Alfy's Pizza

19121 US-2, Monroe
(360) 794-7775

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gildardo Jacinto

Great pizza and salad always great service more than 12 years going to lunch time best pizza on town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsay Sweeten

Went there for a b-day party and im trying to run around with 3 kids keeping them from fighting, breaking something, bothering people and what Im pretty sure was the owner was INCREDIBLY rude after I just paid $10 for his subpar salad bar

1)food wasn't that great and was very expensive for trying to be marketed to families

2) wait staff didnt even help in the back area for the party - refilling water, plates, or checking on the 40 people that were back there

3) owner was rude to kids and customers

Will definitely never go back or recommend this place to anyone

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Angela Colley

Love their Salas bar

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G K

Was there celebrating a birthday party. The Staff was very attentive and helpful, was an overall great experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mary Fowlds

Love Alfys. I used to work at the 1 in Lake Stevens, years ago. Miss it. The Alfys in Monroe, had pizza, just like I remember. Thank u to the person behind the pizza that night, I didn't share a single bite. If your in Monroe, eat at Alfys. You ll be happy you did.....

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rory Shipley

This Monroe location is the bomb. Unlike the Marysville location that is not that good of food. And the people working there ARE THE WORST. Never again we eat there

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

David Bajorins

Just had a birthday party here with probably 35 people. Rented out the private room in back. The old bald guy kept yelling at us that the kids are being too loud, and that even though we bought 35 soda cups the children were using the wrong cups to get their Fountain beverages.
We were told to be quiet multiple times.

I get it, kids are loud at birthday parties, but it's a pizzeria with video games. Anyways the service and pizza were great just the old bald guy yelling at us sucked.

Really soured the whole experience, and we'll think twice about going back.

Note to the old bald guy. If people are loud they're having fun and it's a place that people want to be and they'll spend more money and you'll make more money. Don't be such a curmudgeon.

Brandon Skinner

They changed something with the pizza. It's definitely not the same sauce as I remember. Definitely doesn't taste as good as I was hoping/remembering. The staff was super friendly and great though.
However, rather than driving from Snohomish to Monroe to get Alfy's.. I'll just stay here at get Domino's instead. Too bad it's not the Alfy's pizza that I remember..their sauce was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Karen Pacque

The food was delicious and excellent customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dee Perea

One of the few Alfy's that are left. They still have the salad bar which is great breadsticks are amazing you can't go wrong with the breadsticks. Good pizza too

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kris Whelan

Nice salad bar

Jessie Sherwood

After a long day at work came to get pizza, they forgot my ranch so I reminded them, got home and they made my pizza wrong. Called and complained and they said they could re make it but didn’t offer any form of compensation when I live 15 min away and have to drive back to get it re made. Terrible customer service when they should make it right to the customer. Not interested in going back when I tipped $6 for a $20 order and expected my food to be checked.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Elisabeth Eastman

My experience ordering over the phone was far from pleasant. I really think their staff could learn a thing or two about how to communicate with their customers in a kind and considerate manner. It takes just as much energy to be kind as it does to be rude and impatient.

Neal Hill

Great afternoon

Kylee Bern

Sucks now :( Alfys obviously changed all of their ingredients. Decided to order takeout after a year of not getting to have it. Used to be my favorite but not anymore, crust is more like cardboard and the toppings are somehow flavorless. The main older man looked annoyed that customers came in and tried to order. Half of one of my pizzas didnt have cheese somehow as well. Very sad how this place has turned out, wont be coming back :(

Loading...