Really really tasty pizza and calzone! They were super busy prepping for a last minute event but still sat us and I appreciated them being so accommodating. The gluten free crust was awesome and cooked well (too many are way undercooked and doughy, or too crispy - this crust was cooked to the right level). We’ll be back!
Kevin W.
Pretty close to the beach, but I still suggest it you drive for pickup. Normally long line during lunch, pizza is pretty good, smaller that what you get at most pizza shops although.
Greg Davidson
I arrived at the restaurant at 8:30. All I wanted was to order a few pizzas. I was informed that the kitchen was closed. 8:30!! The open sign was still on. The place is OPEN until 9!!!!!!!!. Apparently, not true. I truly enjoy Sullys pizza, but after this experience it’s going to be quite a while before I consider pizza from here. I want to point out that by 8:30 they had the entire kitchen cleaned and shut down. I couldn’t help but notice that the guy that told me this dashed out right behind me while checking his apple watch as if he had another agenda. Poor way to run a business.
Brittney L.
Ok so I read all the reviews for this place and I have to say I was a bit hesitant going but I mean who can pass up a calzone place. I do have to say the service was a bit rough but after starting a conversation with the worker I learned that he was the only person there working so I then understood the frustration behind his work ethic, which I understand from my own food industry working. Now the important part... the calzones were amazing!! So much flavor, very big sized, very filling and definitely recommend!!
Brooke P.
This is sad to write, but I feel like the last few times we have been in l, our experience has been pretty terrible. Only rated a 3 because the food is generally really good...customer service would have been a 1. We love this local business and have really supported them throughout this last few years. However, we have been treated so rudely by, who I believe is the manager. Last time I actually asked if he wanted us to leave because we felt so very unwelcome. Upon entering we said hello, how are you and he pretty much grumbled that it was busy, and we could sit and he would help us when he found the time, but don't expect it to be soon. We get if you are busy and we have a lot of patience as we know places are short staffed these days - but at least make us feel somewhat welcome. He continued to be rude and acted like it was physically painful to serve us. I finally said 'should we just leave?' Things improved a bit after that, but it was really disappointing. We had a simple order, aren't high maintenance customers and he's seen us come in several times. I'm sure we'll go back at some point, but it's going to be a while. We will spend our money where we feel welcome and hope the attitude changes.
Laura Clark
Sully's is always great. The pizza is tasty and the service is friendly. Typically a few good beers on tap too.
Madison Wean
We were in a few Saturdays ago and were warmly greeted by the server. We arrive about 45 minutes before close and were told they did a hard close at 9. No problem for us! We accepted the challenge gleefully knowing we wanted to get a quick dinner! We ordered apps and pizza and each had two drinks and were out the door by 8:55. Mission accomplished and allowed the staff to get out when they wanted to get out by.Great food and drinks as always! Cannot wait to come back for the food.
Mp N.
It was AMAZING!!! The Waiter was amazing, tables clean, food great, even better, the meat lover calzone even said meat lover written in sauce!!!!!!!!!!!
George Safadago
Best well keep secret in Mukilteo. The pizza and salads are awesome. The beer is cold. The atmosphere is warm and perfect. I've been a reoccurring customer since 1996.Takeout: No
Steve K.
Not sure what's going on there but I suspect that when the owner took public office he let this place go. Was there today, sign off, doors open at 2pm. Nobody on site. I walked out and someone walked in and seemed to hide in the building. I left and had lunch down the street at Cabernet and IPA's. Not the first time either. Better figure it out or sell the place to someone who can run it.
The blonde guy overcharged me $6. I guess the restaurant is struggling, or hes going to get a $6 tip. I tip pretty well btw.I had to re request the sauce and ask for Napkins?Oh and the food was a 6/10 the crust of the Calzone was like a crepe, soft, not crispy and crunchy it was wierd. The sauce was non existent, (I requested Xtra sauce).Waste of time and money. Trashed it.
Michael K.
The business owner and their workers are EXTREMELY rude, the food is comparable to that of Walmart microwave pizza. The restaurant is in an abandoned house, don't waste your time or money here for overpriced microwave food.
Kamani Kingdom
Great pizza, good calzones, but kinda dissappinting wings. Was very disappointed to see they serve Marie Calenders pie for $6 a slice. Good service and friendly staff. Pretty standard pre packaged sauce and toppings, but very crispy and light pizza crust.
Jay S.
Great, well-balanced, American style pizza. Not too oily, not too salty, great crust. Tomato sauce isn't too acidic, salty, or overbearing.Location is great, too. Nice little bar for a drink with a couple of friends. If you overeat you can take a 20 minute walk down to the lighthouse.
Nadine Archambault
Damn good pizza, well crafted. They were out of the pie we had ordered, and was contacted immediately and was comp'd another dessert. My bro-in-law and I went to pick up ordered and were able to enjoy a glass of wine and chat with the other customers. Definitely going back!!!
Really really tasty pizza and calzone! They were super busy prepping for a last minute event but still sat us and I appreciated them being so accommodating. The gluten free crust was awesome and cooked well (too many are way undercooked and doughy, or too crispy - this crust was cooked to the right level). We’ll be back!
Pretty close to the beach, but I still suggest it you drive for pickup. Normally long line during lunch, pizza is pretty good, smaller that what you get at most pizza shops although.
I arrived at the restaurant at 8:30. All I wanted was to order a few pizzas. I was informed that the kitchen was closed. 8:30!! The open sign was still on. The place is OPEN until 9!!!!!!!!. Apparently, not true. I truly enjoy Sullys pizza, but after this experience it’s going to be quite a while before I consider pizza from here. I want to point out that by 8:30 they had the entire kitchen cleaned and shut down. I couldn’t help but notice that the guy that told me this dashed out right behind me while checking his apple watch as if he had another agenda. Poor way to run a business.
Ok so I read all the reviews for this place and I have to say I was a bit hesitant going but I mean who can pass up a calzone place. I do have to say the service was a bit rough but after starting a conversation with the worker I learned that he was the only person there working so I then understood the frustration behind his work ethic, which I understand from my own food industry working. Now the important part... the calzones were amazing!! So much flavor, very big sized, very filling and definitely recommend!!
This is sad to write, but I feel like the last few times we have been in l, our experience has been pretty terrible. Only rated a 3 because the food is generally really good...customer service would have been a 1. We love this local business and have really supported them throughout this last few years. However, we have been treated so rudely by, who I believe is the manager. Last time I actually asked if he wanted us to leave because we felt so very unwelcome. Upon entering we said hello, how are you and he pretty much grumbled that it was busy, and we could sit and he would help us when he found the time, but don't expect it to be soon. We get if you are busy and we have a lot of patience as we know places are short staffed these days - but at least make us feel somewhat welcome. He continued to be rude and acted like it was physically painful to serve us. I finally said 'should we just leave?' Things improved a bit after that, but it was really disappointing. We had a simple order, aren't high maintenance customers and he's seen us come in several times. I'm sure we'll go back at some point, but it's going to be a while. We will spend our money where we feel welcome and hope the attitude changes.
Sully's is always great. The pizza is tasty and the service is friendly. Typically a few good beers on tap too.
We were in a few Saturdays ago and were warmly greeted by the server. We arrive about 45 minutes before close and were told they did a hard close at 9. No problem for us! We accepted the challenge gleefully knowing we wanted to get a quick dinner! We ordered apps and pizza and each had two drinks and were out the door by 8:55. Mission accomplished and allowed the staff to get out when they wanted to get out by.Great food and drinks as always! Cannot wait to come back for the food.
It was AMAZING!!! The Waiter was amazing, tables clean, food great, even better, the meat lover calzone even said meat lover written in sauce!!!!!!!!!!!
Best well keep secret in Mukilteo. The pizza and salads are awesome. The beer is cold. The atmosphere is warm and perfect. I've been a reoccurring customer since 1996.Takeout: No
Not sure what's going on there but I suspect that when the owner took public office he let this place go. Was there today, sign off, doors open at 2pm. Nobody on site. I walked out and someone walked in and seemed to hide in the building. I left and had lunch down the street at Cabernet and IPA's. Not the first time either. Better figure it out or sell the place to someone who can run it.
Restaurantji Recommends
The blonde guy overcharged me $6. I guess the restaurant is struggling, or hes going to get a $6 tip. I tip pretty well btw.I had to re request the sauce and ask for Napkins?Oh and the food was a 6/10 the crust of the Calzone was like a crepe, soft, not crispy and crunchy it was wierd. The sauce was non existent, (I requested Xtra sauce).Waste of time and money. Trashed it.
The business owner and their workers are EXTREMELY rude, the food is comparable to that of Walmart microwave pizza. The restaurant is in an abandoned house, don't waste your time or money here for overpriced microwave food.
Great pizza, good calzones, but kinda dissappinting wings. Was very disappointed to see they serve Marie Calenders pie for $6 a slice. Good service and friendly staff. Pretty standard pre packaged sauce and toppings, but very crispy and light pizza crust.
Great, well-balanced, American style pizza. Not too oily, not too salty, great crust. Tomato sauce isn't too acidic, salty, or overbearing.Location is great, too. Nice little bar for a drink with a couple of friends. If you overeat you can take a 20 minute walk down to the lighthouse.
Damn good pizza, well crafted. They were out of the pie we had ordered, and was contacted immediately and was comp'd another dessert. My bro-in-law and I went to pick up ordered and were able to enjoy a glass of wine and chat with the other customers. Definitely going back!!!