Is this pizza you should go out of your way to try? No. Will it get the job done if you’re hungry and find yourself in Monroe? YES. Plus, the whole vibe of this place is cool and they carry Poppi, Recess, and Jones sodas in addition to all the standard Coke/Pepsi products. I also appreciate the prominently displayed Pride and “Stop Asian Hate” posters prominently displayed at the entrance.
As others have noted, only the gluten free crust is vegan as the wheat crust contains both sour cream and buttermilk, apparently. They still advertise a “plant based menu coming soon”, so ask for the vegan cheese.
J D
Their garlic knots are the BEST! I order about once a month and I almost always get the Margherita for myself. Try it with olive oil instead of marinara, it will change your life. Fresh ingredients, and a soft Cheesy layer of fresh mozzarella atop a tasty crust. Can't go wrong.
My other favorite is the Teriyaki Chicken <333.
Rest of the family likes the Tye City Classic and the Bearcat pizza.
Canzone wise, I love the steak and mushroom.
P&P may be more expensive than other pizza options in Monroe, but it's well worth it. It's local, uses fresh ingredients, and just plainly tastes better.
Ed Blakely
Friendly people, great food, try the garlic knots!
Ira Moser
Take out only, Pizza is great, courteous and helpful staff!
Nick Torza
This place has incredible pizza! They have great combinations and amazing quality. The crust has a great bite to it. This is not what you’d expect out of a small town shop. This place is a hidden gem. The Garlic Knots are to die for. If you’re looking for a great pizza place, you found it.
J Man
Called and got hung up on. Then I went down there and didn’t mention it. Ordered two mediums and was overcharged. I was charged $48 for 2 medium pizzas. Oh! And it’s within my budget! But I will never be back because you are rude. And I will let people know!!! I’ve eaten out hundreds of times and only leave a review if something sucks.
Austin
Honestly, best pizza in town. Such a great small owned business. The owner advocates for the community and stands for what is right. I love this business so much and highly recommend it.
Shannon Garman
This pizza is overpriced and mediocre.
Meagan Ispas
Went in for the first time today and I will say we will most definitely be coming back! We had the Tye city classic combo off the recommendation of the employee who was super nice and helpful! I only gave it a 4 star for atmosphere because I had original thought by the name you could sit and eat and have a beer but it is take out only. Best pizza I’ve had in years! Will recommend to others! Wish I would have taken a picture of the pizza but it was gone fast! They definitely do not skimp on the toppings and the crust is AMAZING!
Karl VP
Bar none. This place kicks ass. The food is great, the service is phenomenal, and the beer is cold.
Unfriendly staff. Seating uncomfortable. Food was meh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Sandy Rogers
Orgazmic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ghost Hyde
The food here used to be good. I grew up coming here for family pizza nights, but over time, the food has gotten worse. Quite frankly, it's disappointing.
We spent $75 for only 3 items. The dough was tough, the cheese was rubbery, and there were barely any toppings on the pizza, despite paying for them.
The cream cheese in the chocolate calzones was also sour.
I don't find it worth the price, and I won't be returning.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Gryffin Rust
The people here are really and I love the vibe in the place and the music. Good prices the deal we used. Pizza was good too, and the 2 liter is really cheap. Would come back if in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Alex Cervantes
Staff is always fast and friendly! Great selection of pizzas and side's. The wings are also a personal favorite of mine.
Is this pizza you should go out of your way to try? No. Will it get the job done if you’re hungry and find yourself in Monroe? YES. Plus, the whole vibe of this place is cool and they carry Poppi, Recess, and Jones sodas in addition to all the standard Coke/Pepsi products. I also appreciate the prominently displayed Pride and “Stop Asian Hate” posters prominently displayed at the entrance. As others have noted, only the gluten free crust is vegan as the wheat crust contains both sour cream and buttermilk, apparently. They still advertise a “plant based menu coming soon”, so ask for the vegan cheese.
Their garlic knots are the BEST! I order about once a month and I almost always get the Margherita for myself. Try it with olive oil instead of marinara, it will change your life.
Fresh ingredients, and a soft Cheesy layer of fresh mozzarella atop a tasty crust. Can't go wrong.
My other favorite is the Teriyaki Chicken <333.
Rest of the family likes the Tye City Classic and the Bearcat pizza.
Canzone wise, I love the steak and mushroom.
P&P may be more expensive than other pizza options in Monroe, but it's well worth it. It's local, uses fresh ingredients, and just plainly tastes better.
Friendly people, great food, try the garlic knots!
Take out only, Pizza is great, courteous and helpful staff!
This place has incredible pizza! They have great combinations and amazing quality. The crust has a great bite to it. This is not what you’d expect out of a small town shop. This place is a hidden gem. The Garlic Knots are to die for. If you’re looking for a great pizza place, you found it.
Called and got hung up on. Then I went down there and didn’t mention it. Ordered two mediums and was overcharged. I was charged $48 for 2 medium pizzas. Oh! And it’s within my budget! But I will never be back because you are rude. And I will let people know!!! I’ve eaten out hundreds of times and only leave a review if something sucks.
Honestly, best pizza in town. Such a great small owned business. The owner advocates for the community and stands for what is right. I love this business so much and highly recommend it.
This pizza is overpriced and mediocre.
Went in for the first time today and I will say we will most definitely be coming back! We had the Tye city classic combo off the recommendation of the employee who was super nice and helpful! I only gave it a 4 star for atmosphere because I had original thought by the name you could sit and eat and have a beer but it is take out only. Best pizza I’ve had in years! Will recommend to others! Wish I would have taken a picture of the pizza but it was gone fast! They definitely do not skimp on the toppings and the crust is AMAZING!
Bar none. This place kicks ass. The food is great, the service is phenomenal, and the beer is cold.
Restaurantji Recommends
Unfriendly staff. Seating uncomfortable. Food was meh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Orgazmic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food here used to be good. I grew up coming here for family pizza nights, but over time, the food has gotten worse. Quite frankly, it's disappointing.
We spent $75 for only 3 items. The dough was tough, the cheese was rubbery, and there were barely any toppings on the pizza, despite paying for them.
The cream cheese in the chocolate calzones was also sour.
I don't find it worth the price, and I won't be returning.
Food: 1
Service: 3
The people here are really and I love the vibe in the place and the music. Good prices the deal we used. Pizza was good too, and the 2 liter is really cheap. Would come back if in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Staff is always fast and friendly! Great selection of pizzas and side's. The wings are also a personal favorite of mine.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread Knots
Loading...