Cornerstone Italian Kitchen (Cornerstone Pie)

The new owners of Cornerstone Italian Kitchen have made REMARKABLE changes! The food is deliciously crafted by the amazing cooks, the drink specials by Jensen are magical ✨️, the atmosphere is cozy yet chic, and the service is friendly and warm. 10/10 recommend for everybody; date nights, family fun, big parties, AND catering! The live music in the summertime is a MAJOR bonus, too. 🎶

We have always eaten in the bar with Jensen as our waiter. He is amazing. He always makes us an excellent drink. He makes the experience enjoyable. The food is awesome.

Employees we friendly and the food was so good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Garlic Chicken

Absolutely perfect place to catch some good slices and has some fun cocktails too! Staff are super freindly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Probably the best meatballs I've ever had, no lie. I was just looking for some spaghetti and meatballs which weren't exactly on the menu but they were able to make it for me. Everything was outstanding from the service to the food. We would absolutely go here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Visiting from San Francisco and found CIK on local reviews. Worth the visit!! We were seated and greeted by Emily who was engaging, smiling and appreciated our humor. She was quick to describe the pizza choices and help us refine our options. The kale salad was GREAT! It's not easy finding a great Kale Salad. The ingrediants were fresh, kale messaged perfect. The Caprese Salad is another great choice: the dressing was good. Those in our group with the house salad, also commented on the freshness and good Ranch dressing. We opted for Donna's Fav and Garlic Chicken pizzas. Both were excellent and actually compliment each other if you're seeking a dual pizza combination. The crust was soft, not too thick, good flavor. Garlic Chicken great flavor, cheese warm and just blends with chicken and sauce so well. Donna's Fav, nice combo with the red and pesto sauce. The meat was tender and nice twist with kalamata olives. We cleaned our plates!! Great atmosphere, fantastic pizza/salads and nice staff. Highly recommend a visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Came in for a quick bite on a Sunday evening. Interesting menu and a really great staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a margarita pizza. Burnt. Small for a “large”. Oval shaped. Not a shred of fresh basil or tomato in sight. Incredibly disappointed with the quality for an overpriced pizza. Do better cornerstone.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

When you walk in you are met with amazing sights and smells! The staff are super nice and the other customers are also super friendly! The pizza was super good but had some issues. 1. The crust was super thin in the very middle but got better to the outside and edges. 2. The crust cut my mouth so much. I had little bits of skin hanging off the roof of my mouth to the point I could taste blood. 3. The toppings were delicious and the mushrooms super chunky I loved them. The only issue with toppings was that it lacked depth and flavor. It was amazing for texture but not flavors. (Maybe I only think this cause my mouth was obliterated by the crust uncertain) over all I would order again and give it another try but for 38$ it was a bit, lackluster.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Delicious and we will be back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Stopped here on our way home from our 2000 mile camping trip. We had been here before and remembered the food being tasty. The cheese bread was good and enough for each of us to have two little slices. The pizzas came out within 20 minutes and were just enough for us four with no leftovers. The large salad was a bit small to share, but good enough for a few bites each. We were glad that we had the option to sit outside since we had our small dogs with us in a stroller. All in all, it was a tasty dinner, although the cost was a bit higher than other pizza places we have been.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Chicken, Caesar Salad

Really great pizza ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Doesn't honor gift cards. I had an extremely disappointing experience at Cornerstone Pie. Before making the trip, I called to confirm that my gift card would still be honored despite the new ownership. I was aware of the ownership change, so I made sure to call. The person on the phone passed me to a manager, who assured me they would honor it DESPITE changing owners. Based on this, I drove all the way from Yakima to meet friends, only to be told in person that they wouldn't accept the gift card.

I even played the recorded conversation where the manager clearly confirmed they would honor it, but they still refused. This was incredibly inconsiderate and frustrating. Time is invaluable, and I purchased the gift card in good faith. They not only took my money happily, but also wasted my time. The manager verbally told me on the phone they would honor it, and that there was a balance on it. I have proof of this conversation.

They then give me an email address to email, AFTER I already did my due diligence to make sure it would work. This doesn't help me while I'm sitting at the restaurant, after driving 45 minutes just to meet my friends at this specific restaurant. I already paid for the gift card, so I'm not going to spend money on the menu after I already gave the company money by getting a gift card. I'm also not going to email them, when I already did what I thought was more than enough by calling them. I wasted an hour and half, fuel, and my time which is invaluable.

Service: 1

A nice atmosphere with good options for dining in or eating outside. Our family enjoy a nice lunch outside on the deck. The pizza topppings were good but the crust lacked flavor. The chicken wings were delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hot Honey