webster

The food was great and the service was quick and attentive throughout the meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vermont Burger

Angela lovebum

I swear everytime im here some jackass is screaming at the vikings football game. i’m just trying to enjoy some authentic irish cooking like how my papa used to make.

david melanson

I walked in twenty minutes ago to find the bar was full but high tops were open. A guy stood and stared at me for about 10 seconds , then asked if I was going to the bar. I told him I’d take a high top which apparently wasn’t what he wanted to hear. He grabbed a menu along with a silverware wrap, threw it on the table and stormed off. At that moment I grabbed my jacket and walked out. It’s not the first time the treatment has been bad but I ignored it because I enjoyed a sandwich that theycould never seem to make correctly. This time was the LAST time.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Stephanie S.

Coworkers and I wanted a good place to go for HH. One lives in Williston and as soon as she suggested it, I knew it was a great choice because the one in Waterbury is excellent. Although our server started out a bit grumpy, he perked up as the night went on and he was always prompt with food and drinks. I got the ale house burger which was cooked exactly as I like it (med rare) and the fries were perfectly crispy. Some coworkers shared chips and guacamole while another got chicken tenders and fries. It's nicely decorated for the holidays. I highly recommend.

Maine Girl

Food and atmosphere were great! Plenty of tvs if you enjoy sports. The service wasn’t the best. It was a weekend and she was younger. Probably 1st job and not excited to be there, but she tried. Wasn’t horrible, but definitely could have been better. Would definitely recommend stopping in. Try the maple chicken burger, it was delicious.Parking: Very hard to find parking as it is in a shopping center. We parked on the complete opposite side. Not too bad of a walk.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Maple Chicken Sandwich

Leslie Drown

Our service provider was not very friendly. Kept flying by trying to talk at the same time. Never stopping at our table period we waited an hour for our food. We had somewhere else to be. So we walked out without having any food.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 1

Keith gomo

Didn't get to eat, It took to long for food to come out, 2 groups came in after our small group of 4 and were gone before our food came out. I do not recommend this place..

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More