Rare Society

13223 39th Ave SE, Mill Creek
(425) 777-4590

Recent Reviews

Paul Slavens

A little pricey but if you want a traditional awesome steak it's the best I have had in this area.

Patrick Gastineau

Cool restaurant, loved the menu

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Block

Decent but pricey for what it is. The cocktails were decent, the steak was good, and the sides were good. Honestly nothing negative but didn't blow my socks off. The location is convenient and it's the best food for sure in that area. Overall a positive experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Frizum “Fresh” Smash

This establishment shows promise, but unfortunately, the appetizers were disappointing. My $100 steak, ordered medium rare, was overcooked and arrived well done. Despite attempting to inform our waitress of the issue, she did not return to our table for 40 minutes. On the bright side, the drinks were exceptional. In the end, a $1000 bill for subpar food and a wonderful atmosphere left us with mixed feelings about our experience.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Danielle W

We came in for my birthday dinner.This was a great experience, and everything tasted amazing.We had a great server named Lexi. She was absolutely amazing and she is so good at what she does. She was extremely knowledgeable about the menu (it was so impressive) and we just really enjoyed her as a server. The girl needs a raise!! ;)We had the steamed clams, broccolini, and mac & cheese. All recommend!They brought out a compliment dessert, we chose the butter cake. I will be back just for that!the Lady Luck cocktail, I need to learn how to make this drink for the summer time! It was so refreshing and had so much flavor.Thanks for a great experience and birthday dinner!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Cake, Steak Was Great

Ashly Yeo

What an amazing dining experience! From the moment we arrived, the wait staff was attentive, courteous and wonderfully professional. We celebrated a belated Valentine's Day dinner and it was memorable all around. The food was superbly made and presented and tasted even better. The portions of the beef tartare was the largest we ever had and the steamed clams were uniquely seasoned and super delicious. I don't have any bread with my meals but the sauce of the clams demanded it and boy, I didn't regret it one bit. The bread was toasted on the same wood grill as the beef so they were covered with the beef tallow - yum! My wife and I shared the executive board and the beef portions though large had the right amount of fat and the beautiful char. So tasty and scrumptious! We ended our meal with the banana foster cheesecake that was a surprise! We can't wait to go back again - highly recommended for dinner dates and special occasions! PS I took one star off for atmosphere because our table was really close to a larger party and also close to the kitchen resulting in the wait staff hitting my head every time they had to get to the larger party. But they always apologize being the courteous professional staff that they are.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak Was Great

MardyEllen P.

Just don't. Esp if no reservations you are treated bad. We waited over an hour plus. And waited and waited. And left

Van Nguyen

My husband and I had dinner here to celebrate Valentines. I ordered Wagyu Denver and the butter cake. The steak was not as I expected, quite bland so I was disappointed. The butter cake is good. However, I got very bad stomach pain and diarrhea after I got home and I'm sure it's from the food here since I had a very early lunch that day. I called the restaurant to complain and the manager basically said it shouldn't be from the food there. He said he would talk to the chef and would call me back but I never received a call back. I paid nearly $300 for dinner there to celebrate Valentines so I'm very upset for this experience. I would not recommend this place ever.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

KL M

Nice place, service was awesome. The food was just ok in my opinion. It seems like they were trying to be too fancy. All of their ingredients seemed to be fresh and of high quality. I personally didn't like it but it doesn't mean you won't. Oh it's a bit loud in there so if you are looking for something quiet or romantic it is not the spot.Wheelchair accessibility: Access is pretty tough here they can make it work, but it's not particularly good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Claudia B.

SERIOUSLY OVERPRICED it's the best way to describe this restaurant. My husband and I went there for Valentine's Day to try it out. We ordered drinks, entrees, sides and dessert and nothing stood out at all. Food tasted ok at most, borderline salty. Way more expensive than your regular steak restaurant. The entrees do not include sides so you have to pay ridiculous prices for mashed potatoes, etc. We have spent much more money on amazing meals, no problem, however the problem here is that the food is not worth the price, not even close. We even felt funny after eating there and I read a lot of reviews of people that have been sick after eating there as well. The service was good though we felt our server was always pushing the most expensive dishes as "a personal favorite" even when we didn't ask for her opinion. The Ambiance felt crowded not only because it was Valentine's Day but because the place is quite small. Overall it just didn't live up to the hype. Please save your money and go to The Keg instead. We won't be returning any time soon.

Gary S.

The ambience is very comfortable. Friendly, professional service. My wife loves lobster, so, she ordered the whole lobster dinner. She wanted mashed potatoes, but, they were out. Settled for "ok" scalloped potatoes. The lobster was a huge letdown. It was tough and stringy. I tried it since she clearly wasn't enjoying it. On the plus side, the amount of lobster meat was ridiculously small. Less to chew. I ordered the rolls and a side of pulled pork. Together they make delicious sliders. I search out steak tartare. This was not a classic version, plus, it was way over-salted. The third person in our party loved their steak.

Becky B.

Very disappointed and overhyped themselves for fine dining or an up scale steakhouse... they told us 20-30 mins for wait but we ended up waiting over an hour just to be seated. Then when we finally got seated I asked to start with appetizers and she said she can only take my orders all at once... pure laziness... We ordered: the associate steak mix, potatoes, long neck clams, meatballs and steamed clams (for 4 people) The waitress (named Moriah) rudely commented that it wasn't enough we only ordered for two people and "we must have small appetites"... actually I told her we went next door to have some wine and appetizers because they took too long!!! she was annoyingly irritated and pissed we didn't order enough for a good tip I presume but attitude and comment was not necessary which made the rest of the 4 hr dinning experience unpleasant!! Rude waitress, everything took way too long & and steak was chewy. I would never go again because of her !! I would rather spend my $300 elsewhere with better food and service!

Laura H.

The food and drinks are amazing! The oysters Rockafeller and Parker House Rolls are epic. Great service, and a cool vibe. Prices are reasonable for the quality. They have it all!

Sofiya Lyashenko

We absolutely love coming here! It’s just quality food and service. I have nothing negative to say.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Roasted Mushrooms, Brocollini, Parker House Rolls, Butter Cake, Steak Was Great, Buttered Rolls

Monica Carlson

It was good... but not great. For the cost, I guess I expected more. Our service was exceptional, but food was not worth the cost (good, but too expensive)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Parker House Rolls, Ricotta Stuffed Ravioli, Bananas Foster Cheesecake

Load More