They changed something with the pizza. It's definitely not the same sauce as I remember. Definitely doesn't taste as good as I was hoping/remembering. The staff was super friendly and great though. However, rather than driving from Snohomish to Monroe to get Alfy's.. I'll just stay here at get Domino's instead. Too bad it's not the Alfy's pizza that I remember..their sauce was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Karen Pacque
The food was delicious and excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dee Perea
One of the few Alfy's that are left. They still have the salad bar which is great breadsticks are amazing you can't go wrong with the breadsticks. Good pizza too
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kris Whelan
Nice salad bar
Jessie Sherwood
After a long day at work came to get pizza, they forgot my ranch so I reminded them, got home and they made my pizza wrong. Called and complained and they said they could re make it but didn’t offer any form of compensation when I live 15 min away and have to drive back to get it re made. Terrible customer service when they should make it right to the customer. Not interested in going back when I tipped $6 for a $20 order and expected my food to be checked.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Elisabeth Eastman
My experience ordering over the phone was far from pleasant. I really think their staff could learn a thing or two about how to communicate with their customers in a kind and considerate manner. It takes just as much energy to be kind as it does to be rude and impatient.
Neal Hill
Great afternoon
Kylee Bern
Sucks now :( Alfys obviously changed all of their ingredients. Decided to order takeout after a year of not getting to have it. Used to be my favorite but not anymore, crust is more like cardboard and the toppings are somehow flavorless. The main older man looked annoyed that customers came in and tried to order. Half of one of my pizzas didnt have cheese somehow as well. Very sad how this place has turned out, wont be coming back :(
Margaret Eversole
This was a great place to get some pizza to go while spending the night at the hotel next door. Great salad bar and pizza choices.
We had our end of the year football party here. Hundreds of dollars spent to celebrate our young players.
Staff, specifically the older man with a goatee was rude the entire time. He was aware of 11-12 year old boys and immediately said they were being disrespectful by being loud. They accused several parents of stealing from the salad bar because they were using the wrong plate for the salad bar, which they didn’t explain. Our whole party of 50+ had paid for the salad bar. When it was time for our group to leave, it was “Get out” on the dot.
I have been going to Alfy’s long before that dude knew what it was. We were celebrating the youth of the Monroe Community and he clearly didn’t care that we paid a lot of money to be there. He knew several members of our party that had paid for the salad bar and said they were stealing because they used this wrong plate.
Never again. And I will encourage all sports teams to avoid this place. I say that as a Monroe community member for 30 years. This place went wrong.
Amanda Phillips
Salad bar is always stocked, clean and yum!
Kid-friendliness: Lots to do for the kiddos. They have fun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar Side, BBQ Cowboy Pizza with Added Pineapple, Hawaiian Pizza
Lori Strickland
Great salad bar
Vegetarian options: Salad bar or pasta
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
Michael W.
It was a kids birthday. Staff was helpful food was good.
They changed something with the pizza. It's definitely not the same sauce as I remember. Definitely doesn't taste as good as I was hoping/remembering. The staff was super friendly and great though.
However, rather than driving from Snohomish to Monroe to get Alfy's.. I'll just stay here at get Domino's instead. Too bad it's not the Alfy's pizza that I remember..their sauce was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
The food was delicious and excellent customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the few Alfy's that are left. They still have the salad bar which is great breadsticks are amazing you can't go wrong with the breadsticks. Good pizza too
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nice salad bar
After a long day at work came to get pizza, they forgot my ranch so I reminded them, got home and they made my pizza wrong. Called and complained and they said they could re make it but didn’t offer any form of compensation when I live 15 min away and have to drive back to get it re made. Terrible customer service when they should make it right to the customer. Not interested in going back when I tipped $6 for a $20 order and expected my food to be checked.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My experience ordering over the phone was far from pleasant. I really think their staff could learn a thing or two about how to communicate with their customers in a kind and considerate manner. It takes just as much energy to be kind as it does to be rude and impatient.
Great afternoon
Sucks now :( Alfys obviously changed all of their ingredients. Decided to order takeout after a year of not getting to have it. Used to be my favorite but not anymore, crust is more like cardboard and the toppings are somehow flavorless. The main older man looked annoyed that customers came in and tried to order. Half of one of my pizzas didnt have cheese somehow as well. Very sad how this place has turned out, wont be coming back :(
This was a great place to get some pizza to go while spending the night at the hotel next door. Great salad bar and pizza choices.
It's the perfect old school pizzeria!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best tasting pepperoni with green peppers ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had our end of the year football party here. Hundreds of dollars spent to celebrate our young players.
Staff, specifically the older man with a goatee was rude the entire time. He was aware of 11-12 year old boys and immediately said they were being disrespectful by being loud. They accused several parents of stealing from the salad bar because they were using the wrong plate for the salad bar, which they didn’t explain. Our whole party of 50+ had paid for the salad bar. When it was time for our group to leave, it was “Get out” on the dot.
I have been going to Alfy’s long before that dude knew what it was. We were celebrating the youth of the Monroe Community and he clearly didn’t care that we paid a lot of money to be there. He knew several members of our party that had paid for the salad bar and said they were stealing because they used this wrong plate.
Never again. And I will encourage all sports teams to avoid this place. I say that as a Monroe community member for 30 years. This place went wrong.
Salad bar is always stocked, clean and yum!
Kid-friendliness: Lots to do for the kiddos. They have fun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar Side, BBQ Cowboy Pizza with Added Pineapple, Hawaiian Pizza
Great salad bar
Vegetarian options: Salad bar or pasta
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza
It was a kids birthday. Staff was helpful food was good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar Side
Loading...