I normally come here for a quick slice, but this place is no longer me and my wife. Not the stores fault, but this is the most family oriented pagliacci, there is a least a family with kids coming in and out every 10- 15 minutes. E bikes/scooter parked right in front of the doors. Young kids walking around the store and tables with kids shouting. Not for those that like to eat in some quiet.
Lynn Rohlfs
Great NY PIZZA. Needs locations in south end. Pizza has become more inconsistent from location to location.
JDS Boston
Best quality pizza and slices in town
Arthur Lee
Small store with some but limited seating. Excellent for takeout. Single slice or whole pizza for pick up or delivery.
тумун гармаев
I like it
Jay
Good, quick pizza. Comfortable chain atmosphere.
bakkaapancake gmail
Does the staff know how to properly drive? Little red car was speeding in the parking lot like there was an emergency.
Eleana May
When my friend and I wanted to meet up in Mercer Island, I checked if there were any late-night dinner options, and perfect, Pagliacci was open!
We tried Michelle’s Pie (pizza) and Nonna’s Pasta, and both were absolutely delicious. The restaurant had a cozy and spacious atmosphere, making it a comfortable place to eat. We were so happy to find good food late at night, and the staff were really nice too!
Dan Kain
Over priced and pizza was super bland. Wouldn't come back.
Steven N
Local pizza chain. It’s been a few years but I have had Pagliacci Pizza dozens of times before. I used to mostly go to the Kirkland location.
It has come to be somewhat expensive but I have found the ingredients to be high quality and the quantity of toppings is never an issue.
I picked up from this Mercer Island location. It’s a stand alone location in the parking lot of a strip mall. They have a number of tables available for dine in. Great tasting pizza as always.
Taking the family here was a blast. The drive wasn’t to bad from Seattle, a bit of traffic because it’s the city and then smooth sailing after you cross Washington Lake. Getting inside was easy and sharing 2 pizzas between 8 people was even easier. The vibe was very chill inside the restaurant and desert gillato was delicious. Highly recommend!
Annie Ramsey-Shearer
I’ve been going to Pogies for over 20 years, maybe even longer! I’ve got their number memorized, and it’s saved as a contact in my phone. My only complaint is that it can be a bit pricey, but honestly, pizza seems expensive everywhere these days. But because of that we don’t get it as often as I’d like. The quality at Pogies is fantastic, though, and it’s clear they’re a great place for young people to work and build careers. They really treat their employees well, which is something I appreciate!
Joseph Lind
Simply the best pizza in town
Araz Maruf
I typically get pizza from this restaurant. The food and customer service are excellent. However, I have some concerns about food safety. The cooks do not wear hair restraints or gloves, and I'm unsure if there is a specific reason for this or if it indicates a lack of concern for food safety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Blake Smuin
Ok but their gluten free crust was delicious. I recommend PSR combo. Fun atmosphere and across from a lovely park. It’s a little pricey for gluten free, but very good.
I normally come here for a quick slice, but this place is no longer me and my wife. Not the stores fault, but this is the most family oriented pagliacci, there is a least a family with kids coming in and out every 10- 15 minutes. E bikes/scooter parked right in front of the doors. Young kids walking around the store and tables with kids shouting. Not for those that like to eat in some quiet.
Great NY PIZZA. Needs locations in south end. Pizza has become more inconsistent from location to location.
Best quality pizza and slices in town
Small store with some but limited seating. Excellent for takeout. Single slice or whole pizza for pick up or delivery.
I like it
Good, quick pizza. Comfortable chain atmosphere.
Does the staff know how to properly drive? Little red car was speeding in the parking lot like there was an emergency.
When my friend and I wanted to meet up in Mercer Island, I checked if there were any late-night dinner options, and perfect, Pagliacci was open!
We tried Michelle’s Pie (pizza) and Nonna’s Pasta, and both were absolutely delicious. The restaurant had a cozy and spacious atmosphere, making it a comfortable place to eat. We were so happy to find good food late at night, and the staff were really nice too!
Over priced and pizza was super bland. Wouldn't come back.
Local pizza chain. It’s been a few years but I have had Pagliacci Pizza dozens of times before. I used to mostly go to the Kirkland location.
It has come to be somewhat expensive but I have found the ingredients to be high quality and the quantity of toppings is never an issue.
I picked up from this Mercer Island location. It’s a stand alone location in the parking lot of a strip mall. They have a number of tables available for dine in. Great tasting pizza as always.
Restaurantji Recommends
Taking the family here was a blast. The drive wasn’t to bad from Seattle, a bit of traffic because it’s the city and then smooth sailing after you cross Washington Lake. Getting inside was easy and sharing 2 pizzas between 8 people was even easier. The vibe was very chill inside the restaurant and desert gillato was delicious. Highly recommend!
I’ve been going to Pogies for over 20 years, maybe even longer! I’ve got their number memorized, and it’s saved as a contact in my phone. My only complaint is that it can be a bit pricey, but honestly, pizza seems expensive everywhere these days. But because of that we don’t get it as often as I’d like. The quality at Pogies is fantastic, though, and it’s clear they’re a great place for young people to work and build careers. They really treat their employees well, which is something I appreciate!
Simply the best pizza in town
I typically get pizza from this restaurant. The food and customer service are excellent. However, I have some concerns about food safety. The cooks do not wear hair restraints or gloves, and I'm unsure if there is a specific reason for this or if it indicates a lack of concern for food safety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Ok but their gluten free crust was delicious. I recommend PSR combo. Fun atmosphere and across from a lovely park. It’s a little pricey for gluten free, but very good.
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...