Garlic Jim's Pizza Mill Creek

Great pizza

Take out only. Otherwise great pizza and good and friendly guys working hard to serve customers.

If you want a pizza that photographs well with zero flavor at 32 dollars for a medium then this is your place. If you want a good tasting pie then this is the last place I would choose in the area.

so goooood

The shift lead guy tonight was very good at customer service. He makes sure the customer is welcome and has what they need to enjoy the food.

Orderd one just had one piece and my opinion is the price does not match the quality I think Cicis Pizza has same quality as yours. Please fix this $33 pizza to worth the price. Ordered Margarita pizza was not even close enough 😩 I am out.

Some of the best pizza around!

I've ordered twice now, once in the store and once online. I used to use the Pizza Hut down the road. NEVER AGAIN! Garlic Jim's is better all the way arround! REPEAT; NEVER THE HUT, ALWAYS JIM'S!

Parking: Have your pizza delivered, avoid parking here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Extra Large

There was a pile of black olives in the corner of the box that slid off during delivery. A lot of the remaining olives fell off while eating. They were placed on top of the pepperoni and Canadian bacon so there wasn't anything to hold them on the pizza. A little cheese on top would be helpful. Fortunately the pizza tasted good.

Food: 4

There was a pile of black olives in the corner of the box that slid off during delivery. A lot of the remaining olives fell off while eating. They were placed on top of the pepperoni and Canadian bacon so there wasn't anything to hold them on the pizza. A little cheese on top would be helpful. Fortunately the pizza tasted good.

Cheese bread is delicious! Customer service is amazing! Love that this is our local pizza joint.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It is not worth it to spend money on pizza here.
Not good, never had such a bad pizza in my life.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

After spending some time in Napoli, IT, it was hard to find local pizza that I could enjoy, until we tried Garlic Jim’s. The pizza dough (regular crust) is very flavorful! Yes, it was the delicious Italian pizza dough that I was missing.
Now Garlic Jim’s is my family’s pizza of choice. I do not recommend the thin crust.

Kid-friendliness: My kids love it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

After spending some time in Napoli, IT, it was hard to find local pizza that I could enjoy, until we tried Garlic Jim’s. The pizza dough (regular crust) is very flavorful! Yes, it was the delicious Italian pizza dough that I was missing.
Now Garlic Jim’s is my family’s pizza of choice. I do not recommend the thin crust.

We just picked up 2 garden salads .the tomatoes cut up were the size of a pea and no mozzarella it was cheddar. 2 pieces of red onion.. what a joke..

Food: 1