Located on the side of Fiamma Restaurant, the Pye Hole is a walk-up window service for hot pizza by the slice, salads and drinks. They offer meat, cheese, veggie and vegan slices. You order on a touch screen and your pizza is delivered through a window. This was my first visit and my pizza was piping hot with a delicious crust. The price is very reasonable with fast service. There are three small tables or you could stand at a railing to enjoy your pizza or just take it to go. Pye Hole accepts card only payment. This is a perfect option for anyone who wants to just grab a quick bite while they're downtown or if you're on a lunch break.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Frost
First time trying slices here, smelled amazing outside. 2 pepperoni slices were completely pitch black/charred on the entire bottom, not enjoyable. Veggie and a cheese slice were good. Thigh fried chicken was overcooked and dry, seemed old like from days before, cole slaw was good. Overall not a good experience for the high price. Employees at window seemed irritated despite tipping for a to go order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3
James Petersen
The ladies making the pizza tonight, Gwinn(?) and Olivia, were doing an excellent job. The pepperoni slice is always decent, but never perfect. Well tonight I found out I was wrong and perfection can be achieved. The slice was perfectly crispy and not greasy at all, thanks to the creators measured use of the topping. I hadn't realized just how much of a negative having MORE pepperoni can become for the overall slice. Olivia and Gwinn's slices are the gold standard now. Perfectly balanced, as all things should be. If you're the owner or their boss, I implore you to try their slices and then let them train the rest of the pye hole staff to make the same slice. Seriously it's never been that good before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sajid Arghandaiwal
They gave me a cold pizza. Didn't even bother to warm it up. Very disappointing.
Pee-Bee Jay
Ordered a few slices. Liked it.
Good ambience. Asked for military discount. They did not have one. But cashier gave me free ranch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake Languein
Henry is the man. Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zachary
Long wait for pricey pizza by the slice, very yummy though! Unrelated, but someone got arrested right outside while we were waiting for our food… lol
Matthew Vincent
Pizza was great. Walk up and order was cool. But it was also cool outside. Wish I could at least order inside at the counter. Would have been nice to have a place to eat as well, but I guess that isn't the intention of this place.
Adam Nedley
Probably my favorite pizza joint in Bellingham.
B D
Great large slice crispy cupped pepperoni properly leopard spotted crust and the slice was out to me fast. A little expensive for a slice though but understandable. Difficult to stop by on a whim for a slice due to the parking situation.
These slices are of good size and hot. I love that they’re open late on weekends. It’s a great place to grab a quick bite to eat. I did see a homeless individual once yelling at the workers and throwing around the parmesan cheese shaker, but that’s just Bellingham for you.
Matt Fontaine
Slices done real good. Hot & flavorful. Hot honey on the side. Rice krispy treats the size of your face. Open late (warning: risk of drunk college kids). Chill vibe. Fast service. What do you want, a shoeshine? They don’t have those.
Amanda Flores
This place used to be a vibe. You come in drunk and needing a slice and you could always count on different options every night. I was sad to be greeted by a screen and to see there wasn’t any fun combos. The pizza came out so hot, we couldn’t eat it for good while. Overall sad to see this place lose its touch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Joe
Lots of variability in quality that I really think depends on the time of night and how busy la fiamma is. On average it's usually a pretty damn good slice. Great for a quick lazy dinner but I can't count how many times this place saved my butt at the end of a drunk night.
Aerin Basehart
I love the walk up window options, if you put your email in for rewards you’ll have a discount code that’s good for the price of a slice of pizza !
Located on the side of Fiamma Restaurant, the Pye Hole is a walk-up window service for hot pizza by the slice, salads and drinks. They offer meat, cheese, veggie and vegan slices. You order on a touch screen and your pizza is delivered through a window. This was my first visit and my pizza was piping hot with a delicious crust. The price is very reasonable with fast service. There are three small tables or you could stand at a railing to enjoy your pizza or just take it to go. Pye Hole accepts card only payment. This is a perfect option for anyone who wants to just grab a quick bite while they're downtown or if you're on a lunch break.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying slices here, smelled amazing outside. 2 pepperoni slices were completely pitch black/charred on the entire bottom, not enjoyable. Veggie and a cheese slice were good. Thigh fried chicken was overcooked and dry, seemed old like from days before, cole slaw was good. Overall not a good experience for the high price. Employees at window seemed irritated despite tipping for a to go order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3
The ladies making the pizza tonight, Gwinn(?) and Olivia, were doing an excellent job. The pepperoni slice is always decent, but never perfect. Well tonight I found out I was wrong and perfection can be achieved. The slice was perfectly crispy and not greasy at all, thanks to the creators measured use of the topping. I hadn't realized just how much of a negative having MORE pepperoni can become for the overall slice. Olivia and Gwinn's slices are the gold standard now. Perfectly balanced, as all things should be. If you're the owner or their boss, I implore you to try their slices and then let them train the rest of the pye hole staff to make the same slice. Seriously it's never been that good before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They gave me a cold pizza. Didn't even bother to warm it up. Very disappointing.
Ordered a few slices. Liked it.
Good ambience. Asked for military discount. They did not have one. But cashier gave me free ranch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Henry is the man. Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Long wait for pricey pizza by the slice, very yummy though!
Unrelated, but someone got arrested right outside while we were waiting for our food… lol
Pizza was great. Walk up and order was cool. But it was also cool outside. Wish I could at least order inside at the counter. Would have been nice to have a place to eat as well, but I guess that isn't the intention of this place.
Probably my favorite pizza joint in Bellingham.
Great large slice crispy cupped pepperoni properly leopard spotted crust and the slice was out to me fast. A little expensive for a slice though but understandable. Difficult to stop by on a whim for a slice due to the parking situation.
Restaurantji Recommends
These slices are of good size and hot. I love that they’re open late on weekends. It’s a great place to grab a quick bite to eat. I did see a homeless individual once yelling at the workers and throwing around the parmesan cheese shaker, but that’s just Bellingham for you.
Slices done real good. Hot & flavorful. Hot honey on the side. Rice krispy treats the size of your face. Open late (warning: risk of drunk college kids). Chill vibe. Fast service. What do you want, a shoeshine? They don’t have those.
This place used to be a vibe. You come in drunk and needing a slice and you could always count on different options every night. I was sad to be greeted by a screen and to see there wasn’t any fun combos. The pizza came out so hot, we couldn’t eat it for good while. Overall sad to see this place lose its touch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Lots of variability in quality that I really think depends on the time of night and how busy la fiamma is. On average it's usually a pretty damn good slice. Great for a quick lazy dinner but I can't count how many times this place saved my butt at the end of a drunk night.
I love the walk up window options, if you put your email in for rewards you’ll have a discount code that’s good for the price of a slice of pizza !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Slice, Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...